We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.
This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Poundland Robbery! Spent £6.00. Charged £7.50 by my bank!
Comments
-
... tend to agree ... and not all charities are the same ... I also dislike chuggers inside the exit door at my local Lidl.@Rosa_Damascena said:
Donation towards which cause exactly? I think this is a sneaky tactic by retailers that should be outlawed. When you complete a transaction you want to pay and get the hell out, so this kind of opportunistic request is likely to get a push on the green button before it is read properly.YoungBlueEyes said:I was in £land this morning, and when I asked the woman on the till she said that the ‘suggested donation’ that comes up before you enter your pin is £1.50.
Regarding the green button ... if it's similar to other retailers you have to touch either the green or red button to continue ... a perfect opportunity for a mistake.3 -
Totally agree.Rosa_Damascena said:
Donation towards which cause exactly? I think this is a sneaky tactic by retailers that should be outlawed. When you complete a transaction you want to pay and get the hell out, so this kind of opportunistic request is likely to get a push on the green button before it is read properly.YoungBlueEyes said:I was in £land this morning, and when I asked the woman on the till she said that the ‘suggested donation’ that comes up before you enter your pin is £1.50.
"suggested donation" they haven't a clue about what I can or can't afford. I would have a suggestion on what they do with their machine.
Let's Be Careful Out There1 -
Agree. I'll choose my charities, not have them pushed on to me.Rosa_Damascena said:Donation towards which cause exactly? I think this is a sneaky tactic by retailers that should be outlawed. When you complete a transaction you want to pay and get the hell out, so this kind of opportunistic request is likely to get a push on the green button before it is read properly.3 -
I can sort of see the logic in it - I worked front of house in hospitality (pubs and coffee shops) for the first half of my 20's, back then people mostly paid in cash and the charity boxes were always pretty full. As we move to using less cash, the charities themselves are probably pushing for this sort of thing. I'm sure the shops don't mind the tax breaks or whatever for 'their' donations - and like most here I do pick and choose my charity donations instead of random shop ones. I just wouldn't assume it's all poundland (and others!) being evil, and not the charities missing all the spare change.4
-
For a number of weeks, M&S had started doing the same but the last time I was in, it didn’t ask me so perhaps the feedback was pretty negative.Mnoee said:I can sort of see the logic in it - I worked front of house in hospitality (pubs and coffee shops) for the first half of my 20's, back then people mostly paid in cash and the charity boxes were always pretty full. As we move to using less cash, the charities themselves are probably pushing for this sort of thing. I'm sure the shops don't mind the tax breaks or whatever for 'their' donations - and like most here I do pick and choose my charity donations instead of random shop ones. I just wouldn't assume it's all poundland (and others!) being evil, and not the charities missing all the spare change.Northern Ireland club member No 382 :j1 -
The charity thing happens at petrol stations too.0
-
It's pretty widespread now I think. Mnoee's point is good - that charities are missing out on the bits of change people would pop into the chuggers, but I don't like this new set-up. I have a couple of charities that I donate to, but I don't click the 'continue with suggested donation' button when I'm tapping my card.
What I do not like is the reaction you occasionally get - whaddya mean no?! Everyone donates! - type thing. Or when you're stood there with your tenner clearly in view and they say 'card machine's ready for you', and then huff and puff and sigh like pressing a couple of buttons to undo it is killing them. Cynical me wonders if they're on kickbacks
Anyway. OP are you any further forward with your discrepancy...?"One has to free oneself from the illusion that international climate change policy is environmental policy. Instead, climate change policy is about how we redistribute de facto the world's wealth." - Ottmar Edenhofer, IPCC economist, interviewed at COP162 -
Having worked on shop floors, there are many metrics placed on colleagues, but the only incentives are really top colleague this or that certificates for the shop/region/UK, perhaps once a month and then a ceremony once a year with low value prizes.@YoungBlueEyes said:It's pretty widespread now I think. Mnoee's point is good - that charities are missing out on the bits of change people would pop into the chuggers, but I don't like this new set-up. I have a couple of charities that I donate to, but I don't click the 'continue with suggested donation' button when I'm tapping my card.
What I do not like is the reaction you occasionally get - whaddya mean no?! Everyone donates! - type thing. Or when you're stood there with your tenner clearly in view and they say 'card machine's ready for you', and then huff and puff and sigh like pressing a couple of buttons to undo it is killing them. Cynical me wonders if they're on kickbacks
Anyway. OP are you any further forward with your discrepancy...?2 -
Sorry my post wasn't all that clear now I read it again. I meant the shop/chain gets a kickback rather than the till person. So they get a few pence in the pound of every donation that goes through. Maybe."One has to free oneself from the illusion that international climate change policy is environmental policy. Instead, climate change policy is about how we redistribute de facto the world's wealth." - Ottmar Edenhofer, IPCC economist, interviewed at COP161
-
... Thanks YBE I don't think your wrong ... however I think till colleagues would be 'rated' on performance via targets set by store management in their start of shift "huddles", which are very important.@YoungBlueEyes said:Sorry my post wasn't all that clear now I read it again. I meant the shop/chain gets a kickback rather than the till person. So they get a few pence in the pound of every donation that goes through. Maybe.
If you haven't been in retail you would be amazed at the tactics and pressure to achieve results. It is generally only the managers and above who receive financial incentives, but there are many freebies and discounts around for selling orientated retailers.3
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 352.4K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.7K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 454.4K Spending & Discounts
- 245.4K Work, Benefits & Business
- 601.3K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 177.6K Life & Family
- 259.3K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards



