P800 and ESC A19

Mikeyorks

ponymad wrote: »

I had 2 codes in the year 2008/09

We're probably at cross purposes there? The Code 559L you mentioned I assumed to be 09-10? The deductions on there are too low ..... but have you checked if they get close to the figures on your 08-09 P11D?

ponymad_3

Sorry .... the P11d fig for 2008 shows 717/ 2009 shows 1458 and 2010 2624

I seem to be being a bit thick here but your advice is really helping.

Mikeyorks

ponymad wrote: »

Sorry .... the P11d fig for 2008 shows 717/ .

As I said in post #40 ....... these things tend to work a year in arrears. As that's how they start out - with the first P11D typically getting to HMRC in the July following the end of the tax year in which the benefit first starts.

The figure above looks to be much closer to the deductions in the 09-10 Coding? You need to cross reference them - but contact HMRC if they won't tally?

roddydogs

dave65 wrote: »

In January I had a demand for £1700 total for 2008/09 & 2009/10, I used martins draft letter and wrote back immediately quoting ESC 19. My circumstances had not changed in 15 years, during which time I never filled in a tax return. No problems until now.

JOY today I received a letter from HMRC saying that after review I did not owe any money!! THANKS MARTIN.

:j

Where do i find Martins Draft letter? cant find it, Ta.

ponymad_3

Mikeyorks wrote: »

.

The figure above looks to be much closer to the deductions in the 09-10 Coding? You need to cross reference them - but contact HMRC if they won't tally?

Yes I can see that , however the 2008 fig was not used on my coding... If they are trying to catch up that year too should i be able to challenge... Will contact them but would like your view Thanks

Gas_Powered_Toothbrush

ponymad wrote: »

dental plan

Lisa needs braces.

Mikeyorks

ponymad wrote: »

If they are trying to catch up that year too should i be able to challenge

Unlikely as 08-09 and 09-10 P800s tend to be issued together. Can only suggest you get out all P11Ds and try to cross match them to your P2 (Coding Notices).
If that fails then ask HMRC to look at the entity

taxing

The Low Income Tax Reforms Group (LITRG) has a guide to help at www.litrg.org.uk/news/2011/2007-08-paye-under
They reckon most should be able to resist HMRC particularly as the P800 assessment is so old - almost 3 years.

It gives guidance on how to go about dealing with HMRC.

dori2o

taxing wrote: »

The Low Income Tax Reforms Group (LITRG) has a guide to help at www.litrg.org.uk/news/2011/2007-08-paye-under
They reckon most should be able to resist HMRC particularly as the P800 assessment is so old - almost 3 years.

It gives guidance on how to go about dealing with HMRC.

This is massively incorrect advice. I presume they're trying to rely on the ESC A19 timeframes. This only applies where information supplied by employers or taxpayers has not been used to update a tax code within 12 months of the end of the tax year in which the information was received.

Just as people have the right to request repayments of tax going back 6 years (although these timescales are changing), so do HMRC have the right to collect any underpaid tax for the same period.

roddydogs

dori2o wrote: »

Yes they do.

Hi, do you know people who have had ESC19 accepted over the phone? mine was dismissed out of hand, I have appealed by letter, just wondered what the circumstances were, Ta