We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.

This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.

📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
The Forum now has a brand new text editor, adding a bunch of handy features to use when creating posts. Read more in our how-to guide

BITCOIN

1126127129131132344

Comments

  • Zola.
    Zola. Posts: 2,204 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Photogenic Name Dropper
    Money is money yep, 1p isn't £1000 though...
    It's still a pretty ballsy move if he actually goes through with it.. when most on the FIREUK forum(s) will be mainly doing the standard index fund investing strategy for the most part. He did set himself up for the trolls with the semantics of the title, I don't disagree.. 
  • Zola.
    Zola. Posts: 2,204 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Photogenic Name Dropper
    edited 25 November 2021 at 11:35AM
    Here is a pretty cool little site for watching new transactions being grouped together before being confirmed in the next block, on the base layer.

    This is generally every ten minutes, something which Bitcoin has been doing 24/7 non-stop since 2009. 

    https://bits.monospace.live/

  • adindas
    adindas Posts: 6,856 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper
    edited 26 November 2021 at 12:33AM

    "There are legitimate ways for people to regularly return rates close to 30% with little risk (aside from the lack of regulation/platform) primarily related to arbitrage"

    I cannot speak on behalf of the OP but I have read many information including on MSE that in the past people could easily get that return using Match betting Arbitrage. If you google it there are tons of info about this

    But there is a limit to define, once you get caught you will be banned and you will need to move to another platform. There is only limited Match betting platforms outthere. So once you exhaust all of them that will be the end of the game.

  • adindas
    adindas Posts: 6,856 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper
    edited 27 November 2021 at 12:42PM

    Everyone knows that staples, food have value because you could eat it. Some people on here said that BTC do not value, a few people are referring to what Warren Buffet and Charlie Munger are saying

     

    The discussion has been going on and on and have turned to become the dialogue of the deaf. On one hand people see the value of BTC on traditional ways such as staples, food. On the other hand, other people see the value in non-traditional way, for instance to see what blockchain could do in the future to increase efficiency, smart contract, land certificate to distribute wealth free from politics and government intervention, etc. Keep in mind efficiency could always be converted to a more tangible values in term of money equivalent. That is the way the industrial revolution changes the life and creating wealth. This is the way Amazon, FB (Meta Platform) creating value. In the past how much would it cost you to send message in no time, to get item, videos on your living room in no time ?? Invaluable, if it was possible to have it in the past. This is unrealised value that later become a reality that some people can not see. What is the current value of gene therapy, mapping, sequencing currently doing nothing to human. But what if they have turned out to be able to cure deseases which is currently incurable ??

    Now those who think that BTC do not have value (e.g., £0). This is a teasing test.

    If you offer to someone to choose either a voucher of full English breakfast value of £25 or one bitcoin (£0 based on some people on this thread), which one do you think the ordinary people will be chosing ??? Keep in mind you could not eat BTC but you could sell it for about US$50,000 and there are a lot of other people want to buy it.

    I believe it is only the people who never read the news those who still believe that the flat is earth will choose the full english breakfast. The other people who might think they have missed the boat and in no way they would want to buy BTC at the current price but would like to have them if someone was offering it for £25. rofl

  • Section62
    Section62 Posts: 10,944 Forumite
    10,000 Posts Fifth Anniversary Name Dropper
    edited 27 November 2021 at 2:21PM
    adindas said:

    If you offer to someone to choose either a voucher of full English breakfast value of £25 or one bitcoin (£0 based on some people on this thread), which one do you think the ordinary people will be chosing ??? Keep in mind you could not eat BTC but you could sell it for about US$50,000 and there are a lot of other people want to buy it.
    This is very much a false dichotomy.  The two things are not comparable.  $50,000 is clearly worth more than £25, but then you could say the same thing about other options.

    Which would you choose, £25 full English breakfast voucher, or €44,000?  A £25 full English breakfast voucher, or 24,333 BT.A shares?

    At the point of making the bargain one side is very clearly worth very substantially more.  The only people who might be tempted by the £25 full English breakfast voucher might be those desperate for food, or those who make a decision that the breakfast is worth more to them personally at this point in time than the potential wealth offered by the alternatives.

    It isn't clear what point you were trying to make, but you aren't making an argument in favour of Bitcoin. Anyone who isn't starving hungry would be better off taking the Bitcoin and then selling it immediately, and using some of the proceeds to buy breakfast.

    So we could add to the equation that someone might decline the Bitcoin offer because they don't believe they could turn it into the asset/currency of their choice quickly enough to still end up with a value of £25.  You are presenting a binary (no pun intended) choice when really there are many choices and outcomes.

    A gift or payment of a certain value at a particular moment in time is not 'proof' of something's worth vs a different thing.

    Moreover, what "ordinary people" would spend £25 on a full English breakfast?  Ones who need to do some MSE learning perhaps?

    adindas said:

    I believe it is only the people who never read the news those who still believe that the flat is earth will choose the full english breakfast. The other people who might think they have missed the boat and in no way they would want to buy BTC at the current price but would like to have them if someone was offering it for £25. rofl
    You keep on about 'flat earthers' and what Warren Buffet and Charlie Munger say - but nobody in these threads is making the comments you are talking about.

    Nobody.

    It is a really strange way to make an argument in favour of Bitcoin/Crypto.... what is it you are hoping to achieve here?

    In the meantime it is coming across as if you are trying to insult other non-specific forum members.  If you have a point to make it would be good if you could make it... because going on about 'flat earthers' and Warren Buffet and Charlie Munger are giving the discussion a bit of a toxic vibe, which doesn't do any of us any good.

    Edit: "dialogue of the deaf" is also insulting and derogatory, please find an alternative expression in future. Thanks.
  • adindas
    adindas Posts: 6,856 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper
    edited 27 November 2021 at 5:18PM
    Section62 said:
    adindas said:

    If you offer to someone to choose either a voucher of full English breakfast value of £25 or one bitcoin (£0 based on some people on this thread), which one do you think the ordinary people will be chosing ??? Keep in mind you could not eat BTC but you could sell it for about US$50,000 and there are a lot of other people want to buy it.
    This is very much a false dichotomy.  The two things are not comparable.  $50,000 is clearly worth more than £25, but then you could say the same thing about other options.

    Which would you choose, £25 full English breakfast voucher, or €44,000?  A £25 full English breakfast voucher, or 24,333 BT.A shares?

    At the point of making the bargain one side is very clearly worth very substantially more.  The only people who might be tempted by the £25 full English breakfast voucher might be those desperate for food, or those who make a decision that the breakfast is worth more to them personally at this point in time than the potential wealth offered by the alternatives.

    It isn't clear what point you were trying to make, but you aren't making an argument in favour of Bitcoin. Anyone who isn't starving hungry would be better off taking the Bitcoin and then selling it immediately, and using some of the proceeds to buy breakfast.

    So we could add to the equation that someone might decline the Bitcoin offer because they don't believe they could turn it into the asset/currency of their choice quickly enough to still end up with a value of £25.  You are presenting a binary (no pun intended) choice when really there are many choices and outcomes.

    A gift or payment of a certain value at a particular moment in time is not 'proof' of something's worth vs a different thing.

    Moreover, what "ordinary people" would spend £25 on a full English breakfast?  Ones who need to do some MSE learning perhaps?

    adindas said:

    I believe it is only the people who never read the news those who still believe that the flat is earth will choose the full english breakfast. The other people who might think they have missed the boat and in no way they would want to buy BTC at the current price but would like to have them if someone was offering it for £25. rofl
    You keep on about 'flat earthers' and what Warren Buffet and Charlie Munger say - but nobody in these threads is making the comments you are talking about.

    Nobody.

    It is a really strange way to make an argument in favour of Bitcoin/Crypto.... what is it you are hoping to achieve here?

    In the meantime it is coming across as if you are trying to insult other non-specific forum members.  If you have a point to make it would be good if you could make it... because going on about 'flat earthers' and Warren Buffet and Charlie Munger are giving the discussion a bit of a toxic vibe, which doesn't do any of us any good.

    Edit: "dialogue of the deaf" is also insulting and derogatory, please find an alternative expression in future. Thanks.
    Well, the point I make here is that there are some people said BTC does not have any value, blindly following WB and CM opinion in the previous poster that I have shown.
    So, in my previous post I propose a test, to choose either a full English breakfast voucher with value of £25.00 or one bitcoin BTC. To me and some people on this thread believe BTC has value although is not the value in traditional way like food that every people could understand.So, for those whose said BTC is worthless no value the  BTC should be valued at £0.00.
    Everyone could see £25 is definitely bigger than £0. So, for those who think BTC is worthless, does not have any value and you have been presented that choice, you should have chosen a full English breakfast voucher with value of  £25. I fail to understand what is derogatory here when it is just a logical comparison, testing.
  • IvanOpinion
    IvanOpinion Posts: 22,131 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 10,000 Posts Name Dropper Combo Breaker
    OMG Mr Goxx is dead, how will people know when to buy and sell crypto?
    On the plus side Mrs Roxx, a beloved sea cucumber has applied for the job.
    I don't care about your first world problems; I have enough of my own!
  • HHarry
    HHarry Posts: 1,040 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper
    adindas said:
    Everyone could see £25 is definitely bigger than £0. So, for those who think BTC is worthless, does not have any value and you have been presented that choice, you should have chosen a full English breakfast voucher with value of  £25. I fail to understand what is derogatory here when it is just a logical comparison, testing.
    Bitcoin has a price, currently around £40k, and so yes anyone would take the Bitcoin over breakfast.

    But does Bitcoin have ‘value’. I don’t think so in the traditional sense like shares (future earnings) or gold (industrial usage).  There may be some uses for Blockchain technology in the future, but does that mean that Bitcoin itself has value?

    (And my honest answer is that I don’t understand whether Bitcoin is an integral part of the usefulness of the blockchain, or just an easy to use function that shows how the system works)
  • Section62
    Section62 Posts: 10,944 Forumite
    10,000 Posts Fifth Anniversary Name Dropper
    adindas said:

    Well, the point I make here is that there are some people said BTC does not have any value, blindly following WB and CM opinion in the previous poster that I have shown.
    This is the problem.  You are failing to accept and acknowledge that people can form and hold their own opinions independently of others.  It is insulting to suggest that other forum members are not so capable, by suggesting or implying that they are 'blindly following' some famous person you clearly have a very negative view of.

    adindas said:

    So, in my previous post I propose a test, to choose either a full English breakfast voucher with value of £25.00 or one bitcoin BTC. To me and some people on this thread believe BTC has value although is not the value in traditional way like food that every people could understand.So, for those whose said BTC is worthless no value the  BTC should be valued at £0.00.

    Everyone could see £25 is definitely bigger than £0. So, for those who think BTC is worthless, does not have any value and you have been presented that choice, you should have chosen a full English breakfast voucher with value of  £25.
    It's a false test though.  It doesn't prove what you think it does.

    Also, the logic being used by the people who say Bitcoin has no value applies in equal terms to the "full English breakfast voucher".  The voucher is worthless if the restaurant isn't open when you want to use it, or the business has gone bankrupt.  To comply with the law in certain cases the voucher might have the words "Coupon value 0.01p" (or similar) printed on it, which also makes the point that you don't have £25 in your hands.  If you can't exchange the voucher for a breakfast then you have a piece of paper worth whatever the rate is for recycled paper.

    And someone opting to take the Bitcoin instead of the voucher faces exactly the same risk, without even the benefit of a piece of recyclable paper.

    The choice between them becomes a judgement of which option involves higher risks of ending up with zero value for the bargain.
    adindas said:

    I fail to understand what is derogatory here when it is just a logical comparison, testing.
    The phrase you use implies that people who are hearing impaired (or 'deaf') are incapable of having meaningful dialogue.  Which is obviously untrue, and should be self-evidently so when the dialogue going on in this forum is entirely in written (and graphical) form.

  • adindas said:

    Everyone knows that staples, food have value because you could eat it. Some people on here said that BTC do not value, a few people are referring to what Warren Buffet and Charlie Munger are saying

     

    The discussion has been going on and on and have turned to become the dialogue of the deaf. On one hand people see the value of BTC on traditional ways such as staples, food. On the other hand, other people see the value in non-traditional way, for instance to see what blockchain could do in the future to increase efficiency, smart contract, land certificate to distribute wealth free from politics and government intervention, etc. Keep in mind efficiency could always be converted to a more tangible values in term of money equivalent. That is the way the industrial revolution changes the life and creating wealth. This is the way Amazon, FB (Meta Platform) creating value. In the past how much would it cost you to send message in no time, to get item, videos on your living room in no time ?? Invaluable, if it was possible to have it in the past. This is unrealised value that later become a reality that some people can not see. What is the current value of gene therapy, mapping, sequencing currently doing nothing to human. But what if they have turned out to be able to cure deseases which is currently incurable ??

    Now those who think that BTC do not have value (e.g., £0). This is a teasing test.

    If you offer to someone to choose either a voucher of full English breakfast value of £25 or one bitcoin (£0 based on some people on this thread), which one do you think the ordinary people will be chosing ??? Keep in mind you could not eat BTC but you could sell it for about US$50,000 and there are a lot of other people want to buy it.

    I believe it is only the people who never read the news those who still believe that the flat is earth will choose the full english breakfast. The other people who might think they have missed the boat and in no way they would want to buy BTC at the current price but would like to have them if someone was offering it for £25. rofl

    Wouldn't the  better question be would the common person pick a £40k tangible asset or a £40k intangible asset? 
    Between one cooked breakfast and BTC I'd take a punt on the BTC but a £40k wad of cash or one BTC I'd probably take the cash.

    I hope no real opinion on BTC, but I don't feel I've missed the boat and have no regrets on not holding any. Though I'm not a fan of the for us or against us mentality that seems to dominate the Crypto debate
    Make £2023 in 2023 (#36) £3479.30/£2023

    Make £2024 in 2024...
Meet your Ambassadors

🚀 Getting Started

Hi new member!

Our Getting Started Guide will help you get the most out of the Forum

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 354.1K Banking & Borrowing
  • 254.3K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
  • 455.3K Spending & Discounts
  • 247.1K Work, Benefits & Business
  • 603.7K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
  • 178.3K Life & Family
  • 261.2K Travel & Transport
  • 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
  • 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
  • 37.7K Read-Only Boards

Is this how you want to be seen?

We see you are using a default avatar. It takes only a few seconds to pick a picture.