The Top Easy Access Savings Discussion Area

invuk

Pretty dumb question but hopefully someone can answer it for me. I currently have a Tandem instant saver paying 5% and have just applied for a Cahoot simple saver which pays 5.12%. Cahoot only pays 5% interest if interest is paid monthly. Does this mean they both pay the same if monthly interest is chosen? 

poppystar

soulsaver said:

BlackthornU said:

Beehive Money 5.2% NLA

Source...?
Still available to me when logged in - which may mean limited to existing customers?

Not there for new customers. Sadly I left it until today to apply🙁

refluxer

invuk said:

Pretty dumb question but hopefully someone can answer it for me. I currently have a Tandem instant saver paying 5% and have just applied for a Cahoot simple saver which pays 5.12%. Cahoot only pays 5% interest if interest is paid monthly. Does this mean they both pay the same if monthly interest is chosen? 

Tandem pays 4.89% gross (monthly) which equates to 5.00% AER.
Cahoot pays 5.00% gross (when the monthly option is chosen) which equates to 5.12% AER

Whether you withdraw the interest or leave it in the account to compound, you'll get more with the Cahoot account. 

flaneurs_lobster

invuk said:

Pretty dumb question but hopefully someone can answer it for me. I currently have a Tandem instant saver paying 5% and have just applied for a Cahoot simple saver which pays 5.12%. Cahoot only pays 5% interest if interest is paid monthly. Does this mean they both pay the same if monthly interest is chosen? 

Both Tandem and Cahoot (and every other lender/product) will quote an APR to allow rates to be compared on a like-for-like basis. The Cahoot 5% figure is the rate if the interest is paid away each month (aka the gross interest rate). If the interest were left to compound in the account then the effective rate is 5.12% over a year (the Annual Percentage Rate and the gross rate for the annual interest product).

I haven't looked up the numbers for the Tandem product. 

invuk

Thanks guys really appreciate the time and effort for all the responses  Just one last question, if you choose monthly over 12-month interest does it always work out the same or do you get more if you choose the annual option?

allegro120

invuk said:

Thanks guys really appreciate the time and effort for all the responses  Just one last question, if you choose monthly over 12-month interest does it always work out the same or do you get more if you choose the annual option?

It works out the same.

intalex

allegro120 said:

invuk said:

Thanks guys really appreciate the time and effort for all the responses  Just one last question, if you choose monthly over 12-month interest does it always work out the same or do you get more if you choose the annual option?

It works out the same.

Only if you keep the funds in there for the full 12 months, if you were to "exit" i.e. close down the account and have the accrued interest paid, then the annual option would yield a tiny bit more than the monthly option.

To give you an idea of how tiny, by my workings, a maximum possible difference of 0.0305% of the principal would be yielded if "exiting" at exactly the mid-point of the 12-month period. At a principal equal to the £85k FSCS limit this would be a maximum possible difference of £25.89.

So unless you need the monthly interest to be accessible (e.g. as a supplementary income, to feed a regular saver, etc), it might be slightly better to go with annual interest on an easy access account, and then:
- "exiting" immediately if a better interest rate comes along, and then re-apply the same logic with a new account
- "exiting" at the precise 6-month point if the same interest rate is available in a new account
- keeping the account going if the interest rate remains better than anything else available in the market

soulsaver

poppystar said:

soulsaver said:

BlackthornU said:

Beehive Money 5.2% NLA

Source...?
Still available to me when logged in - which may mean limited to existing customers?

Not there for new customers. Sadly I left it until today to apply🙁

Nor existing now, NLA when logged in. 

martinm1

intalex said:

allegro120 said:

invuk said:

Thanks guys really appreciate the time and effort for all the responses  Just one last question, if you choose monthly over 12-month interest does it always work out the same or do you get more if you choose the annual option?

It works out the same.

Only if you keep the funds in there for the full 12 months, if you were to "exit" i.e. close down the account and have the accrued interest paid, then the annual option would yield a tiny bit more than the monthly option.

To give you an idea of how tiny, by my workings, a maximum possible difference of 0.0305% of the principal would be yielded if "exiting" at exactly the mid-point of the 12-month period. At a principal equal to the £85k FSCS limit this would be a maximum possible difference of £25.89.

So unless you need the monthly interest to be accessible (e.g. as a supplementary income, to feed a regular saver, etc), it might be slightly better to go with annual interest on an easy access account, and then:
- "exiting" immediately if a better interest rate comes along, and then re-apply the same logic with a new account
- "exiting" at the precise 6-month point if the same interest rate is available in a new account
- keeping the account going if the interest rate remains better than anything else available in the market

I dont thinks that's true, both will yield exactly the same over any period, as long as the interest is not taken out.  I believe your workings are based on the interest rate quoted for monthly interest, but the bank has it just rounded to 2dp, whereas in reality it is many dp.

masonic

martinm1 said:

intalex said:

allegro120 said:

invuk said:

Thanks guys really appreciate the time and effort for all the responses  Just one last question, if you choose monthly over 12-month interest does it always work out the same or do you get more if you choose the annual option?

It works out the same.

Only if you keep the funds in there for the full 12 months, if you were to "exit" i.e. close down the account and have the accrued interest paid, then the annual option would yield a tiny bit more than the monthly option.

To give you an idea of how tiny, by my workings, a maximum possible difference of 0.0305% of the principal would be yielded if "exiting" at exactly the mid-point of the 12-month period. At a principal equal to the £85k FSCS limit this would be a maximum possible difference of £25.89.

So unless you need the monthly interest to be accessible (e.g. as a supplementary income, to feed a regular saver, etc), it might be slightly better to go with annual interest on an easy access account, and then:
- "exiting" immediately if a better interest rate comes along, and then re-apply the same logic with a new account
- "exiting" at the precise 6-month point if the same interest rate is available in a new account
- keeping the account going if the interest rate remains better than anything else available in the market

I dont thinks that's true, both will yield exactly the same over any period, as long as the interest is not taken out.  I believe your workings are based on the interest rate quoted for monthly interest, but the bank has it just rounded to 2dp, whereas in reality it is many dp.

Actually it is true. For a static balance, the annual option gives a linear increase in accrued interest over the whole year, while the monthly option starts at a lower gross rate and has a slight upward curve over time (due to compounding). So for accounts with the same AER and monthly vs annual interest, over periods of less than a year you'll earn slightly more from the annual option as you'll be on the shallower end of the curve. The only time annual vs monthly with the same AER earn exactly the same is when saving over exactly 1 year (or 2 years etc), as this is the point when monthly catches up with annual. Any fractions of a year will lead to a difference.

Remember that interest accrues daily at a rate of 1/365 x gross rate on the closing balance of the account, and the gross rate is different between monthly and annual variants. No amount of extra precision will make them the same.

Here's a table and plot of the relative outcomes when closing the respective accounts on the first of each month (based on Paragon double access 5.16%), you can only just see the gap between the lower blue curve and upper red line in the plot: