Jeff Buckley - Hallelujah (single) - MP3/WMA/ DRM AAC download from only 49p (59p @ A

almond

bellrooster wrote: »

Personally, I prefer Bon Jovi's version

*hides*

seen jon sing it live at 02 and omg brillant :T everybody is going on about the jeff buckley version and i heard it yesterday not going to upset anybody
hear but get jons version

ezzmo

sarahg1969 wrote: »

It could have been much worse. Diana could have been singing it.

Pmsl. well said!!:T yes the Diana does, The Cranberries version would have been ghastly!

jembie

Next to Jeff Buckley this has to be the best ever performance of the song
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=ymB0VNFm6Ls

Or this one for a laugh
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=yMqLueRm3Fc

catkins

1carminestocky wrote: »

It's just a shame this version has never been officially released as IMO it blows ALL the other ones out of the water (and, to the uninformed, yes, it is a woman :rolleyes: , and arguably the best female singer on the planet).


http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=P_NpxTWbovE

I so so agree. I think k.d. Lang has an incredible amazing voice. I have seen her live and she was brilliant - the best live performance I have ever seen. Her voice is so strong and powerful. She totally deserves that standing ovation on the video.

It is so annoying that someone with such a fantastic voice is so ignored and a silly X Factor winner who sobs and simpers and when she sings just warbles can ruin this song and will still get to number 1.

Mind you she could have recorded Bob the Builder and still all the leemings would have bought it just because she won X rubbish.

A few years (if that) and she will be forgotten.

JHM_2

Personally, I prefer k d lang's version from the BBC4 St. Luke's concert a few months ago, which I recorded (for personal use only, of course).

The whole concert will be available on Blu-Ray in the new year
http://www.amazon.co.uk/K-D-Lang-Live-Orchestra-Blu-ray/dp/B001KEGRAW/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=dvd&qid=1229417962&sr=1-1


Can't find that particular performance on YouTube, but here's one she prepared earlier (2004)
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=FTv9m8c6hnw

dogtown_raider

regardless of which version you like (cohen, buckley, kd lang) i think the general consenus is most of us like the song the way it was meant to be sung (is that a word?) and that is of course in a soft somber style.

rather than over the top in a 'look everyone i can sing' fashion.

I think if they really wanted to tell if anyone even liked the x-factor songs they should release them a few weeks before christmas and if they were half as good as the saturday night couch potato crowd that buys their records think they are then they would still be there come Christmas day and yet OTHER artists would stand a chance.

we dont get to wish songs like bob the builder beat out eminem to the number one spot anymore - it's dull. I'd rather a travesty got there on it's own than being force fed at just the right time of year.

Is Alexandra's version even the full one does anyone know? I know the one she sang on TV wasn't.

jembie

dogtown_raider wrote: »

we dont get to wish songs like bob the builder beat out eminem to the number one spot anymore - it's dull. I'd rather a travesty got there on it's own than being force fed at just the right time of year.

I agree. Everyone should go out and buy Geraldine's Christmas song and make that number 1 instead...That would stick it to Mr High pants Cowell!!

ljw2701

While KD Lang's version is good, I also had the privilege of seeing Leonard Cohen sing this twice this year:j - Manchester in June and Glasgow in November - and believe that no-one can sing it like the man who wrote it!

However, if Alexandra's version brings Cohen to the attention of a wider audience then I have no real complaints.

dogtown_raider

but it won't. will it?

itll bring alexandra to the attention of an audience. how many kids do you know who listen to the original just because the song they like has been covered? If they did then rap music would be re-igniting 70's and 80's pop songs.

Toto

As a musician who has played this tune more times than I've had hot dinners i'm totally sick of it I think this thread has shown the world and his aunt have covered it. All we need now is an x factor cover of car wash and Imagine and we'd have the complete set.:rotfl: