New Forum Comments

Skid_Marks

What's the point of MSE inviting comments on the new format and then removing those that are critical of it?

heatherw_01

Hi, we move threads if we think they’ll get more help elsewhere (please read the forum rule) so this post/thread has been moved to another board. If you have any questions about this policy please email forumteam@moneysavingexpert.com.

poppellerant

I think the OP's username bears an uncanny resemblance as to what the new forums look like.

martinthebandit

poppellerant wrote: »

I think the OP's username bears an uncanny resemblance as to what the new forums look like.

....and I think your right.

usignuolo

Is this supposed to be where I can post comments on the new Forum format? I was only directed here by another member as I could not find it by inspection. I have made what I hope are some constructive comments on the Techie area of the Forum. However I will summarise again

1. Layout is much too spaced out, have to keep scrolling up and down to find relevant topics and then once in a topic to read comments

2. Colour and format is not restful or easy on the eye (see also 1)

3. Login option is squeezed up on left of forum front page and has to be clicked on again to log in, what is wrong with having the login embedded in the entry page as before? Now looks like they forgot it and added it at last minute. (Hello - Some of us go direct to the forum to log in...)

4. The option to "Read More" about the new format does not work, it just refreshes the same Forum front page with no further information

Generally it is a pretty poor effort and I really don't think I shall be using it so often if at all if the new format as currently presented is adopted.

Former_MSE_Andrea

Hi Skid Marks

I'm not aware of any of the MSE Team removing any comments so far. However, we do need non-logged in users to give us their feedback on the email address at the top of the Forum so we can collate it.

dzug1

umm what new forum format? I must be missing something obvious but it looks the same to me as it has done for yonx

lstar337

dzug1 wrote: »

umm what new forum format? I must be missing something obvious but it looks the same to me as it has done for yonx

Log out and look.

vm2pensioner

"Hi everyone

For Monday and Tuesday this week we are trialling a new look for non-logged in Forum visitors only. Let us know what you think at forumfeedback@moneysavingexpert.com

Thanks!

MSE Team"

It's now Wednesday - and the ghastly new format is still in place.

wiogs

Horrible format - please do not use it again.

busybee100

Not pleasant. Loud colours, lots of white screen, looks like it's been designed for a smart phone.

And where is the new posts button? I've discovered lots of new ideas just by browsing.