We'd like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum... Read More »
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
YNAB robber needs help to execute the plan
Options

Wanna_Bee_Free
Posts: 2,314 Forumite


Right, I am going to finally start a diary on here. I am being supported financially by my OH to allow me to help my sister care for my 90 year old father. I have an expensive event in Feb that I need to save for. I have been using YNAB since Feb so I have an accurate record of my spending for 6 months. It's not pretty. I keep robbing Peter to pay Paul so I pay for something fun and then I steal from a boring but necessary YNAB category to fund it. If I am going to pay my annual costs, have money for the big event I need to actually master this budgetting stuff. I am starting August with all my pounds allocated and a realistic amount for everything except personal spends £10. I spent £130.49 last month to get a new to me iphone and really didn't have the money but I want a working phone. When I first started reading the forums in 2007 I was over £25k in debt. I would just have put a new one on credit or signed up to a new handset contract but these days I have a £6 monthly deal and bought an ok second hand iphone from B@ckm@rket. I have a lot to learn still but I'm better than I was. Now I am debt free but OH has interest free cc debts mainly to furnish a place we rented for a year when my Dad was so ill.
My plan is to keep a journal page of all my many wants and whims, hopefully many of them will disappear by the end of the month. I don't want to steal from my other YNAB categories as they are all there for a reason.
YNAB July 2 overspent categories £173
Infinite amounts of shuffling around robbing Peter to pay Paul.
Goals for August
Check YNAB before spending
No robbing Peter to pay Paul
No shuffling to hide my sins.
Slow down, think, plan ahead
Take sandwich, snacks water etc to stop the risk of spending
Use the library for books
Keep the faith this month. If I can leave the categories intact September will have more wriggle room.
1/8 Balance £10 my spending money £3 on coffee at the free MI5 exhibition at the National Archives with a friend. Feels totally worth it at the moment. He's been ill and I didn't buy lunch, cakes, or something nice from the gift shop.
Monthly phone bill out £6 budgetted and planned.
2/8 Balance £7 my spending money
Lots of NSDs are needed now - my challenge is to see how long I can go. Wednesday ideally.
My plan is to keep a journal page of all my many wants and whims, hopefully many of them will disappear by the end of the month. I don't want to steal from my other YNAB categories as they are all there for a reason.
YNAB July 2 overspent categories £173
Infinite amounts of shuffling around robbing Peter to pay Paul.
Goals for August
Check YNAB before spending
No robbing Peter to pay Paul
No shuffling to hide my sins.
Slow down, think, plan ahead
Take sandwich, snacks water etc to stop the risk of spending
Use the library for books
Keep the faith this month. If I can leave the categories intact September will have more wriggle room.
1/8 Balance £10 my spending money £3 on coffee at the free MI5 exhibition at the National Archives with a friend. Feels totally worth it at the moment. He's been ill and I didn't buy lunch, cakes, or something nice from the gift shop.
Monthly phone bill out £6 budgetted and planned.
2/8 Balance £7 my spending money
Lots of NSDs are needed now - my challenge is to see how long I can go. Wednesday ideally.
4
Comments
-
NSD 1 yesterday. Feeling pleased with myself. Two car loads of stuff came back from storeage so next is to sort through and rehome as much as possible. We've taken our home off the market so no longer need to pay hide away our excess stuff and we both want to streamline a bit more now.1
-
Have you reallocated the storage costs?Mortgage at 01.01.14 £119,481.83:eek: today £0 Emergency fund £5.5/5.5k & £200/200 cash.:jWeight 24/02/19 14st 7lb now 12st determined to stop defining myself by my mistakes. Progress not perfection.:T100%through my 1% mortgage challenge. 100% through my pb challenge.1
-
Is that £10 for the month? It's not very much and I wonder how realistic it is to expect yourself to manage on it*Dad loan - £5300 - £7200
*Virgin Credit Card - £3552.50 - £0
*Natwest - £1828.35 -£400
Barclaycard - £2315.25 - £0.00
Creation Finance - £960.32 £840
*Total debt - £8440/£11641.17*
Savings
*Savings Buffer - £1000/£1500
*Emergency Fund - £1010/£1500
New diary- https://forums.moneysavingexpert.com/discussion/6474943/the-three-cs-coffee-clothes-credit-cards/0 -
Ooh visitors, thanks for stopping by! Managed another NSD and took so many snacks out with me today on the train I have bought almost all of them home again.
in_need_of_direction the storeage costs are allocated to repay a 0% cc and we will start saving that later this month. Mind you it was a bit of an unbudgeted cost we took on as a result of putting the house on the market. Not exactly good at this stuff. Sadly I'm the better one of the two of us at it.
Sarahwithlove, yes it's £10 for the month which I believe isn't realistic at all but I need to take the phone hit from last month somewhere so this is basically the problem. I know it would be better to be realistic but a lot of my YNAB overspending is because I spend some unplanned money and then steal it from another sinking fund. If I didn't overspend all the time I wouldn't end up in these situations but I really want to try and reset for a better September. I am hoping a £40 refund is coming back to me although I can't control if/when that is this month. Otherwise I think I may have to say no to some things I want to do if I am going to stick to it. Even if I try and fail it will set me up in a better place for next month than if I don't try.
0
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply

Categories
- All Categories
- 351.1K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.1K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 453.6K Spending & Discounts
- 244.1K Work, Benefits & Business
- 599K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 177K Life & Family
- 257.4K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.6K Read-Only Boards