Ready, steady… save!
You don’t need a chart to join in. Here are 2 ways to record your savings:
1. Cross it off
Pop a chart into your first post. Saved an amount? Cross it out! Read more »
£0.01 £0.02 £0.03
2. Write it down
Skip the chart and add updates to your first post. Read more »
“Another +£3 saved today. Go me!”
Use +£ before each new saving so it counts towards your total.
We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.
This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Economy 10 & Smart Meters
Comments
-
update to this saga. Octopus say the Aclara meter I have is the only model to require 2 MPANs, (which is basically what you explained to me Scot39) so they coming to exchange the meter to a different brand 5T meter which should do the trick, close one mpan down and get me onto the snug tariff. I have to say I have been very impressed with them in the 2 weeks I have been with them. A million miles away from EDF experience.
6 -
A little off topic for OP here but just FYI
Octopus might not have come across them - but the Aclara is not the only twin element being fitted - that I have come across in this forum.
The users wids23 for instance posted this photo of an installed liberty 116 - and I believe the 2E/S4 - the two means its the twin element version. And the 4 - means it has 7 ports. 3 siwtched auxiliary supplies.
It's iirc the more variable auxiliary port smets2 version of their old 7 port only smets1 liberty 114.
https://www.securemeters.com/product/smart-meter-electricity/liberty-116/
Think the tag says fitted in June 2025.
For some reason dont seem to be able to open the original thread when tried clicking on the date.
There may be other models available - but iirc the SP user who posted also had the Aclara1422.
0 -
they’ve switched me to a Kaifa M120B let’s see what happens
further update. Day 1, 2 meter readings, and water came on overnight as expected, so all looks to be sorted. Basically EDF weren’t bothered, Octopus been very helpful.
edit further update, they need to deactivate one of the mpans before moving me onto snug. Not had any meter reads from new meter feed through to the app, although it is working as expected, not had a bill yet either. Pretty chilled though as their communication has been good2 -
update on this.
octopus have been brilliant, changed the meter and getting 2 readings now as expected. Have now switched to Snug tariff, but have one question for those on it.When I look at the half hour readings and costs info you can download from the octopus website, it looks spot on and as I would expect. However, when I look at the two readings on the meter, it doesn’t tally. Going by the meter readings it appears that in the last 2 days I have used 32kWh peak (data shows 17kwh which I would expect) and off peak water/heat meter says 19kwh, whereas data says 34kwh, again which I would expect.
When I look at the initial bill they sent for first 2 days of snug they just show a kWh usage number and don’t include the normal difference between 2 meter readings multiplied by the rate. Is that how you’d expect to see it? I don’t think the meter is switching at the times outside of 0030-0700 when they are boosting the heat/water to the off peak rate, yet their data and their billing does appear to be correct.
So far it appears 0030-0700, 1500-1600 and 2300-2330 are being billed at the off peak rate, which is hour more than I expected, so that’s a plus
,
0 -
On Snug, the peak and off peak meter readings are surplus to requirement. You are now on a Time Of Use tariff and therefore billed based on the price and units used within each 30 minute window rather than what the meter registers say.
1 -
Yeah that’s what I thought, thanks for confirming
0 -
The Octopus (and I upset other forumites by calling them this) core off peak guaranteed hours are 0030 to 0630 and the 1 hr in afternoon (15:00-1600 - but iirc some posts suggested that slot had changed with DST).
Can you share your app 1/2 hrly rate / timing charts - as Ive never seen them extend the 1hr afternoon to 1.5 hrs in past threads.
Heres an example from one user in another thread showing the potential variations - it really wont necessarily be the same every night - so be wary about self timed devices - likely best kept to core timings - when energy is cheap they give more 9.5p night slots.
The two charts their from that user show different timings on different days
On one the off peak is on 2300 0000 then peak for 1/2 hr - then 0030 as core - then the 1 hr afternoon
On the other its on from 0000 rather than 0030 start of core.
The extra slots in advance are not uncommon - and you could even get more than the 8 hours on occassions - they have some way off changing timing on in theory a daily basis.
And note the user was telling Octopus only to power his NSH / HW for 3 or 4.5 hours - which explains why power use doesnt switch on edges with unit rates - but vienna28s consumption is or would have been charged at night rates for the 7.5/8 hours.
A feature I believe is still supported - and if you have old lossy heaters like mine - might tend to see them charge later than say on e7 - when they would charge from 0030 to say 0230 on my typical winter usage - my 3 NSH average around 14kWh per day - so 2 hrs average charge).
The old register 1 and 2 readings are I suspect still operating on your old fixed e7 legacy timings - which remain as a fall back if the OTA dynamic settings don't work. Your registers maybe are only nearest kWh - which could also introduce rounding errors - but at least at this time of year - GMT vs DST shouldnt be complicating the mix.
So things like the 1 hr afternoon boost - well the registers will always count that as day rate not off-peak.
If your old or new Octopus E7 was 0030-0730 (or set there by Octopus - it is there smart e7 default according to one faq page) - an advance of night window - like the 1/2 hr in your example - or the hour in the vienna28 chart - again would be mis-allocated by registers - counted as peak not off peak.
The same would be true for last hour (0630 to 0730 - would be billed as off peak by registers not peak)
And again any non zero randomised offset type disparity (in the vienna28 - his ALCS offset by 7 mins) also causes issues.
Snug itself is charged using the 1/2 hourly data and rates - as made clear in the T&Cs for all of their smart TOU tariffs. (It used to be repeated in the Snug specific section - but either I missed it on a quick scan or it isnt anymore)
The key thing is that any extra hours outside core (0030 0630 and say 1500-1600) are also charged at night rate - 9.5p when Octopus schedule them.
0 -
sorry @Scot_39 that was a typo on my behalf 1500-1600 in afternoon then 2300-2330 at night are the additional times so far for first 4 days of being on snug. I fully understand now, have to say been very impressed by octopus compared to EDF
1 -
Glad your getting the 1 hr as promised - some had issues around that slot for a while but got the 9p night rates after swapping.
0
Categories
- All Categories
- 356K Banking & Borrowing
- 255K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 456.3K Spending & Discounts
- 248.5K Work, Benefits & Business
- 606.2K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 179.1K Life & Family
- 264K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards

