The Top Regular Savers Discussion Thread

Kim_13

https://forums.moneysavingexpert.com/discussion/comment/82153336#Comment_82153336

Bad memories of how long Darlington took to resolve the issue. Who were the other miscalculating BS?

bubieyehyeh

My three interest miscalcations this year are Melton, Darlington and Cambridge building societies.

Cambridge initially denied it was wrong, when I pushed back and asked them to look again they finally agreed it was wrong, but took them another week to actually pay the missing interest. They claimed I was the only person affected, but I found that hard to believe.

masonic

https://forums.moneysavingexpert.com/discussion/comment/82153390#Comment_82153390

Some of these societies are quite small, but it stretches credulity that any of them would be adding up interest manually for each customer in such a way that one person could be the victim of a miskeying.

RosieRooBear

On the subject of miscalculating BS’s, for anyone who has the:

Loughborough 5 Year Retirement Saver, both mine and my husband’s accounts were due the yearly interest payment last week. I phoned up so I can update my spreadsheet with the amount, however even though our opening cheques were cleared within a couple days of each other and we only had £0.83 difference in our accounts, my interest was £569.18 (which is right) and my husband’s was £446.69 (clearly wrong). It is being looked into and I’m awaiting a callback. I was waiting to post when I had a resolution but I’m going away for a few days and may not be able to update on here, that’s if I here anything this week 🤷🏼‍♀️. Maybe worthwhile anyone who has this account to phone and request interest payment amount to make sure it’s correct.

Melton RS6, ignored both mine and my husband’s maturing instructions which they should have received mid last week to close and pay into nominated account. Can access my account, interest payment incorrect, but have managed to close the new easy access account they set up. Husband’s account blocked for 24 hours as too many password attempts but guessing it will be the same as mine. Hopefully he can get it sorted by a phonecall this morning before we go away 🤯

bubieyehyeh

https://forums.moneysavingexpert.com/discussion/comment/82153394#Comment_82153394

Indeed I assumed other were affected, but they either hadn't realised, or had queried and accepted what Cambridge said

wmb194

Melton RS I6

I closed the new account at about 6am and have just received the proceeds to my nominated account so at least this was fast. Still light on the missing interest though so I’ve sent a message via the ‘contact us’ page on its website about it.

moneymikey

MELTON RS 6

Hi - I've checked the "Action required" letter received from Melton concerning maturity instructions (dated 11 September 2026).

At the bottom of the page it says:

"It can take up to two working days for us to process your instructions. All withdrawals and closures to your nominated account can also take up to two working days to show in your nominated account, transfers to Building Societies may take longer. The two working days starts from the day after the fixed end date."

LZC

Nationwide

Is it possible to open a new RS the same day as the old one matures?

masonic

https://forums.moneysavingexpert.com/discussion/comment/82153429#Comment_82153429

Yes, closure seems to work, but withdrawals do not. I was going to keep it open to receive the missing interest, but since I cannot get any money out of it I shall proceed with closing mine.

SonOfPearl

https://forums.moneysavingexpert.com/discussion/comment/82153459#Comment_82153459

No, you have to wait until the next day.