We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.
This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
Debate House Prices
In order to help keep the Forum a useful, safe and friendly place for our users, discussions around non MoneySaving matters are no longer permitted. This includes wider debates about general house prices, the economy and politics. As a result, we have taken the decision to keep this board permanently closed, but it remains viewable for users who may find some useful information in it. Thank you for your understanding.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Pay Rise Cancelled for NHS staff
Comments
-
But your tone and language used is just offensive and looking to start an argument.
Do you work in the public sector/NHS in any form?If you are so against all this, I do hope you are voting with your feet, and don't turn the the police / NHS workers when you are in need, and go to them to help you out, often putting their own lives on the line to save a strangers life, i.e. yours.
I don't want to hear this nonsensical point again:rolleyes:
I really do believe the public sector needs trimmed, along with many, many other people.0 -
donaldtramp wrote: »I really do believe the pubic sector needs to be trimmed0
-
donaldtramp wrote: »Just making my point Graham, something you're not usually shy about;)
Do you work in the public sector/NHS in any form?
I do yes.
And you will often find me having a damn good rant about the waste and beaurocracy. I have even said a few times my own job is a waste really as it's all to do with targets, but I need to earn a wage too, just like anyone else, and while the job is there, I shall do it. But my job does benefit patients directly. There has been many a time when to reach a target, a patient has been investigated, and found to be lacking care, which they then, if they co-operate, duly get.
(Is that how you spell that word? I dunno. So to save me being jumped upon, I thought I would just make myself look feeble and ask).
However, I don't believe nurses get a high enough wage for the job they do. I think GP's are paid fairly. And a lot of the GP figures on paper, are not made up solely of the GP job itself, but can often be made up of several other interets that GP's hold, and work on behalf of other parts of the NHS.
I also don't think the police get a high enough pay to justify ther job.
Theres a saying that always sticks with me. The people on the frontline, will never be rich people, but they give more than they could ever take in a wage.0 -
Graham_Devon wrote: »I also don't think the police get a high enough pay to justify ther job.
Theres a saying that always sticks with me. The people on the frontline, will never be rich people, but they give more than they could ever take in a wage.
Know how much the average PC gets paid ?....
basic salary is around £33,000 add in good pension (even new downgraded scheme pays half pension at 55 - some authorities are spending MORE on pensions than actual policing) etc brings it up to around £40,000. If the bobby is on the beat all the time then fair enough but £40k for someone who spends half the week (at least) form filling for HMG - personally, I think that's a bit steep.0 -
Why such interest in GP's salaries? If you can't beat them then try to join them if you think you have the academic ability to do so - we'll talk again in 8 years time shall we?? I'm sick of hearing sour grapes from others who think their skills are of equal value and feel underpaid. If they were, pay would reflect that.
Find me a poor GP and I'll show you a stupid GP, they just don't exist.
The NHS harbours some of the best managers and biggest wastes of space. Some people totally abuse the benefits on offer and aren't prepared to do a decent days work, and they get away with it when line management is weak.Value-for-money-for-me-puhleeze!
"No man is worth, crawling on the earth"- adapted from Bob Crewe and Bob Gaudio
Hope is not a strategy...A child is for life, not just 18 years....Don't get me started on the NHS, because you won't win...I love chaz-ing!
0 -
-
I do yes.And you will often find me having a damn good rant about the waste and beaurocracy. I have even said a few times my own job is a waste really as it's all to do with targets, but I need to earn a wage too, just like anyone else, and while the job is there, I shall do it. But my job does benefit patients directly. There has been many a time when to reach a target, a patient has been investigated, and found to be lacking care, which they then, if they co-operate, duly get.
I know you need to earn a wage but could that not be in a sector that isn't just there to create further layers of bureaucracy and waste. (I have no idea what your job is, so don't take it personally, just saying how I feel)
I'm making a valid point about the expansion of the public sector. It has been totally unnecessary.There has been many a time when to reach a target,
I have no idea what you do but I'm sure that everyone in the public sector would justify their jobs similarly.
I don't care! I don't want to pay for this largesse.I also don't think the police get a high enough pay to justify ther job.Theres a saying that always sticks with me. The people on the frontline, will never be rich people, but they give more than they could ever take in a wage.
Graham, you've been quick enough to have a pop at other folk on the benefit pyramid scheme over on other boards (I agree with you on a lot of things you've said) but I also believe the public sector needs a cull, you too are consuming tax. It will happen soon hopefully....
I am one of the taxpayers in the middle (who has lived well within his means) who has been squeezed by Brown to pay for a massive social security budget and a bloated public sector. Time for a bit of common sense before the country collapses.0 -
Graham_Devon wrote: »I do yes.
And you will often find me having a damn good rant about the waste and beaurocracy. I have even said a few times my own job is a waste really as it's all to do with targets, but I need to earn a wage too, just like anyone else, and while the job is there, I shall do it. But my job does benefit patients directly. There has been many a time when to reach a target, a patient has been investigated, and found to be lacking care, which they then, if they co-operate, duly get.
(Is that how you spell that word? I dunno. So to save me being jumped upon, I thought I would just make myself look feeble and ask).
However, I don't believe nurses get a high enough wage for the job they do. I think GP's are paid fairly. And a lot of the GP figures on paper, are not made up solely of the GP job itself, but can often be made up of several other interets that GP's hold, and work on behalf of other parts of the NHS.
I also don't think the police get a high enough pay to justify ther job.
Theres a saying that always sticks with me. The people on the frontline, will never be rich people, but they give more than they could ever take in a wage.
The going rate for a new PhD chemist in industry is £26k p.a. A chartered mechanical engineer with 10 years of training can expect £40-50k. The director in a medium sized chemical company gets 60k. A policeman gets £25k. A trained nurse gets £30k. Over 50% of GPs get between £100k and £200k on top of their private income.
You are concerned with the pay of nurses and policemen. So how much do you want them to be paid? Do you also feel that the private sector should fall even further behind? Do you think we have a better health service in the UK for having the more expensive doctors than other parts of Europe?0 -
Old_Slaphead wrote: »Know how much the average PC gets paid ?....
basic salary is around £33,000 add in good pension (even new downgraded scheme pays half pension at 55 - some authorities are spending MORE on pensions than actual policing) etc brings it up to around £40,000. If the bobby is on the beat all the time then fair enough but £40k for someone who spends half the week (at least) form filling for HMG - personally, I think that's a bit steep.
It's not 40k though, your just making that up with the pension part, something no one would even think of doing with a private sector employee.
You have no idea which PC is using the pension scheme for a start.
So no real point saying its 40k.
33k for a police officer, who has gone through training (unpaid I might add to start with). Seems fair to me. Wouldn't even buy you a 2 bed starter home in most places. Plus unsociable hours? The harm they could come to?0 -
donaldtramp wrote: »
I am one of the taxpayers in the middle (who has lived well within his means) who has been squeezed by Brown to pay for a massive social security budget and a bloated public sector. Time for a bit of common sense before the country collapses.
Yer, funnily enough, I'm one of them too
What people never seem to mention is the lack of double time, the working on christmas eve while every other private sector office worker is enjoying time with their family. Working boxing day, christmas day etc, at normal wage.
They can only see the upside of the pension.
Theres downsides too, which no one ever seems to mention.0
This discussion has been closed.
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply

Categories
- All Categories
- 352K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.5K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 454.2K Spending & Discounts
- 245K Work, Benefits & Business
- 600.6K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 177.4K Life & Family
- 258.8K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.6K Read-Only Boards