We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.

This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.

Debate House Prices


In order to help keep the Forum a useful, safe and friendly place for our users, discussions around non MoneySaving matters are no longer permitted. This includes wider debates about general house prices, the economy and politics. As a result, we have taken the decision to keep this board permanently closed, but it remains viewable for users who may find some useful information in it. Thank you for your understanding.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!

Public Sector workers laughing all the way to the bank

11920222425

Comments

  • darich
    darich Posts: 2,145 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Combo Breaker
    that is why it is almost perfect, and not perfect.

    3 mistakes in 4 lines is hardly "almost perfect"
    A mistake in 75% of the lines you write?
    :confused:

    Keen photographer with sales in the UK and abroad.
    Willing to offer advice on camera equipment and photography if i can!
  • vivatifosi
    vivatifosi Posts: 18,746 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 10,000 Posts Mortgage-free Glee! PPI Party Pooper
    oh someone is grumpy, the police can't go on strike and had their paydeal agreed last year and next year it will be frozen, as for the black hole in pensions who else pays 11% of their wages into a pension - not many people. police numbers are being cut, workloads are being doubled, so life is not all rosy but yes we r lucky to still have employment.

    For me the big issue is retirement age. You can't compare 11% contributions to lower contributions for other public sector workers who are retiring 10 years later. I'm a pension fund trustee and it is hugely more expensive to provide a pension for someone who is retiring at 55 than for someone retiring at 65. I'm not suggesting that police should work until 65, but there are very good reasons why the pension contributions are high. FWIW I think the police pension is a pretty good deal for those who will be able to claim it.
    Please stay safe in the sun and learn the A-E of melanoma: A = asymmetry, B = irregular borders, C= different colours, D= diameter, larger than 6mm, E = evolving, is your mole changing? Most moles are not cancerous, any doubts, please check next time you visit your GP.
  • Old_Slaphead
    Old_Slaphead Posts: 2,749 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Combo Breaker
    edited 23 November 2009 at 3:42PM
    oh someone is grumpy, the police can't go on strike and had their paydeal agreed last year and next year it will be frozen, as for the black hole in pensions who else pays 11% of their wages into a pension - not many people. police numbers are being cut, workloads are being doubled, so life is not all rosy but yes we r lucky to still have employment.

    Even Labour's own rag is appearing to intimate that at over £1million to fund the average bobby's pension,

    http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2009/nov/22/police-pension-funding-shortfall

    there are questions about the long term viability of public pensions.
  • Eric_Pisch
    Eric_Pisch Posts: 8,720 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Combo Breaker
    kabayiri wrote: »
    You are indeed correct Old S.

    However, to cut Carol some slack the concept of percentage is abused weekly on X factor.

    I'm tired of hearing about people giving 150%. If you give 100% of your effort you are doing all you can! :)

    depends, it could be based on what the avg performance is or even the expected performance not necisarily the maximum individual performance

    if your job requires 40 hours a week and you consistently do 44 you are giving it 110%
  • macaque wrote: »
    username2003

    You have asked for the evidence and then ranted in the same post.

    School playgrounds have been sold off. Class sizes are getting bigger. Universities and employers increasingly having retrain school leavers in basic skills. Police stations and police in the community have declined rapidly in recent years. Bin collections are now only every fortnight. Public WCs have almost dissapeared. Traffic wardens are no longer public servants but profit centres. UK public transport has become one of the most expensive in the world. Local council officials now force their way into peoples houses. Road verges are littered with millions of signs as the roads themselves fall apart. Unfinished road works are everywhere.



    See below

    Chief Executive, BOLTON AT HOME, Circa £125,000
    Director of Community & Children's Services, Circa £120K
    Group Director of Housing and Customer Services, Hampshire, up to £105,000 package
    Chief Executive, Poole, Dorset, £140k package
    Children’s participation and targeted support manager Kensington, £31,900 - 43,100 plus PRP
    Health and Safety Manager £250 per day - Negotiable
    Contract Monitoring and Development Manager, HACKNEY, £42,258 - £44,910
    Head of Family Wellbeing Service, Twickenham, £46,050 - £48,876 pa
    Principal Practitioner – Continuous Improvement Lean Specialist, £44,947 to £55,391 per annum
    Community Safety Officer, £20.49 PAYE/£24.59 Umbrella
    Travel Buddy Co-ordinator, HOUNSLOW,£29,601 - £31,761
    Management Plan Co-Ordinator HADRIANS WALL HERITAGE, c £34K
    Project Delivery Manager,BUSINESSLINK.GOV.UK, London, £55000 - £70000 per annum
    Membership and Stakeholder Co-ordinator, Up to £28k
    DIRECTOR OF SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT IN GOVERNMENT, £57,936 - £68,990
    Project Manager, Financial Inclusion Derbyshire, RURAL ACTION DERBYSHIRE, £32,000 pa
    Head of Performance, BARNET, £44,262 - £46,692 pa inc
    Head of Service Delivery, Poplar, London, Circa £45,000 per annum inclusive
    Safeguarding Development Officer, HALTON, £28,636 - £30,851 p.a
    Conference and Reviewing Manager, HALTON, £35,430 - £38,042 p.a
    Practice Manager- Adoption and Permanence, EAST SUSSEX, £39,711- £43,401 pa
    Performance and Information Manager, CAMBRIDGESHIRE, £31,433 - £42,583
    Senior Personal Assistant - Executive Director, NEWHAM, £29,601-33,510 pa inc
    Service Manager for Safeguarding & Quality Assurance, LUTON BC, £46,295 - £48,950 pa, Children's Rights Officer (Safeguarding & Standards), DONCASTER, Up to £34,549 pa
    Independent Reviewing Officer (Safeguarding & Standards), DONCASTER, Up to £40,741 pa
    Head of Change, WORCESTERSHIRE, £75,267 - £83,388
    Lean Practitioner, HARROW, To £42,000 pa plus benefits
    Service Manager, BARNET, £51,381 - £55,071 pa inc
    Assistant Director - Children's Trust & Performance, MIDDLESBROUGH. Salary to £70-£75k
    Independent Chair - Child Protection, BRACKNELL FOREST BC, £41,200 - £43,900 pa
    Strategic Development and Commissioning Manager YORKSHIRE CC, SM2 - up to £58,490
    Head of Children's Safeguarding, £52,073 - £60,921
    Senior Resettlement Officer, CROYDON, £33,177 - £38,574 pa
    Head of Family Placement Services, MANCHESTER CC, £46,263-£49,413
    Principal Manager, Children's Residential Service, MANCHESTER CC, £39,855-£41,616
    Deputy District Manager, MANCHESTER CC, £42,840-£45,765
    District Managers MANCHESTER CC, £58,494
    Service Lead for Safeguarding, MANCHESTER CC, £57,078
    Head of District Provision, MANCHESTER CC, £65,000
    Transport Strategy Director, Manchester, Circa £90,000 plus final salary...
    Safeguarding Children Manager (Partnerships), NOTTINGHAMSHIRE, To £39,855
    Safeguarding Children Board Development Manager, NOTTINGHAMSHIRE CC, To £39,855 Programme / Project Manager (Business Support Carbon Reduction, Energy Efficiency), £42,246 to £50,373
    Bury Accessible Natural Greenspace Officer, BURY MBC, £21,519 - £24,646 per annum
    Programme Director - Building Schools for the Future, NORFOLK, Up to £90k
    Environmental Health Manager, HACKNEY, £48,501 - £51,381
    Senior Project Manager Skills Development, LDA, £48,935
    Children’s Services Senior Quality Assurance and Improvement Adviser £40,741 - £44,352 p.a. plus...
    Senior Research Advisor – Assessment, Coventry, c£55,800 + attractive benefits
    Manager – Business & Programme Management, Coventry, c£47,000+ attractive benefits
    Programme Support Manager, Coventry, c£34,400 + attractive benefits
    Development Managers – Policy & Implementation, Coventry, c£34,400+ attractive benefits
    Internal Consultants, Coventry, c£38,500+ attractive benefits
    Manager, Coventry, c£47,000+ attractive benefits
    Research Manager, Coventry, c£38,500 + attractive benefits
    Qualifications Development Manager, Coventry, c£39,800 + attractive benefits
    Programme & Portfolio Manager, Coventry, c£55,800 + attractive benefits
    Assistant Head of Executive and Committee Services, WANDSWORTH, £49,551 to £52,548
    Project Manager, HACKNEY, £46,701 - £49,452
    Principle Project Manager x 2, HACKNEY, £52,335 - £55,206
    Service Development and Performance Manager, HACKNEY, £42,258 - £44,910
    Head of Access and Options, HACKNEY, £ - £
    Head of Change, WORCESTERSHIRE CC, £75,267 - £83,388 per annum
    Financial Inclusion Manager, London, £33,150 - £39,000
    Neighbourhood Investment Managers, London, £33,150 - £39,000
    Neighbourhood Investment Managers, Cheshire, £31,025 - £36,500
    Programme and Partnership Manager, Cheshire, £33,150 - £39,000
    Director of Research and Evaluation, £55000 - £65000 per annum
    Step Forward Engagement Officer, Birmingham, £18 - £22 per annum
    Decentralised Energy Project Manager, ISLINGTON COUNCIL,£38,283 - £40,966 pa fixed-term to...
    Strategic Director (Community Engagement), CARLISLE, Salary up to £78,000 including car...
    Smarter Travel Richmond Programme Manager, RICHMOND, £52,704 - £55,572
    Partnership Director, COVENTRY, £43,128 - £46,276
    Electoral Services Manager, ST ALBANS, Up to £35,980 inc. pa + £5,000...
    Senior Performance Officer, CAMDEN, £37,851 - £40,506
    Research & Evaluation Analysts - Children's Services,£15 - £16 per hour
    Advisors & Employability Consultants, London, Midlands and Scotland, £26,000 - £31,500
    Community Outreach Co-ordinator, HOUNSLOW, £28,800 - £30,390 pa. Incl
    Influencing Manager, Central London, £36,000 - £40,000
    Deputy Team Managers, WALTHAM FOREST, PO5/6: £38,961 - £43,368
    Head of Overview and Scrutiny, NEWHAM, £47,247 - £57,741 pa inc.
    Senior Partnership Development Officer - Regional Officer, YORK, £27,068 - £31,448 pa
    Policy and Projects Officer, EALING, £44,403 - £46,191 pa inclusive
    Settings Support Team Manager, CROYDON, £41,610 -...
    Head of Schools Asset Support Team, SOLIHULL MBC, £54,475 - £67,431 pa
    Cultural Strategy Officer, CROYDON, £34,542 - £36,306
    Regulatory Project Manager, London, £45,500 - £64,000
    Category Manager - Care & People Services,£50,000 - £52,000
    Director of Sheffield First Partnership Up to £81,645, SHEFFIELD CC, Up to £81,645
    Deputy Team Manager, MILTON KEYNES, £37,206 to £42,786 p.a. + £2,000...
    Assistant Director, NORTH LINCOLNSHIRE COUNCIL, Up to £73,500
    Research and Performance Officer, HOUNSLOW, £29,601 - £31,761 pa incl
    Public Relations and Consultation Manager, REDCAR, £61,973 - £64,487
    Head of Locality Services, HEREFORDSHIRE, £55,000 + Benefits
    Community Safety & Licensing Manager, NEW FOREST DC, £36,733 - £42,972 per annum plus...
    Employee Relations Manager, WANDSWORTH, £43,152 - £45,807 (PO6)
    Principal Constitutional Services Officer, STEVENAGE. £31,754 - £35,430 p.a. plus...
    Head of Evaluation and Analysis (maternity cover),£33k
    Community Safety Officers - UK, COMMUNITY SAFETY SKILLS, £15 - £20 PH
    Neighbourhood Officers - UK, COMMUNITY SAFETY SKILLS, up to £15 per hour Approx
    Head of Training Design, Corporate Services, £53,360 - £65,440
    Head of Asset Management, BEDFORDSHIRE, £47,687 - £52,023 pa
    Head of Asset Management, BEDFORDSHIRE, £47,687 - £52,023 pa
    Performance & Information Officer - Social Care & Partnerships, WINDSOR, £31,795 - £35,255 pa
    Public Relations and Consultation Manager, REDCAR & CLEVELAND BC, £61,973 - £64,487
    Chair,£40,000 per annum (6 days per month)
    Senior Head of Tourism and Leisure, EASTBOURNE BC, Up to £65,500 p.a. plus car...
    Senior Director - Schools & Lifelong Learning, ROTHERHAM MBC, Up to £82,000 pa
    Director - Safeguarding & Corporate Parenting, ROTHERHAM MBC, Up to £80,000 pa
    Safeguarding Manager, BEDFORDSHIRE, £39,855 - £43,351
    Head of Learning Disabilities/Mental Health, BEDFORDSHIRE, £57,803 - £62,139
    Head of Older People & Physical Disabilities, BEDFORDSHIRE, £57,803 - £62,139
    Project Manager – Service Review, GLOUCESTERSHIRE, £45,243 - £49,728 per annum
    Children's Centre Extended Services Managers, BRENT, Up to £39,855 p.a. inc. + £1,740 LW
    Safeguarding Adults Manager, SANDWELL, £42,505 - £45,220
    Project Development Manager (Economic Development – Enterprise), SOUTHWARK, £35,739 - £41,841
    Street Scene Enforcement Officer-East London, £18-20 per hour
    Smoke free and Workplace Health Coordinator –London, £34,500
    Community Neighbourhood Manager, ST ALBANS CITY AND DISTRICT, Up to £35,985 pa inc. + Car Option
    Health, Safety & Security Manager-West London,£35-45,000

    you forgot to add these very highly paid front line jobs



    Administrative Assistant JCP

    Salary
    £13110 - £14420

    Administrative Officer JCP (aka the ones that do all the processing at HMRC, Jobcentre, DVLA, plus they are the ones that get verbally and physically abused, spat at, and stabbed in some cases as front line jobcentre staff)
    Salary
    £ 15258 - £17800

    very attractive salary (most aren't even on £17k try the the lower end! )

    idiot!
  • Old_Slaphead
    Old_Slaphead Posts: 2,749 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Combo Breaker
    edited 27 November 2009 at 10:22AM
    wxmlad wrote: »
    Administrative Officer JCP (aka the ones that do all the processing at HMRC, Jobcentre, DVLA, plus they are the ones that get verbally and physically abused, spat at, and stabbed in some cases as front line jobcentre staff)
    Salary
    £ 15258 - £17800

    very attractive salary (most aren't even on £17k try the the lower end! )

    idiot!

    Seems decent enough salary (unless you work in a big city like London).

    Add of another 20% for the pension = £20,000pa

    No-one working in the offices of my manufacturing company doing a similar clerical job is getting paid that (most are on £14,000-£16,000 no pension). Try looking in recruitment agency shop windows....not that many non-specialist clerical jobs are offering £20k+

    nb my experience of working in civil service was that as soon as a 'customer' turns nasty you immediately call for the manager to deal with.

    Anyway, no-one's quibbling about the lower paid staff - it's the middle/senior management gravytrain that needs sharply cutting back.
  • tek-monkey
    tek-monkey Posts: 1,434 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Combo Breaker
    Why add 20% for the pension?
  • Old_Slaphead
    Old_Slaphead Posts: 2,749 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Combo Breaker
    edited 27 November 2009 at 10:26AM
    tek-monkey wrote: »
    Why add 20% for the pension?

    Because that's the effective employer contribution and a FS pension is part of the total remuneration package. Unions tell us that pensions are really simply deferred pay.
  • vivatifosi wrote: »
    For me the big issue is retirement age. You can't compare 11% contributions to lower contributions for other public sector workers who are retiring 10 years later. I'm a pension fund trustee and it is hugely more expensive to provide a pension for someone who is retiring at 55 than for someone retiring at 65. I'm not suggesting that police should work until 65, but there are very good reasons why the pension contributions are high. FWIW I think the police pension is a pretty good deal for those who will be able to claim it.

    Why not? :confused:

    All we hear these days is that the police are snowed under with paperwork, perhaps there is a case that experienced officers over 55 could take on this mountain of paperwork, releasing the younger officers to do the leg work.
    "I can hear you whisperin', children, so I know you're down there. I can feel myself gettin' awful mad. I'm out of patience, children. I'm coming to find you now." - Harry Powell, Night of the Hunter, 1955.
  • I understand that my local authority (and many more) actually payout more on police pensions that they do paying the wages of the current force.
This discussion has been closed.
Meet your Ambassadors

🚀 Getting Started

Hi new member!

Our Getting Started Guide will help you get the most out of the Forum

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 352.1K Banking & Borrowing
  • 253.6K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
  • 454.2K Spending & Discounts
  • 245.1K Work, Benefits & Business
  • 600.7K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
  • 177.5K Life & Family
  • 258.9K Travel & Transport
  • 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
  • 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
  • 37.6K Read-Only Boards

Is this how you want to be seen?

We see you are using a default avatar. It takes only a few seconds to pick a picture.