We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.
This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
The MSE Forum Team would like to wish you all a Merry Christmas. However, we know this time of year can be difficult for some. If you're struggling during the festive period, here's a list of organisations that might be able to help
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Has MSE helped you to save or reclaim money this year? Share your 2025 MoneySaving success stories!
Regular Savings Accounts: The Best Currently Available List!
Comments
-
Its better now they've reduced the direct debit down from £25 to £10kaMelo said:Whilst it's nice to see them upping their rates, as others have said, holding an Ecology BS savings account was never about the rates they offered, it was only ever about being able to fund them via direct debit as this is what enabled qualification for current account rewards or switch offers. Just keep funding and withdraw down to their minimum balance after six months or so then rinse and repeat.
I'll keep my accounts open for as long as they keep the DD funding option.I consider myself to be a male feminist. Is that allowed?1 -
Now live on their site https://www.ybs.co.uk/savings/product?id=YB901839WBridlington1 said:
I haven't many further details about it yet (it's only just appeared on moneyfacts), but the account allows penalty free withdrawals so I very much doubt you need to buy a property with it, I've also yet to see a first home regular saver that requires you to use the funds towards a home, though having said that it may or may not be restricted to those who are yet to buy their first home yet though (we'll find out in the morning).jameseonline said:
Do you have to buy a home with it?, mind you it's only 5%Bridlington1 said:YBS First Home Saver to be launched at 5%
£500/mth max
1 Withdrawal/yr (excluding closure)
Account lasts 2 years
Can skip months if you wish
Account can be opened with £1
At £1 to open and no further funding requirements I think it's worth opening speculatively, particularly given the account lasts two years.- You can only hold a First Home eSaver account if you are saving towards owning your first home. We reserve the right to transfer the account to the Internet Saver Plus Issue 14 if this is not the case.
5 -
It looks like I've timed it very well then, I'm currently in the process of buying my first home. Another month or two and I'd have been ineligible if all goes according to plan.flaneurs_lobster said:
Now live on their site https://www.ybs.co.uk/savings/product?id=YB901839WBridlington1 said:
I haven't many further details about it yet (it's only just appeared on moneyfacts), but the account allows penalty free withdrawals so I very much doubt you need to buy a property with it, I've also yet to see a first home regular saver that requires you to use the funds towards a home, though having said that it may or may not be restricted to those who are yet to buy their first home yet though (we'll find out in the morning).jameseonline said:
Do you have to buy a home with it?, mind you it's only 5%Bridlington1 said:YBS First Home Saver to be launched at 5%
£500/mth max
1 Withdrawal/yr (excluding closure)
Account lasts 2 years
Can skip months if you wish
Account can be opened with £1
At £1 to open and no further funding requirements I think it's worth opening speculatively, particularly given the account lasts two years.- You can only hold a First Home eSaver account if you are saving towards owning your first home. We reserve the right to transfer the account to the Internet Saver Plus Issue 14 if this is not the case.
1 -
You will, of course, have to close the account down the moment your purchase completes to not fall foul of the terms.Bridlington1 said:
It looks like I've timed it very well then, I'm currently in the process of buying my first home. Another month or two and I'd have been ineligible if all goes according to plan.flaneurs_lobster said:
Now live on their site https://www.ybs.co.uk/savings/product?id=YB901839WBridlington1 said:
I haven't many further details about it yet (it's only just appeared on moneyfacts), but the account allows penalty free withdrawals so I very much doubt you need to buy a property with it, I've also yet to see a first home regular saver that requires you to use the funds towards a home, though having said that it may or may not be restricted to those who are yet to buy their first home yet though (we'll find out in the morning).jameseonline said:
Do you have to buy a home with it?, mind you it's only 5%Bridlington1 said:YBS First Home Saver to be launched at 5%
£500/mth max
1 Withdrawal/yr (excluding closure)
Account lasts 2 years
Can skip months if you wish
Account can be opened with £1
At £1 to open and no further funding requirements I think it's worth opening speculatively, particularly given the account lasts two years.- You can only hold a First Home eSaver account if you are saving towards owning your first home. We reserve the right to transfer the account to the Internet Saver Plus Issue 14 if this is not the case.
Good luck with the home buying.2 -
Good point, I somehow must have misread your quote when I posted it. Oh well, I may as well open it with £1 anyway, it'll generate 2p if I make my opening deposit from Co-op by debit card and I may as well act as a guinea pig on this occasion regarding how long it takes YBS to transfer the account into an Internet Saver Plus Issue 14.flaneurs_lobster said:
You will, of course, have to close the account down the moment your purchase completes to not fall foul of the terms.Bridlington1 said:
It looks like I've timed it very well then, I'm currently in the process of buying my first home. Another month or two and I'd have been ineligible if all goes according to plan.flaneurs_lobster said:
Now live on their site https://www.ybs.co.uk/savings/product?id=YB901839WBridlington1 said:
I haven't many further details about it yet (it's only just appeared on moneyfacts), but the account allows penalty free withdrawals so I very much doubt you need to buy a property with it, I've also yet to see a first home regular saver that requires you to use the funds towards a home, though having said that it may or may not be restricted to those who are yet to buy their first home yet though (we'll find out in the morning).jameseonline said:
Do you have to buy a home with it?, mind you it's only 5%Bridlington1 said:YBS First Home Saver to be launched at 5%
£500/mth max
1 Withdrawal/yr (excluding closure)
Account lasts 2 years
Can skip months if you wish
Account can be opened with £1
At £1 to open and no further funding requirements I think it's worth opening speculatively, particularly given the account lasts two years.- You can only hold a First Home eSaver account if you are saving towards owning your first home. We reserve the right to transfer the account to the Internet Saver Plus Issue 14 if this is not the case.
Many thanks.flaneurs_lobster said:
Good luck with the home buying.Bridlington1 said:
It looks like I've timed it very well then, I'm currently in the process of buying my first home. Another month or two and I'd have been ineligible if all goes according to plan.flaneurs_lobster said:
Now live on their site https://www.ybs.co.uk/savings/product?id=YB901839WBridlington1 said:
I haven't many further details about it yet (it's only just appeared on moneyfacts), but the account allows penalty free withdrawals so I very much doubt you need to buy a property with it, I've also yet to see a first home regular saver that requires you to use the funds towards a home, though having said that it may or may not be restricted to those who are yet to buy their first home yet though (we'll find out in the morning).jameseonline said:
Do you have to buy a home with it?, mind you it's only 5%Bridlington1 said:YBS First Home Saver to be launched at 5%
£500/mth max
1 Withdrawal/yr (excluding closure)
Account lasts 2 years
Can skip months if you wish
Account can be opened with £1
At £1 to open and no further funding requirements I think it's worth opening speculatively, particularly given the account lasts two years.- You can only hold a First Home eSaver account if you are saving towards owning your first home. We reserve the right to transfer the account to the Internet Saver Plus Issue 14 if this is not the case.
1 -
I'm coming round to the idea of speculatively opening accounts. I'm now considering the Leeds Home Deposit Saver, but understand it is mainly branch/post with "some operations" possible by phone or online. Could someone with the account confirm whether it is possible to set up withdrawals online?
0 -
When I did some experimentation with an Access Saver last year, which is also branch/post, I was unable to make withdrawals directly to an external account online but could make transfers to another Leeds BS account online. Closure (by cheque) can also be done online.masonic said:I'm coming round to the idea of speculatively opening accounts. I'm now considering the Leeds Home Deposit Saver, but understand it is mainly branch/post with "some operations" possible by phone or online. Could someone with the account confirm whether it is possible to set up withdrawals online?
You can make withdrawals to an external account/close the account over the phone though.
1 -
Thanks, that's good to know. Having the telephone servicing is helpful. With the rising cost of postage, I do wonder how long postal accounts will remain viable.Bridlington1 said:
When I did some experimentation with an Access Saver last year, which is also branch/post, I was unable to make withdrawals directly to an external account online but could make transfers to another Leeds BS account online. Closure (by cheque) can also be done online.masonic said:I'm coming round to the idea of speculatively opening accounts. I'm now considering the Leeds Home Deposit Saver, but understand it is mainly branch/post with "some operations" possible by phone or online. Could someone with the account confirm whether it is possible to set up withdrawals online?
You can make withdrawals to an external account/close the account over the phone though.
2 -
I closed my Leeds HDS online a month or two ago as part of a cull of my lower paying RS accounts. To avoid a cheque in the post you also need an existing Leeds easy access account of any flavour. You can close the HDS and/or internal transfer online very quickly which then enables you to make multiple withdrawals from the EA account whenever needed. If you wish to keep the HDS open bear in mind you can only make 1 withdrawal p.a. from your savings.masonic said:I'm coming round to the idea of speculatively opening accounts. I'm now considering the Leeds Home Deposit Saver, but understand it is mainly branch/post with "some operations" possible by phone or online. Could someone with the account confirm whether it is possible to set up withdrawals online?1 -
fun4everyone said:ty, ill just go open coop now.
6 days later and still all I have is the "Thank you for your application email". Soon I will crack out the "its been 84 years" gif. Yes I am trying to moan it in.
P.S. good luck on your home purchase Bridlington1.1
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 352.9K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.9K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 454.7K Spending & Discounts
- 246K Work, Benefits & Business
- 602.1K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 177.8K Life & Family
- 259.9K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards



