We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.

This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.

📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!

The Old Regular Savers Discussion Thread 28/12/24-29/1/26

1…907908910912913…1113

Comments

  • Dizzycap
    Dizzycap Posts: 2,065
    1,000 Posts Third Anniversary Photogenic Debt-free and Proud!
    Ambassador
    edited 21 November 2025 at 11:45AM
    Chaykin said:
    Chaykin said:
    Hanley Economic BS - I got their online version. Will try to open branch version via post c/w cheque. Will post to Biddulph branch and I will let you all know how I get on.
    Hanley Economic BS - I did as I said above and this is the response I got via email today.
    We have received an application and a cheque for £300 to open a Branch Smart Saver.

    Unfortunately, we are unable to open the account in branch as you need to be present to do this. This is highlighted in our terms and Conditions.

    You can however open this online,  therefore I am returning your application and cheque in the post.

    As we are not sure how long this savings account will be available, I would suggest you open this online as soon as possible to avoid disappointment.
    @nomorekids - really lucky for you that you managed to open this via post. Would be good if you could remember which branch you posted your application to.

    I applied to 2 Hanley branches by post and neither would open a branch RS by post. The usual unfortunately etc etc. Never mind, the Principality Christmas RS made up for it, allbeit @ only £150 a month, but that depends on how many you hold  ;) I've got another 2 Principality Christmas RS maturing in early January, and if still available, I'll get another 2 via the maturity option - swings & roundabouts.
    As the Hanley Economic BS 1 Year Online Smart Saver (TAR10) is NLA, I assume that the branch offering will also be finishing soon?
    --**MONEYFACTS**-- FULL List of Money Comparison Products + News / Guides--
       Personal MSE 2026 Money Saving Challenges:
    ~ NSD 2026 Challenge May 12/20 (6)
    # Regular Savers 2026- New 9/12 - Total: 31 (6)
    # No.12 Save £2 a Day 2026 £364.98 / £730 (6)
    # No.2 Save 1p A Day Challenge 2026 £355.02 / £667.95 (6)
    # No.4 Save £12k in 2026 - £8492.37 / £12,000 (6)
    # £10-a-Day Challenge 2026 - £710.56 / £1825 (6)
    # No.8 Sealed Pot Challenge 19 (22/10) 426 / £400 (6)
    # No.27 - Top Up EP 2 £1255 / £2880 (6).
    # Make £2026 in 2026 - Completed
    Motto: 'SAVE before you spend on Non-essentials' 
  • gt94sss2
    gt94sss2 Posts: 6,525
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper Combo Breaker
    Forumite
    Chaykin said:
    WillPS said:
    Hanley BS Branch Smart Saver

    Wife sent an application to Stone branch (closest branch, marginally). Although she hasn't heard anything back yet, the account and the initial deposit are now visible in her Hanley app.

    I had already opened my account in person in Newcastle under Lyme.

    Her application specifically stated "1 Year Branch Smart Saver (TAR09)", so if they were to reject they'd have had to for a reason other than "you have to open the account online".
    Hanley Economic BS - my application also specifically stated "1 Year Branch Smart Saver (TAR09)". I guess I'll try to re-post to Stone!  :D
    Given the Stone branch is closed until Tuesday, I suspect HEBS will have told their staff not to process any more postal applications by then.
  • s71hj
    s71hj Posts: 1,242
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper Combo Breaker
    Forumite
    gt94sss2 said:
    Chaykin said:
    WillPS said:
    Hanley BS Branch Smart Saver

    Wife sent an application to Stone branch (closest branch, marginally). Although she hasn't heard anything back yet, the account and the initial deposit are now visible in her Hanley app.

    I had already opened my account in person in Newcastle under Lyme.

    Her application specifically stated "1 Year Branch Smart Saver (TAR09)", so if they were to reject they'd have had to for a reason other than "you have to open the account online".
    Hanley Economic BS - my application also specifically stated "1 Year Branch Smart Saver (TAR09)". I guess I'll try to re-post to Stone!  :D
    Given the Stone branch is closed until Tuesday, I suspect HEBS will have told their staff not to process any more postal applications by then.
    Anyone who has successfully opened this by post, did you send a cheque? If so, payable to who? 
  • J63320
    J63320 Posts: 245
    Fourth Anniversary 100 Posts Name Dropper
    Forumite
    MHBS RS maturing 30th November.
    I had an email from MHBS on, I think, the 14th, to say I had a message.  On the 17th I Logged in, found the maturity instructions and made my choice - to close the account and move the money to my current account which I selected from the drop-down list. I’ve got a screenshot of the webpage acknowledging the instructions.
    Today I had another email, so I logged in again and once again there was a message asking me to give maturity instructions. I repeated what I had already done, but also replied to their message. The only oddity is that, in the details of my current account, my name is followed by an asterisk - is it possible that they’ve done a CoP check and this has caused a mismatch? Otherwise, what’s going on? Has anyone else here been asked twice?
  • J63320 said:
    MHBS RS maturing 30th November.
    ...
    Has anyone else here been asked twice?

    Yes, me.  After receiving the first message I decided to accept the default of the funds going into an easy access account, so I did not give maturity instructions.  When I then received a second message I found it irritating but thought it was just a reminder and decided to ignore it.  If you gave maturity instructions and you also received a second message it suggests they've just sent everyone a second message by mistake.

  • soulsaver
    soulsaver Posts: 7,134
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Photogenic Name Dropper
    Forumite
    edited 21 November 2025 at 2:39PM
    J63320 said:
    MHBS RS maturing 30th November.
    I had an email from MHBS on, I think, the 14th, to say I had a message.  On the 17th I Logged in, found the maturity instructions and made my choice - to close the account and move the money to my current account which I selected from the drop-down list. I’ve got a screenshot of the webpage acknowledging the instructions.
    Today I had another email, so I logged in again and once again there was a message asking me to give maturity instructions. I repeated what I had already done, but also replied to their message. The only oddity is that, in the details of my current account, my name is followed by an asterisk - is it possible that they’ve done a CoP check and this has caused a mismatch? Otherwise, what’s going on? Has anyone else here been asked twice?
    MHBS instructions aren't the clearest. Do you have 2 reg savers? Have you given maturity instructions on both? 
  • Chaykin
    Chaykin Posts: 205
    Part of the Furniture 100 Posts Name Dropper Photogenic
    Forumite
    Dizzycap said:

    I applied to 2 Hanley branches by post and neither would open a branch RS by post. The usual unfortunately etc etc. Never mind, the Principality Christmas RS made up for it, allbeit @ only £150 a month, but that depends on how many you hold  ;) I've got another 2 Principality Christmas RS maturing in early January, and if still available, I'll get another 2 via the maturity option - swings & roundabouts.
    As the Hanley Economic BS 1 Year Online Smart Saver (TAR10) is NLA, I assume that the branch offering will also be finishing soon?
    I get it that it's against the T&Cs anyway but what's annoying is that it seems to just be down to pot luck if they open one for you by post or not - rather than strictly apply to their T&Cs. I think I'm going to risk posting to Stone anyway seeing that @WillPS 's wife managed that way. It's only a £0.87 gamble.
    gt94sss2 said:

    Given the Stone branch is closed until Tuesday, I suspect HEBS will have told their staff not to process any more postal applications by then.
    I hope the branch version (TAR09) will remain available for longer than the, now NLA, online one (TAR10) which I have anyway.
    s71hj said:

    Anyone who has successfully opened this by post, did you send a cheque? If so, payable to who? 
    I always just make them payable to myself - never failed. Others say make them payable to "BS name a/c your name".
  • J63320
    J63320 Posts: 245
    Fourth Anniversary 100 Posts Name Dropper
    Forumite
    J63320 said:
    MHBS RS maturing 30th November.
    I had an email from MHBS on, I think, the 14th, to say I had a message.  On the 17th I Logged in, found the maturity instructions and made my choice - to close the account and move the money to my current account which I selected from the drop-down list. I’ve got a screenshot of the webpage acknowledging the instructions.
    Today I had another email, so I logged in again and once again there was a message asking me to give maturity instructions. I repeated what I had already done, but also replied to their message. The only oddity is that, in the details of my current account, my name is followed by an asterisk - is it possible that they’ve done a CoP check and this has caused a mismatch? Otherwise, what’s going on? Has anyone else here been asked twice?
    Update - Just had another message and logged in again. They have confirmed that they’ve received my instructions, and told me that there will be no problem with the asterisk, but nothing about why I was sent two messages. Good to get such a quick response, though.
    I only have the one RS with them - I’m not as much of an RS fanatic as some posters here! 
  • s71hj said:
    gt94sss2 said:
    Chaykin said:
    WillPS said:
    Hanley BS Branch Smart Saver

    Wife sent an application to Stone branch (closest branch, marginally). Although she hasn't heard anything back yet, the account and the initial deposit are now visible in her Hanley app.

    I had already opened my account in person in Newcastle under Lyme.

    Her application specifically stated "1 Year Branch Smart Saver (TAR09)", so if they were to reject they'd have had to for a reason other than "you have to open the account online".
    Hanley Economic BS - my application also specifically stated "1 Year Branch Smart Saver (TAR09)". I guess I'll try to re-post to Stone!  :D
    Given the Stone branch is closed until Tuesday, I suspect HEBS will have told their staff not to process any more postal applications by then.
    Anyone who has successfully opened this by post, did you send a cheque? If so, payable to who? 
    Cheque I made payable to myself 
    If you want to be rich, never, ever have kids ;)
  • WillPS
    WillPS Posts: 5,504
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Newshound! Name Dropper
    Forumite
    Hanley Economic Branch Saver

    My initial deposit was cash (in person).

    MrsPS's was by cheque addressed to her.
This discussion has been closed.
★ ★ ★ Meet your Ambassadors

🚀 Getting Started

Hi new member!

Our Getting Started Guide will help you get the most out of the Forum

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 355.7K Banking & Borrowing
  • 254.9K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
  • 456.1K Spending & Discounts
  • 248.3K Work, Benefits & Business
  • 605.9K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
  • 179K Life & Family
  • 263.7K Travel & Transport
  • 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
  • 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
  • 37.7K Read-Only Boards

Is this how you want to be seen?

We see you are using a default avatar. It takes only a few seconds to pick a picture.