Regular Savings Accounts: The Best Currently Available List!

Bobblehat

exel1966 said:

Not an error/flaw, more an observation, but why open the 2nd one this month, just leave it until the 1st or 2nd Jan? It's vaguely possible that if opened in Dec and not funded you may fall foul of the min £10 monthly deposit even though you have 10 days to fund. Those two rules rather contradict one another, however I'm sure the latter rule would override the minimum

Also, if requiring extra funds ready in time for Xmas 25 you could adjust the split from 10/240 at some point to whatever you think you'll need.

For those who worry about CoP.

• Please note Confirmation of Payee (CoP) will not work for 24 hours after you initially set up your account, for details of the scheme please see our CoP webpage 

If it's still available on 1st/2nd Jan, that would be fine to open and fund it then.

I assumed that by putting it in December, it would be a good example for those that wanted to "grab it quick", (or already grabbed it!). Those that are prepared to take a chance would see that the number crunching above would still be valid if it were opened in early January. The sweet spot might be to open it early on 24th December and even the harshest interpretation of "10 days" would certainly fall on a bank working day straight after the New Year break! That's what I'm going for. It also gives me the certainty that if the account is open on the 24th, I should be well in time to alter my pending January SO (to the older RS) to £10 instead of its current value of £250. The first payment to the new RS I'll do manually, and set up a 2nd SO for £240 to start in February.

The main purpose of trying such a table was to see if a certain combination of factors would breach the £3750 rule, I couldn't do it in my head, so played around and eventually came up with this version as the best one I could come up with to test out on the forum who are far quicker than me to see various possibilities (or problems) 

I did try a few "different splits" but as I don't have a current reason to maximise the maturity value of the older RS, I went for the maximum overall payments without breaking the max rule which is the 10/240 split with £250pm in the new one after the older RS matures. I think this could maximise the overall total of interest over the two RS's.

Stargunner

Bridlington1 said:

qbadger said:

Also perhaps worth noting that according to the Issue 2 Terms, an account opened this month "...must be credited with between £10 and £250 per calendar month". This condition can not seemingly be met if you have already fully funded Issue 1 this month and the combined monthly deposit rule is enforced in practice.

https://mhbs.co.uk/document/1YR02/

Though that term makes no difference for this month anyway.

If you miss more than one payment in a calendar year the account is transferred into an EA account, but it is currently the final month of the calendar year anyway, if you open the account in December it is not possible to miss more than one payment this calendar year so if you miss this payment nothing happens and the year resets in January leaving you in the same position as you would be had you opened the account in January so far as meeting that term is concerned.

If you have a fully funded Issue 1 the only real difference by opening in December vs January is that assuming they enforce the rule about only being able to deposit £250 between them is that your funding window for making your initial deposit is reduced if you open it in December.

I would imagine that most people would want to fund them on the 2nd January, to maximise the interest potential, so it wouldn’t make any difference to them, whenever they open them.

Bridlington1

Stargunner said:

Bridlington1 said:

qbadger said:

Also perhaps worth noting that according to the Issue 2 Terms, an account opened this month "...must be credited with between £10 and £250 per calendar month". This condition can not seemingly be met if you have already fully funded Issue 1 this month and the combined monthly deposit rule is enforced in practice.

https://mhbs.co.uk/document/1YR02/

Though that term makes no difference for this month anyway.

If you miss more than one payment in a calendar year the account is transferred into an EA account, but it is currently the final month of the calendar year anyway, if you open the account in December it is not possible to miss more than one payment this calendar year so if you miss this payment nothing happens and the year resets in January leaving you in the same position as you would be had you opened the account in January so far as meeting that term is concerned.

If you have a fully funded Issue 1 the only real difference by opening in December vs January is that assuming they enforce the rule about only being able to deposit £250 between them is that your funding window for making your initial deposit is reduced if you open it in December.

The funding window will be exactly the same, whatever month you open it.

Apologies, my post was badly worded. I should've put in practice you've a shorter timeframe that you are able to make your initial deposit.

The point I was attempting to make was that if you've fully funded Issue 1 and you open issue 2 in December and they enforce the term regarding only being able to deposit £250 between the two accounts, you'd be unable to make your initial deposit for Issue 2 in December but the 10 calendar day funding window remains so in practice the number of days you can actually make your initial deposit into the account without the payment getting bounced. E.g. if you opened the account tomorrow (23/12/24), the 10 calendar days would start from then but you wouldn't in practice be able to make your deposit till 1/1/25 so your funding window in practice would be restricted to the first couple of days of January only.

Bobblehat

qbadger said:

The maximum balance of Issue 1 as per its Terms is £3,750:

https://mhbs.co.uk/document/1YR01/

This wasn't the case when I saved the T&C's during the application process on 26.09.2024 ... they were saved as I showed them earlier, with max as £3000! Does this affect the table I posted, I don't think so? I still think the maximum interest to be had by 31.03.2026 is achieved by the 10/240 split and paying in £250 to Iss 2 after Iss 1 has matured. I'm prepared to be proved wrong!

Bridlington1

Bobblehat said:

qbadger said:

The maximum balance of Issue 1 as per its Terms is £3,750:

https://mhbs.co.uk/document/1YR01/

This wasn't the case when I saved the T&C's during the application process on 26.09.2024 ... they were saved as I showed them earlier, with max as £3000! Does this affect the table I posted, I don't think so? I still think the maximum interest to be had by 31.03.2026 is achieved by the 10/240 split and paying in £250 to Iss 2 after Iss 1 has matured. I'm prepared to be proved wrong!

The maximum balance for Issue 1 was increased from £3k to £3.75k not long after it was launched IIRC.

EDIT:
See below:
https://forums.moneysavingexpert.com/discussion/comment/81018871/#Comment_81018871

masonic

Bobblehat said:

qbadger said:

The maximum balance of Issue 1 as per its Terms is £3,750:

https://mhbs.co.uk/document/1YR01/

This wasn't the case when I saved the T&C's during the application process on 26.09.2024 ... they were saved as I showed them earlier, with max as £3000! Does this affect the table I posted, I don't think so? I still think the maximum interest to be had by 31.03.2026 is achieved by the 10/240 split and paying in £250 to Iss 2 after Iss 1 has matured. I'm prepared to be proved wrong!

The interest rate is the same, so prioritising the newer one will result in a higher carried balance when the other matures, and therefore more interest overall.

If they varied the maximum balance while the original one was on sale, I'm surprised they didn't notify you of updated T&C.

Bobblehat

masonic said:

Bobblehat said:

qbadger said:

The maximum balance of Issue 1 as per its Terms is £3,750:

https://mhbs.co.uk/document/1YR01/

This wasn't the case when I saved the T&C's during the application process on 26.09.2024 ... they were saved as I showed them earlier, with max as £3000! Does this affect the table I posted, I don't think so? I still think the maximum interest to be had by 31.03.2026 is achieved by the 10/240 split and paying in £250 to Iss 2 after Iss 1 has matured. I'm prepared to be proved wrong!

The interest rate is the same, so prioritising the newer one will result in a higher carried balance when the other matures, and therefore more interest overall.

If they varied the maximum balance while the original one was on sale, I'm surprised they didn't notify you of updated T&C.

I've no memory of them notifying me ... but I've no excuse for missing the forum post by Kim_13 and signposted by Bridlington1. The forum is a more reliable source of such information 

ForumUser7

There was a discussion somewhere on the forum - I think it was something like with the duration of the account in terms of months, and a £250 per month, you’d exceed £3000 and reach £3750. People reported this to MHBS who subsequently updated the ts and cs. I agree though that customers who opened on the old terms should’ve been sent the new terms - bad form, I only knew about this from being on the forum.

The thing I’m really curious about is if the systems enforce the whole deposit limit! I.e. if it will let you pay £250 in each regardless of terms, and doesn’t just void the interest at the end of the term.

granta

Mansfield BS Kick Start (7th issue) RS

I've just realised the bonus comes to an end in the next few days and overall interest rate drops to 4%. I'd like to withdraw funds - does anyone know if this can be done electronically via online secure message or any other quick way without sending passbook etc?

akh43

BestSeagull said:

My Nationwide Flex RS has just matured. I tried to open the current one but the system tells me I can't because I already have a RS.
Any idea how long it will take to sort itself out?

Mine matured on 21st and had already transferred to a new EA account when I logged in today and I was able to open a new RS and fund today.