Writers:Share - Get paid to leave comments!

rooth

ktpie wrote: »

Seems to me that they have changed their minds on their acceptance criteria since they wrote this. The ones I have had rejected didn't fall into any of these catagories.

I think you are right. It is the same for me. If I had not read in this forum thread that some people have had comments accepted I would have thought they were rejecting all of them.

It seems now they are accepting 20% and rejecting 80% which is the opposite of the their claim to accept 80% of comments.

Chollita

Ditto, if everyone's remaining comments were being rejected, I would have thought that they are clearing the decks to make way for new comments, but why are they accepting some comments and not others?

Question for all: are you having all outstanding comments a) rejected b) accepted c) both?

elliemoo

I have had 12 acceptances this morning with no rejections yet, and 7 acceptances yesterday with no rejections.

jpgames

"Hi there. Thanks for your comment - unfortunately there's a problem with it and we can't accept it. The two main problems we have with comments are: 1. It's too short - comments need to be 150 words long. 2. It's not unique - your comment must be all your own words! Have a look at our 'How to' page for some tips: http://www.writersshare.co.uk/how-to-comment/. And keep the comments coming! Thanks from all at Writers:Share."

What a joke, I have to say I'm extremely angry.

Had 3 comments rejected this morning and they were ALL my own words and 200+ words.

If they don't have the money to pay just be honest!

:mad: :mad: :mad:

Chollita

5 rejections out of 6 now ... guess WS don't like me any more *sniff* think I'll take my talents elsewhere ...

jo_b_2

jpgames wrote: »

"Hi there. Thanks for your comment - unfortunately there's a problem with it and we can't accept it. The two main problems we have with comments are: 1. It's too short - comments need to be 150 words long. 2. It's not unique - your comment must be all your own words! Have a look at our 'How to' page for some tips: http://www.writersshare.co.uk/how-to-comment/. And keep the comments coming! Thanks from all at Writers:Share."

Had 3 comments rejected this morning and they were ALL my own words and 200+ words.

If they don't have the money to pay just be honest!

:mad: :mad: :mad:

Likewise, only submitted 3 comments - all 3 were my work and well over 150 words and not rubbish either! All 3 have been rejected! I think the 80% acceptance criteria is looking a bit inaccurate! :rolleyes:

thompsop07

3 out of 3 accpepted yesterday and 12 of 13 today, that one was actually 139 words aswell

ktpie

geordie_joe wrote: »

I think your post fell into the 5th catagory which they forgot to mention

5) can't afford to pay for it.

Yep I think you are right, just checked my email and they have rejected all the other comments I did, so out of 10 just 1 accepted (which was accepted a few weeks ago). I wouldn't have said one of mine was far better than the rest, perhaps it just got accepted before they started to feel the pinch!

MoneyMagnet

ktpie wrote: »

Originally Posted by Writers:Share

...
However the typical reasons why we reject comments are:
...

2) Those of comment are is poor English - Will be rejected - obviously.

They don't like poor English? Talk about the pot calling the kettle black :rotfl:

Feline2001

Chollita wrote: »

5 rejections out of 6 now ... guess WS don't like me any more *sniff* think I'll take my talents elsewhere ...

But is there elsewhere to go that is a similar concept?