Vcs simon renshaw smith

pesky_robway

Small update on this

Today i went to court to challenge this.

The judge heard my case and found in my favour and awarded me my costs.

Thank you for all the help given i doubt id of done it without it

Umkomaas

pesky_robway said:

Small update on this

Today i went to court to challenge this.

The judge heard my case and found in my favour and awarded me my costs.

Thank you for all the help given i doubt id of done it without it

Excellent result, well done. 

Could you please tell us a little bit more, in particular which court, the Judge's name (if you remember that), on what grounds did the court find in your favour. Also, if you could give us short report on how things unfurled on the day and an indication as to how the PPC's legal rep handled things. 

ANOTHER VCS ONE BITES THE DUST!

keypulse

Brilliant news @pesky_robway, good work. I too would love to hear more about your win.

beamerguy

pesky_robway said:

Small update on this

Today i went to court to challenge this.

The judge heard my case and found in my favour and awarded me my costs.

Thank you for all the help given i doubt id of done it without it

Brilliant, look forward to your report and please tell us
1: which court
2: name of judge
3: how much was awarded

Coupon-mad

Yay, just caught up with this outcome - please tell us more? 
How did you feel and what won it?  Well done - ANOTHER VCS ONE BITES THE DUST!

pesky_robway

Ho guys sorry for the slow reply.here are some more details

Middlesbrough combined court
Judge reed

On the day i went to court and i was met by their solicitor and offered a final get out of £125 before we stepped into the court room.i of course rejected the offer.

We then went into the court room and they pulled out a massive collection of papers showing photos of all signs and their rules and regs.they also had pictures of my vehicle etc.

the judge got straight to the point and asked if i had a ticket to park which i showed him.

Their solicitor didn't have a defence statement from the parking attendant who issued the ticket

The judge then asked on what grounds this ticket should stand,to which the reply was failure to display.the parking attendent noted on his xda that i had produced a ticket at the time and the judge basically said that it was a complete waste of time as i had done my best to adhere to the parking conditions and there wouldnt be a problem if the tickets were sticky backed.

The case was dismissed in my favour on producing a valid ticket and a photo of the parking attendants hand held device stating he had missed my ticket and i produced one at the time and he had seen it.

I was awarded £56 in costs payable within 2 weeks which i am still yet to recieve

pesky_robway

Here is the official court paper

Le_Kirk

A sound result, let's hope you get your money.

beamerguy

pesky_robway   well done.   Was the legal Elms Legal by chance ?


The judge was right about TIMEWASTING, not the first time VCS/EXCEL have been told that.

Why Simon Renshaw-smith keeps bringing time wasting cases to court must now be down to desperation

Renshaw-smith blotted his book a long time ago with the courts.

So, Renshaw-smith did not pass GO and lost £100 + the scam £60 + his costs ???

Fruitcake

Well done on your most excellent win. This isn't the first judge to say that non-adhesive tickets are not fit for purpose. 


It seems odd to me that payment by a Sunday has been ordered, but I am not court savvy.
If it doesn't arrive on time you have several choices including complaining to the court or making a court claim yourself. This will cost you £25 but you will get it back. 
Alternatively there might be a way to get court appointed bailiffs to seize goods to the value owed.