stop/start

topdaddy_2

F1F93 wrote: »

Here is a list of all the things I disagree with that you've said.

Well, not all of them. I got bored after the first 4 pages.
Enough of a list for you? Believe me, I've got more.

You disagree that mse is a good forum? I suggest you try a proper motoring forum, maybe one thats marque specific and then see the levels of expertise availible.
secondly you disagree that my saracstic response was valid to gywlims sarcastic response? I dont see whqts to disagree with there unless you consider that actually career advise. More fool you if you did.
Thirdly and most importantly, you have missed THE thing you do think is wrong, the heater function issue. Talk about missing an open goal, a list one thing long and you didnt put it on the list:rotfl:

topdaddy_2

colino wrote: »

Are you really, really not sure I've got it right? Ask a grown up and see if they can put you straight.

Ive checked, and the grown up said not all cars have an ecu so no you cannot be correct. And maybe a few other things but im sue thats the main thing.

F1F93

topdaddy wrote: »

You disagree that mse is a good forum?
You never said it was, I never quoted you as saying you did, and I never disagreed with any such statement. Please quote me disagreeing that MSE is a good forum!
I suggest you try a proper motoring forum, maybe one thats marque specific and then see the levels of expertise availible.
I suggest you try a proper motoring forum to find out how a heater works!
secondly you disagree that my saracstic response was valid to gywlims sarcastic response? I dont see whqts to disagree with there unless you consider that actually career advise. More fool you if you did.
Given the amount of complete bull you've come up with over the past few days forgive me for missing the sarcasm.
Thirdly and most importantly, you have missed THE thing you do think is wrong, the heater function issue. Talk about missing an open goal, a list one thing long and you didnt put it on the list:rotfl:
So I didn't mention the heater issue in the first, second, third, fifth, seventh or eighth lines of my quote? In that case, quote your response in the first four pages that mentions the heater issue that I haven't quoted.

Answers in red.

atrixblue.-MFR-.

topdaddy wrote: »

Ive checked bloke down the pub said not all cars have an ecu so no you cannot be correct. And maybe a few other things but im sue thats the main thing.

altered that for you!
We are not talking about all cars we are talking about cars with stop start (runs to check the proceed has an ecu......yes it does)

motorguy

topdaddy wrote: »

you have missed THE thing you do think is wrong, the heater function issue.

The rest of us dont have a "heater function issue" - you seem to, but you wont explain what it is?

motorguy

topdaddy wrote: »

Ive checked, and the grown up said not all cars have an ecu so no you cannot be correct. And maybe a few other things but im sue thats the main thing.

I think we could be fairly confident in saying that any car that any of are likely to be driving that has stop start, has an ECU.

topdaddy_2

motorguy wrote: »

Shielder mentioned that to say it was NOT about thatare you pig muck dense? Shielder mentioned its not about that. You mentioned its not about that. I MENTIONED ITS NOT ABOUT THAT AND EVEN QUOTED YOU BY NAME IN SAYING THAT ITS NOT ABOUT THAT! Insistant on argueing arent you? Even argueing with some one who agrees with you in principle AND writing. Other pople can see that right? I did put that or has mg bored me into a nonsense induced hallucination? I cant be sure at this stageIt was another example to help explain to the terminally dim.
actually its a less than useful analogy that isnt very relevant. You get that right? Please tell me you do
It doesnt matter. If they had the heater on, the car would use what latent heat it could from the heater matrix. If the heater wasnt previously on and you put the heater on, the car would restart to heat the heater matrix.
it kinda does. You are basing an arguement on an assumption you have made. Ive only worked off what has been said. And again(getting bored of saying this now) I have not made comment on the car restarting due to the function of the stop startBut you havent made a "statement" - you just keep telling us what its not?yes, yes I did. This tells me the answer ro my question in red at the top of this post
No. You did. Post #36. no. Reread. Post 32 as a hint but Id not put it past you to deny the obviousThen you have your "classic" Post #41 "The heater wont work like that, it would be stupid to think it would. Your not smart enough for me to talk to any more"
everything written there is correct, especially the bit about you for the several reasons given in this post aloneYou were immediately pulled on that and ever since you've been avoiding having to admit to me and everyone else that you're wrong (again)
but im not :T
Banal
er, no. Again. Its disputing the "instant cooling" theory banded around by others-certainly not something Ive said.Unles you want o argue with that too. Will you argue with the fact Ive not said it or the thermal conduction part? Or both?(wouldnt surpise me)

Uh huh.

Its not clear what you mean by the last bit. Does it mean you dispute the varible nature of cooling? You disagree with the varibles mentioned-there may be more, I ackowledge that, apature size for example? Or quite simply, you feel the 2-5minute range is finite and all emcompassing? Anyway answers...you know...

topdaddy_2

atrixblue.-MFR-. wrote: »

altered that for you!
We are not talking about all cars we are talking about cars with stop start (runs to check the proceed has an ecu......yes it does)

motorguy wrote: »

I think we could be fairly confident in saying that any car that any of are likely to be driving that has stop start, has an ECU.

Hehe. You both discussing the presence of ecu's but not discounting the pixies.:rotfl: axtrixblue has an excuse in his sig, whats yours mg?
And im not sure the pub has been open since last nightbut thats (another) aside.

topdaddy_2

F1F93 wrote: »

Answers in red.

Ive said its not a good forum. Its not. and yep. You didnt state it so how can it part of the list or do you disagree with everything you have quoted? You think im wrong in saying ive driven cars? They were vag? They had stop/start etc etc etc.

F1F93

topdaddy wrote: »

Ive said its not a good forum. Its not. and yep. You didnt state it so how can it part of the list or do you disagree with everything you have quoted? You think im wrong in saying ive driven cars? They were vag? They had stop/start etc etc etc.

What? Are you high?! I wrote a list of things that were said by you in the first four pages. This is a non-exhaustive list of things that I disagree with. Everything in this list I disagree with. If it is not in this list, then I may or may not disagree with it.

Where has this come from about MSE being a bad forum? I did not quote it, ergo you cannot assume that I disagree with it.
And if it's such a bad forum, I suggest you leave this forum and stop giving people wrong information.

Again, I did not post anything about you driving VAG cars in my list. I honestly don't understand why you mentioned this. Although, given how much I disagree with you, I will admit that I wouldn't be surprised if you were lying.