We'd like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum... Read More »
We're aware that some users are experiencing technical issues which the team are working to resolve. See the Community Noticeboard for more info. Thank you for your patience.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
General Discussion and Whimsical Banter
Options
Comments
-
@ToastLady said:@callum9999 said:It would be nice to know exactly why the banks have closed my accounts but I'm slightly torn on this one in that I can see both sides of the argument. On the one hand knowing the specific reasons behind the account closures would be useful in order to take steps to avoid being banned from other banks and the lack of a clear answer to the question "exactly why has this bank closed my account?" is pretty frustrating I've found. On the flip side though if the bank closes the account due to fraud/money laundering and the bank told the customer that this was the reason behind the closure it would give criminals the chance to destroy/cover up any evidence or warn others involved with the same crime. If a bank had to give a reason for account closures then if someone receives no explanation the implication would be that the account was closed due to suspected criminal activity and this may potentially end up tipping off criminals.
Do we trust the banks to get it right? How can we complain to the Financial Ombudsman?
As we have seen there have been knock on consequences of account closures where the worst has been presumed, perhaps understandably, by other banks etc.
Just imagine if one was sent down for a couple of years but as well as not being present at court you didn't even know what you had been convicted of or even charged with, leaving you with a criminal record.
I think there are questions of lawfulness regarding the conduct of these financial organisations.
As reported in The Daily Telegraph Saturday today Nigel Farage hopes to build a class action lawsuit to include others who "have been wronged", but this will probably have to wait until he comes out of the jungle.
2 -
Bridlington1 said:Thumbs_Up said:I take it you're not a mature student? So basically you are just starting out in life and now you have a life time ban with 3 banking groups.Can't say I'm a member of your fan group. I have read some of you earlier comments about this predicament you have and it did come over as a bit of a jolly jape. Back then you did seem to have the attitude, and to quote a film "frankly my dear I don't give a dam"You are correct, I'm not a mature student at all and at the age of 20 I now find myself banned from 3 banking groups, with a fourth not letting me open new accounts but allowing me to retain the accounts I currently have with them, so probably not my greatest achievement.I admit I've probably come across as sounding a bit unsympathetic and overly harsh in some of my earlier posts in particular, this was not the intention and I can't say I've never intended to come across as a "jolly jape" in any of my posts and I do "give a damn" about this predicament and wouldn't wish it on anyone. At the same time though once you've received a lifetime ban there is precious little you can do to reverse it so I take the view that all you can do is to make the best of it and where possible take reasonable steps to prevent it happening again and attempt to minimise the potential impact that a repeat of the event can have on you.
12 -
pecunianonolet said:Barkin said:pecunianonolet said:
I was advised that aggregating 20k in an usually empty current account within 20 minutes and moving it all straight back out would have for sure triggered a fraud and ML check or even temp freeze.
I've done exactly that - though not with HSBC, admittedly - on numerous occasions, and never had any issues.1 -
With Bitcoin spot ETF about to enter the US market, are there any similar options available to UK investors? It’ll be good to get some exposure to Crypto via ISA / Pension wrappers.0
-
callum9999 said:It would be nice to know exactly why the banks have closed my accounts but I'm slightly torn on this one in that I can see both sides of the argument. On the one hand knowing the specific reasons behind the account closures would be useful in order to take steps to avoid being banned from other banks and the lack of a clear answer to the question "exactly why has this bank closed my account?" is pretty frustrating I've found. On the flip side though if the bank closes the account due to fraud/money laundering and the bank told the customer that this was the reason behind the closure it would give criminals the chance to destroy/cover up any evidence or warn others involved with the same crime. If a bank had to give a reason for account closures then if someone receives no explanation the implication would be that the account was closed due to suspected criminal activity and this may potentially end up tipping off criminals.
I'm certainly no expert when it comes to fraud/money laundering or criminal investigations though and do not know how many people if indeed there are any people who have been convicted of money laundering because of the lack of explanation behind the account closures so do question whether the possibility that a delay in realising why an account has been closed in some instances warrants allowing other account closures to be made without explanation.ToastLady said:callum9999 said:It would be nice to know exactly why the banks have closed my accounts but I'm slightly torn on this one in that I can see both sides of the argument. On the one hand knowing the specific reasons behind the account closures would be useful in order to take steps to avoid being banned from other banks and the lack of a clear answer to the question "exactly why has this bank closed my account?" is pretty frustrating I've found. On the flip side though if the bank closes the account due to fraud/money laundering and the bank told the customer that this was the reason behind the closure it would give criminals the chance to destroy/cover up any evidence or warn others involved with the same crime. If a bank had to give a reason for account closures then if someone receives no explanation the implication would be that the account was closed due to suspected criminal activity and this may potentially end up tipping off criminals.dealyboy said:@ToastLady said:@callum9999 said:It would be nice to know exactly why the banks have closed my accounts but I'm slightly torn on this one in that I can see both sides of the argument. On the one hand knowing the specific reasons behind the account closures would be useful in order to take steps to avoid being banned from other banks and the lack of a clear answer to the question "exactly why has this bank closed my account?" is pretty frustrating I've found. On the flip side though if the bank closes the account due to fraud/money laundering and the bank told the customer that this was the reason behind the closure it would give criminals the chance to destroy/cover up any evidence or warn others involved with the same crime. If a bank had to give a reason for account closures then if someone receives no explanation the implication would be that the account was closed due to suspected criminal activity and this may potentially end up tipping off criminals.
Do we trust the banks to get it right? How can we complain to the Financial Ombudsman?
As we have seen there have been knock on consequences of account closures where the worst has been presumed, perhaps understandably, by other banks etc.
Just imagine if one was sent down for a couple of years but as well as not being present at court you didn't even know what you had been convicted of or even charged with, leaving you with a criminal record.
I think there are questions of lawfulness regarding the conduct of these financial organisations.
As reported in The Daily Telegraph Saturday today Nigel Farage hopes to build a class action lawsuit to include others who "have been wronged", but this will probably have to wait until he comes out of the jungle.
I think you make a compelling case. I do think the banks are getting a bit "trigger happy" when it comes to handing out lifetime bans in general these days and I share your concerns that the banks can and inevitably do make mistakes and am all too aware of some of the impacts that account closures can have. I have also found some of the closures we have seen in recent months to be very concerning and am also of the view that everyone should have the right to have a bank account somewhere, although not every bank should have to offer an account to everyone.At the same time though I can also see some logic behind the argument that if a customer can decide to terminate a banking relationship without explanation then a bank aught to be able to do the same. Indeed from the bank's perspective I can see why few of them would want me as a customer, I tend to use banks solely for their loss leaders and maximise every penny I can get out of them so there is probably little money to be made from my custom, if anything I probably cost many of the banks money so it is understandable that they would want to get rid of me. Whether it is right that a bank should be able to terminate their relationship with a customer if they haven't broken any of their Ts&Cs is something I remain somewhat undecided on though. Banks are becoming increasingly vital to day to day life so I suspect as time goes on the merit of that argument will likely diminish.So as you can probably gather this has become one of the few topics of debate where I have become genuinely undecided on. I am very sympathetic to your position on this issue but at the same time can see some logic to allowing banks to close accounts without explanation in some instances.1 -
Bridlington1 said:callum9999 said:It would be nice to know exactly why the banks have closed my accounts but I'm slightly torn on this one in that I can see both sides of the argument. On the one hand knowing the specific reasons behind the account closures would be useful in order to take steps to avoid being banned from other banks and the lack of a clear answer to the question "exactly why has this bank closed my account?" is pretty frustrating I've found. On the flip side though if the bank closes the account due to fraud/money laundering and the bank told the customer that this was the reason behind the closure it would give criminals the chance to destroy/cover up any evidence or warn others involved with the same crime. If a bank had to give a reason for account closures then if someone receives no explanation the implication would be that the account was closed due to suspected criminal activity and this may potentially end up tipping off criminals.
I'm certainly no expert when it comes to fraud/money laundering or criminal investigations though and do not know how many people if indeed there are any people who have been convicted of money laundering because of the lack of explanation behind the account closures so do question whether the possibility that a delay in realising why an account has been closed in some instances warrants allowing other account closures to be made without explanation.
2 -
Bridlington1 said:I tend to take the information that I get from bank staff with a pinch of salt these days. On a few occasions I've been given incorrect information, notably by Barclays who told me I would be able to switch a TSB student account to a Barclays student account using the CASS, only to be told several weeks later when I opened the account in branch that I wouldn't be able to switch in using the CASS and that I would need to close the TSB account manually and return with proof of account closure. That one ended well. On other occasions I've contacted a bank twice to ask the same question and received two completely different responses.1
-
@Bridlington1 ... https://forums.moneysavingexpert.com/discussion/comment/80397178/#Comment_80397178
... there's a clue there.1 -
So the top end of the EA market continues to rise, albeit gradually, converging on 5.25%...At the same time, the top end of the short term fixed rate market is starting to drop...And also at the same time, the top end of the short term fixes for mortgage rates are starting to decline.Anyone kind enough to explain how this all fits together?I no longer check the forums as regularly as I used to. If you wish to catch my attention please remember to tag me (@ircE) so I get a notification.1
-
No idea ... but excellent thread ircE ... sorry it's caused by a bumpy top ... expectation by the markets of drops in interest rates in the next few months.0
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply

Categories
- All Categories
- 350.9K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.1K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 453.5K Spending & Discounts
- 243.9K Work, Benefits & Business
- 598.8K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 176.9K Life & Family
- 257.2K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.6K Read-Only Boards