new bmw x1 or land rover evoke?

angela_stone

which is the better car husband prefers x1 I prefer other advice most welcome.

neilmcl

Better car in what respects?

What do you need it for?

Personally I don't see the point of an X1, especially when the standard 1 series comes with an X-drive option. In fact I wouldn't go for either, there are plenty of more accomplished "soft roaders" out there to choose from.

dannyrst

depends what you mean by "better car".

Herzlos

Who is using it most?

The Evoke should be, in pretty much any regard, the better car.

tykesi

Evoque*...

Iceweasel

Better?

That's in impossible question, without knowing what you are going to use the car for, and where you are going to go with it.

First off - why 4x4?

almillar

Just for starters - look at the boots - from memory the X1's is pretty darn small, as is rear space, but also, I think it's significantly smaller than an Evoque which I think is more X3 sized.

dannyrst

almillar wrote: »

Just for starters - look at the boots - from memory the X1's is pretty darn small, as is rear space, but also, I think it's significantly smaller than an Evoque which I think is more X3 sized.

So the X1 is better at having a small boot. :rotfl:

burlington6

Bought my wife an Evoque earlier this year. The pos has spent more time in the dealer than we've owned it. They have had serious engine issues.

On the plus side, they've offered to give us the new model when it's out because they can'f fix the engine problem. ( it had done about 600 miles from new )

I'll probably ask for my money back though

angela_stone

me, as a woman just prefer the styling.

angela_stone

oh dear that does not sound promising.