Hanley Economic Building Society BRANCH SAVER

bundoran

happybagger said:

For info email received:
Rare for an account to become closed issue AND for existing account holders not be allowed to continue to operate it normally.

The Branch Saver account will become a closed issue, and the balance of the account cannot be increased after 4pm on 8 October 2023.

  You will not be able to deposit or replace any withdrawn funds into your account after this date.

Yes. The only other instances of this I've ever come across is with Leeds Building Society, where specific account terms often include: "The account may be closed for further deposits at any time. This will be done on a minimum of 30 days’ written notice, after which you will not be able to deposit further funds."

For example their currently available Limited Issue Online Access Account Issue 47 paying 4.4% interest has it.

Strangely the Issue 43 Regular Saver that runs for 2 years also has it. It seems very odd that a regular saver has a condition saying that they might stop you paying money in during the term.

HHUK

10_66 said:

Approximately how long did it take from when you sent your letter (did you send it via their freepost address) to when you received the FP from them, please?

My experience timescale-was was similar to drphila's.
I wanted to find out how a long a request for a Faster Payments withdrawal requested by post would take to process.
I sent a signed letter asking for a withdrawal of £100 to the Freepost address, together with my passbook, on a Thursday, and the money was received in my bank account on the Friday of the following week.
The updated passbook was received a couple of days later, with a signed slip confirming the withdrawal, and the fact that there would be a charge of £10 for the Faster Payments service.
I had forgotten that requests for a FP withdrawal of <£500 attract this charge, and am not sure when it will show in my HEBS account.

ForumUser7

HHUK said:

10_66 said:

Approximately how long did it take from when you sent your letter (did you send it via their freepost address) to when you received the FP from them, please?

My experience timescale-was was similar to drphila's.
I wanted to find out how a long a request for a Faster Payments withdrawal requested by post would take to process.
I sent a signed letter asking for a withdrawal of £100 to the Freepost address, together with my passbook, on a Thursday, and the money was received in my bank account on the Friday of the following week.
The updated passbook was received a couple of days later, with a signed slip confirming the withdrawal, and the fact that there would be a charge of £10 for the Faster Payments service.
I had forgotten that requests for a FP withdrawal of <£500 attract this charge, and am not sure when it will show in my HEBS account.

Shame about the £10 fee. Would’ve been nice if they gave you a courtesy call to ensure you were expecting this.

Bridlington1

I can't seem to see it mentioned anywhere but for those choosing to make withdrawals by transfer to a HEBS instant access account. I've discovered their systems will let you reduce the balance on the instant access account down to 1p, I don't know whether or not they'll let you keep the balance at 1p indefinitely though. Withdrawing my initial deposit from the instant saver on Thursday was reasonably quick to be fair, I requested the withdrawal around 5:30am, the money was debited immediately and was in my nominated account when I checked at around 1pm the same day. Also to satisfy my own curiosity I've discovered they let you make 1p deposits into it by debit card.

gwapenut

I achieved similar with The Cambridge a few years back, and got a very friendly phone call a month or so later asking me to restore the account to its minimum level.

refluxer

Bridlington1 said:

I can't seem to see it mentioned anywhere but for those choosing to make withdrawals by transfer to a HEBS instant access account. I've discovered their systems will let you reduce the balance on the instant access account down to 1p, I don't know whether or not they'll let you keep the balance at 1p indefinitely though. Withdrawing my initial deposit from the instant saver on Thursday was reasonably quick to be fair, I requested the withdrawal around 5:30am, the money was debited immediately and was in my nominated account when I checked at around 1pm the same day. Also to satisfy my own curiosity I've discovered they let you make 1p deposits into it by debit card.

Apologies if you've mentioned this before but, as withdrawing to a HEBS Instant Access account presumably doesn't get around the need to visit a branch or post off the Branch Saver passbook to make a withdrawal, how does opening one help with the process ? Just curious  

Bridlington1

refluxer said:

Bridlington1 said:

I can't seem to see it mentioned anywhere but for those choosing to make withdrawals by transfer to a HEBS instant access account. I've discovered their systems will let you reduce the balance on the instant access account down to 1p, I don't know whether or not they'll let you keep the balance at 1p indefinitely though. Withdrawing my initial deposit from the instant saver on Thursday was reasonably quick to be fair, I requested the withdrawal around 5:30am, the money was debited immediately and was in my nominated account when I checked at around 1pm the same day. Also to satisfy my own curiosity I've discovered they let you make 1p deposits into it by debit card.

Apologies if you've mentioned this before but, as withdrawing to a HEBS Instant Access account presumably doesn't get around the need to visit a branch or post off the Branch Saver passbook to make a withdrawal, how does opening one help with the process ? Just curious  

It's mainly if you want to withdraw more than £10k in one month for whatever reason. You can only withdraw up to £10k by faster payment each day, but there is no such limit for internal transfers so if you wanted to withdraw say £20k, you could transfer the £20k to the instant access account without penalty, then withdraw £10k from the instant access account to your nominated account on two consecutive days to avoid faffing about with cheques.

refluxer

Bridlington1 said:

refluxer said:

Bridlington1 said:

I can't seem to see it mentioned anywhere but for those choosing to make withdrawals by transfer to a HEBS instant access account. I've discovered their systems will let you reduce the balance on the instant access account down to 1p, I don't know whether or not they'll let you keep the balance at 1p indefinitely though. Withdrawing my initial deposit from the instant saver on Thursday was reasonably quick to be fair, I requested the withdrawal around 5:30am, the money was debited immediately and was in my nominated account when I checked at around 1pm the same day. Also to satisfy my own curiosity I've discovered they let you make 1p deposits into it by debit card.

Apologies if you've mentioned this before but, as withdrawing to a HEBS Instant Access account presumably doesn't get around the need to visit a branch or post off the Branch Saver passbook to make a withdrawal, how does opening one help with the process ? Just curious  

It's mainly if you want to withdraw more than £10k in one month for whatever reason. You can only withdraw up to £10k by faster payment each day, but there is no such limit for internal transfers so if you wanted to withdraw say £20k, you could transfer the £20k to the instant access account without penalty, then withdraw £10k from the instant access account to your nominated account on two consecutive days to avoid faffing about with cheques.

Ah, OK - I presumed there would be a good reason for it. That's useful to know, thanks.

drphila

It's mainly if you want to withdraw more than £10k in one month for whatever reason. You can only withdraw up to £10k by faster payment each day, but there is no such limit for internal transfers so if you wanted to withdraw say £20k, you could transfer the £20k to the instant access account without penalty, then withdraw £10k from the instant access account to your nominated account on two consecutive days to avoid faffing about with cheques.

You're only allowed one withdrawal per MONTH if you don't want to pay a penalty

drphila

Bridlington1 said:

I can't seem to see it mentioned anywhere but for those choosing to make withdrawals by transfer to a HEBS instant access account. I've discovered their systems will let you reduce the balance on the instant access account down to 1p, I don't know whether or not they'll let you keep the balance at 1p indefinitely though. Withdrawing my initial deposit from the instant saver on Thursday was reasonably quick to be fair, I requested the withdrawal around 5:30am, the money was debited immediately and was in my nominated account when I checked at around 1pm the same day. Also to satisfy my own curiosity I've discovered they let you make 1p deposits into it by debit card.

Nice workaround, thanks. Whether or not they'll let you keep it at 1p I don't know but in any case the terms actually say it only has to be £1 anyway.