The Old Regular Savers Discussion Thread 28/12/24-29/1/26

SH88SH88

allegro120 said:

SH88SH88 said:

Recently started a RS with Chorley.  First payment was received quite quickly,  second was quite slow. Anybody care to share any opinions re Chorley,  in particular speed of payment,  customer service, any specific foibles etc ? TIA .

Was your second payment sent at weekend?  Chorley don't credit weekend deposits until the next working day.  Deposits made on working day are credited on the same day, but don't show until next day.

First payment was sent on Friday,  visible Online sometime on Saturday. 
Second sent on Saturday,  not showing by late morning Tuesday,  so ... sent a secure message at lunchtime.  Coincidentally or miraculously (not sure which), the payment was visible very soon afterwards. Anyway,  all is well that ends well .....

Bridlington1

Regarding Monmouthshire BS ``phantom accounts":

Each of my phantom accounts had been ones that had been opened but never funded for whatever reason.

I've done a spot of experimenting and there may be a way of getting rid of the phantom accounts from the app. I simply sent £1 to each of the phantom accounts on Saturday, the £1s bounced back and landed in my current account yesterday.

I've just checked the app and the accounts have now disappeared so I'm just left with the open accounts only showing in the app.

It could also be a complete coincidence but I thought I'd mention it anyhow just in case it works for anyone else.

Slinky

janusd said:

i'm not wanting to open a second account as I already have 2 of them - caused by my initial application crashing before showing the acceptance screen... I might throw £1 into that second account tomorrow and see what happens next week.

I had the same thing happen. I sent over £50 yesterday which appeared in the account today, so I've followed it up with another £950.  This is the Exclusive RS1

s71hj

Bridlington1 said:

Regarding Monmouthshire BS ``phantom accounts":

Each of my phantom accounts had been ones that had been opened but never funded for whatever reason.

I've done a spot of experimenting and there may be a way of getting rid of the phantom accounts from the app. I simply sent £1 to each of the phantom accounts on Saturday, the £1s bounced back and landed in my current account yesterday.

I've just checked the app and the accounts have now disappeared so I'm just left with the open accounts only showing in the app.

It could also be a complete coincidence but I thought I'd mention it anyhow just in case it works for anyone else.

I think it may be a coincidence and that it just happens to be a time they are doing some gardening so to speak. I had 2 RSs that accidentally opened when the app was being very stroppy recently . Naturally I tried to fund both but the funds bounced back twice, once from a transaction that was an internal transfer from my MBS easy saver and once a FP from my current account. That was weeks ago but only in past few days the ghost RS has disappered

35har1old

WillPS said:

DodgerPot said:

Re Monmouthshire Branch Exclusive 

I’m also interested in opening this account by post as I’m not local to any branches. 

I already hold the Regular Saver and App Exclusive. 

How have others opened the Branch Exclusive? Where are the applications forms found ? 

Or is it simply a case of writing and enclosing a cheque to open sent to any branch ?

https://www.monbs.com/media/2032/savings-application-form-march-2022-savapp-03-22-1.pdf

Send a cheque if you like, but others have reported not doing it and it being fine.

Just type in Monmouthshire savings application form with the same result 
Posted on Saturday 2nd class there envelope to head office visible in app on Tuesday email received saying thanks for visiting Newport branch.
Would have required a ferry crossing to visit branch

soulsaver

s71hj said:

Bridlington1 said:

Regarding Monmouthshire BS ``phantom accounts":

Each of my phantom accounts had been ones that had been opened but never funded for whatever reason.

I've done a spot of experimenting and there may be a way of getting rid of the phantom accounts from the app. I simply sent £1 to each of the phantom accounts on Saturday, the £1s bounced back and landed in my current account yesterday.

I've just checked the app and the accounts have now disappeared so I'm just left with the open accounts only showing in the app.

It could also be a complete coincidence but I thought I'd mention it anyhow just in case it works for anyone else.

I think it may be a coincidence and that it just happens to be a time they are doing some gardening so to speak. I had 2 RSs that accidentally opened when the app was being very stroppy recently . Naturally I tried to fund both but the funds bounced back twice, once from a transaction that was an internal transfer from my MBS easy saver and once a FP from my current account. That was weeks ago but only in past few days the ghost RS has disappered

Ditto. I've had a mystery account disappear from the app without any action from me.

janusd

s71hj said:

Bridlington1 said:

Regarding Monmouthshire BS ``phantom accounts":

Each of my phantom accounts had been ones that had been opened but never funded for whatever reason.

I've done a spot of experimenting and there may be a way of getting rid of the phantom accounts from the app. I simply sent £1 to each of the phantom accounts on Saturday, the £1s bounced back and landed in my current account yesterday.

I've just checked the app and the accounts have now disappeared so I'm just left with the open accounts only showing in the app.

It could also be a complete coincidence but I thought I'd mention it anyhow just in case it works for anyone else.

I think it may be a coincidence and that it just happens to be a time they are doing some gardening so to speak. I had 2 RSs that accidentally opened when the app was being very stroppy recently . Naturally I tried to fund both but the funds bounced back twice, once from a transaction that was an internal transfer from my MBS easy saver and once a FP from my current account. That was weeks ago but only in past few days the ghost RS has disappeared

for me, the unfunded RS from a couple of years ago has been removed from the app, but tantalisingly, the unfunded 2nd App Exclusive account is still there... 

s71hj

janusd said:

s71hj said:

Bridlington1 said:

Regarding Monmouthshire BS ``phantom accounts":

Each of my phantom accounts had been ones that had been opened but never funded for whatever reason.

I've done a spot of experimenting and there may be a way of getting rid of the phantom accounts from the app. I simply sent £1 to each of the phantom accounts on Saturday, the £1s bounced back and landed in my current account yesterday.

I've just checked the app and the accounts have now disappeared so I'm just left with the open accounts only showing in the app.

It could also be a complete coincidence but I thought I'd mention it anyhow just in case it works for anyone else.

I think it may be a coincidence and that it just happens to be a time they are doing some gardening so to speak. I had 2 RSs that accidentally opened when the app was being very stroppy recently . Naturally I tried to fund both but the funds bounced back twice, once from a transaction that was an internal transfer from my MBS easy saver and once a FP from my current account. That was weeks ago but only in past few days the ghost RS has disappeared

for me, the unfunded RS from a couple of years ago has been removed from the app, but tantalisingly, the unfunded 2nd App Exclusive account is still there... 

My wife had that. We did a speculative £50 in and it stuck so a week later we topped up with £950 and then another £1000 at turn of month. 

Bridlington1

Coventry BS are launching a Sunny Day Saver (2) at 4.3% (var), £150/mth, unlimited withdrawals.

In addition it comes with prize draws, See below for details:
https://secure.coventrybuildingsociety.co.uk/savings-and-investments/application/SpecificTermsAndConds.aspx?prodCode=SDS2

Note the account is ineligible for inclusion on the first page of this thread owing to the thresholds.

surreysaver

Bridlington1 said:

Regarding Monmouthshire BS ``phantom accounts":

Each of my phantom accounts had been ones that had been opened but never funded for whatever reason.

I've done a spot of experimenting and there may be a way of getting rid of the phantom accounts from the app. I simply sent £1 to each of the phantom accounts on Saturday, the £1s bounced back and landed in my current account yesterday.

I've just checked the app and the accounts have now disappeared so I'm just left with the open accounts only showing in the app.

It could also be a complete coincidence but I thought I'd mention it anyhow just in case it works for anyone else.

I sent £50 as £50 is the minimum to open the account with. My £50 landed safely. Maybe your £1 bounced back as it was below the minimum?