NOW OPEN: the MSE Forum 'Ask An Expert' event. This time we'd like your questions on TRAVEL & HOLIDAY DEALS. Post by Wed and deals expert MSE Oli will answer as many as he can.

Why do you bank with your bank?

edited 19 January at 11:31PM in Budgeting & bank accounts
63 replies 3.8K views


  • edited 20 January at 11:22AM
    TimSynthsTimSynths Forumite
    528 Posts
    Third Anniversary 100 Posts Name Dropper Photogenic
    edited 20 January at 11:22AM
    Total bias on my part as ive been working for Lloyds for nearly 20 years and will quite happily see out my days there, but I bank with Lloyds. When I joined I was with First Direct and changing banks took some getting use too.

    With Apps, the internet and phone banking its all so easy now. I have visited a branch once in 18 years- last August to pay a £2.5k cheque as I can only do up to £1k in the app, I had used the Post Office paying in service but they lost the cheque (heard the same from others too) so wont ever use them again.

    My account is free as i'm a member of staff so I get a few benefits too such as AA cover, European travel insurance and a free magazine once a month.

    Product wise I have a savings account too paying over 5% but no other services, even with a staff discount I can insure my home and car elsewhere for less and I use Barclaycard credit card as I get cash back but i'm not a heavy user. I borrowed some money last year to buy double glazing and using a tool on this site got the best rate with ratesetter.

    I like the app and the online functions and I take advantage of open banking too so I can see my Barclaycard on the Lloyds site and also my accounts in Money dashboard. Phonebank wise I think i've called them 4 times in 18 years- twice to replace lost cards, once to see if the above mentioned lost cheque had arrived from the post office and once to auth a transfer to buy some crypto.

    I also have accounts with Revolut, Monzo and Starling for when i'm travelling as they are cheaper to use- mainly use Starling now.

    I'm biased but dead happy with Lloyds- a lot of great people working in the background for you, would I bother changing for £200- no, not worth the hassle or risk if something was to go wrong- I wouldn't sky dive or swim with sharks for the same reasons.
  • KerrehKerreh Forumite
    65 Posts
    Fifth Anniversary 10 Posts Name Dropper Combo Breaker
    I guess I'd go with a combination of inherited selection based on parents banking and lazyness!

    LLoyds - 3 accounts (wages and bills in/out of one, I transfer money into another for monthly grocery/fuel money and the third I park my sinking funds in and move them in/out as required)
    Santander - 1 zero credit card which I understand you can't get anymore but is good for using abroad in terms of charges (I first had an 'Action Saver' account with Abbey National some years/decades ago)
    Natwest - 1 Mortgage (Good rate, obtained through a broker in 2018, I like their service - lovely to talk to on the phone, overpayments easy, app nice to use)

    But for these I've recently started getting somewhere with having some savings so also have:

    Cynergy - 1 Easy Access (I use it as a carpark for some funds), 1 one year fixed bond (I like the interest rate)
    Principality BS - 1 Regular Saver (Christmas Saver) (I like the interest rate) 
    Aim 1:12mth Emergency Fund -> £3988.79/£15000 Aim 2: Car kicks the bucket Fund -> £7260/£17000
  • Bridlington1Bridlington1 Forumite
    1.3K Posts
    1,000 Posts First Anniversary Photogenic Name Dropper
    Perksy5 said:
    Nationwide for the regular saver
    Lloyds for the monthly savers, £50 0% overdraft and the free magazine
    Halifax for the regular saver and the £15/mth for making debit card payments to myself
    TSB for the £5/mth for making debit card payments to myself
    Natwest and RBS for the digital regular savers plus the £3/mth (post fee) for logging into the app and paying out 2 DDs
    Santander for the free railcard and £1.5k 0% student overdraft
    Bank of Scotland for the regular saver
    Virgin money for the exclusive cash ISA and 2% interest on the current account so ideal for paying out cheques.
    HSBC for the regular saver
    Co-op for the refer a friend bonus
    Amex, Tesco bank and Capital one credit cards for the direct debits they provide.
    Hull and East Yorkshire credit union for the £25 bonus on their Christmas saver.
    Metro bank for completeness seen as I've banked with pretty much every other bank so thought, why not? Now it gets used as a nominated account for some savings accounts.

    7 of the above I've had switching incentives out of as well.

    I have savings accounts with about a third to a half of Britain's building societies, largely because of decent paying savings accounts and the fact that many offer the best rates to existing customers and customers with however many year's continuous membership. Plus I have a few savings accounts because they let me make deposits by direct debit or debit card and another load because they offered decent interest rates but have fallen behind so now contain minimal balances in case the rate rises again.

    Used to bank with Barclays for the rainy day saver but they closed my account just weeks after I opened it. I've had a card reader out of them though.

    I am mainly driven by money when it comes to my banking choices so am not too fussed about sentimental reasons/app layout etc. At the end of the day I'll bank with whichever banks gives me an incentive to bank with them.
    I thought I was busy with my 3 or 4 accounts but wow how do you stay on top of all that? No real favourites from any of those?
    Most of those accounts only have a limited number of transactions each month. So in reality it is very little effort once you've plonked everything in the spreadsheet and are able to remember where your money is.

    HSBC is just a case of plonk £250 in the current account on 11th of each month and let the standing order do its work. Ignore the account the rest of the time.
    TSB is just a case of wait till they give me a fiver, then shove £25 in each of their accounts and do 30 x £1 debit card deposits into a savings account from each account.
    Halifax is just a case of bounce £1.5k through my 3 Halifax reward accounts, then do a £500 debit card payment to myself from each and collect the £15 on 12th of the month.
    etc, etc.

    I haven't any real favourites out of the list. I have banks which I dislike for one reason or another, such as TSB as their technical systems are atrocious, particularly when they create new profiles for each current account you open so I've ended up with 4 different internet banking logins, which haven't fully merged.

    Nationwide won't let you change your statement frequency resulting in me getting a statement for the flex regular saver each month when just an annual one would have done. Also their statements don't give references, which is a pain if you've got dozens of bank accounts. Though other than that it's very user friendly.

    There are positives and negatives to all banks I've found and each is better for different purposes. Natwest and RBS have a good app but Lloyds, Halifax and Bank of Scotland have better internet banking. HSBC has the quickest online banking to get into whilst metro bank is the quickest account to open and allows you to get your debit card printed and collected in branch so is useful in case of postal strikes. Santander is great for the student account etc.

    If I had to name a favourite bank I couldn't answer that question. I have some banks I like more than others but no favourite.

    MikeJXE said:
    Rob5342 said:
    MikeJXE said:
    ZeroSum said:
    MikeJXE said:
    I bank with Santander 123 account, I'm advised on here it's not the best but I have been with them about 10 years and never had a problem.

    I don't worry about missing a few pounds and I'm not rich but I am happy and money doesn't equal happiness
    It's more that the full fat version charge extra fees for rubbish interest. 123 lite is a decent account, but it's no longer available to those who haven't already got one.

    Personally, like many on here I don't have a 'main' account. I have different accounts for different things depending on what benefits they offer.
    I don't need to change I'm 82 and don't want the hassle,
    Switching is very simple these days and no' hassle whatsoever. Don't stay with your bank for that reason if you can see a better account.

    Yes I know it is easy to switch but you don't know how good or bad that bank is until you switched to them 

    I have 4 other banks I use for switching rewards but I won't change my main bank it suites me for all my daily needs, all my main DDs go from there

    I have one credit card and pay full amount at the end of the month

    I only have to check 2 statements my bank and my credit card 

    I have 2 savings accounts paying 2.75% and 3.25% One Is with my bank the other a building society in the town. I know there are better but I am happy with these,

    I don't need to chase interest rates, my very rich friend does that and it drives him nuts, he doesn't have a minutes peace, Stressed out because his big investments are sinking, Sits in a cold house because he only allows the heating on for 45 minutes twice a day. I have no doubt he will be gone before me despite him being 8 years younger. 

    Life is easy for me but it doesn't make me rich but I don't need to be 
    You could just open a second current account with one of your existing banks and switch that to get the incentive. If you really dislike that bank you can always switch out again once they've given you the switching incentive but I see little harm in trying a few other banks out. 

    It always amazes me how people manage with only a few accounts. I think I'd go round the twist if I had less than a dozen current accounts plus a load of savings accounts.

    I personally quite enjoy playing the financial tart though to be fair however I appreciate it's not for everyone.
  • edited 21 January at 6:39PM
    LookingForPeaceLookingForPeace Forumite
    75 Posts
    10 Posts Name Dropper
    edited 21 January at 6:39PM
    I have unused accounts with various banks, but I've recently settled on a simpler way because my priorities have changed.

    My one used current account is with Metro, as I like their customer service and can get to a branch if I need to. The app and website are nice and simple, no big banners begging me to take credit cards etc. There's no financial perks like with some other banks, but I personally value having some trust in getting help when I need it over a free magazine or something.

    I then have an easy access, unlimited withdrawal savings account for my emergency fund and short-term savings. Alongside that is a limited access saver for Christmas and holiday savings. Both with YBS - decent enough interest (comparatively), but I'm not changing every 2 minutes for 0.01% extra.

    I choose banks for customer service and simplicity, in summary 😊
  • RobM99RobM99 Forumite
    2.3K Posts
    Sixth Anniversary 1,000 Posts Photogenic Name Dropper
          I changed from Barclays to - remember these ... National Girobank! That progressed to Abbey National ---> Alliance & Leicester ---> Santander as my main account. I also have a basic account with Metro.
          My home town has lost the Nit West, Barclays, Santander branches and now the post office is going (it does exactly what I want). We need yet more charity shops, take-aways and Turkish barbers after all. It must be the only town centre in Britain without a pub or bar. Plenty of new flats (there's a surprise) without the added infrastructure to support the ever-expanding population!. Anyway enough of me moaning (that never happens!). 20/30 please and 107 AFDs in a row (AFD - Alcohol Free Days for the beginner!).
    Now a gainfully employed bassist.
  • subjecttocontractsubjecttocontract Forumite
    848 Posts
    Part of the Furniture 500 Posts Name Dropper Combo Breaker
    Mainly I hold bank accounts that either pay good interest or that provide a savings account that offers an attractive interest rate.
  • DullGreyGuyDullGreyGuy Forumite
    4.6K Posts
    1,000 Posts Name Dropper
    Myself and now ex used to work for a bank group and so had staff accounts with them as you got the packaged account at no charge. The bank was bad at stopping the benefit when you left employment so continued with that after both leaving that job and the Ex.

    Ex got into financial difficulty and bad debt and as we still had a joint loan (I was paying, fully up to date) was told I was no longer welcome as a customer. Therefore based on the accounts available at the time, my newly increased income and needing to find something quickly I switched to Barclays for my main account. 

    Have looked a few times to switch but never found anyone offering anything more interesting... HSBC admitted they made a mistake about what they could offer (US accounts), First Direct were appalling service, Handlesbanken didnt offer anything for their fees.

    Whilst Barclays are the main bank have plenty of other accounts... Starling for international cash needs, Chase for a savings above the higher rates but limited values with barclays etc. 
  • AmityNeonAmityNeon Forumite
    646 Posts
    500 Posts Name Dropper
    Financial rewards.
    I budget independently from accounts so I don't use pots.

    No institution provides every feature I want, but I hold accounts with the majority of retail banking institutions so I use whichever is convenient based on need.
    • NatWest: coin/cash deposits, and my local branch is a 2-minute walk away
    • Chase: scheduled payments/standing orders on non-working days from a high-interest account
    • Kroo/Monzo/Starling (and non-bank Revolut): payment convenience, e.g. physically Nearby, bill split, web links
    • Metro Bank: Sunday branch service (not that I've had to use it, but it's there just in case)
    Accounts I would avoid for 'main' banking:
    • Co-op Bank: no card controls, no open banking, overall dated systems
    • TSB: technical fiascos, poor online banking management; they obviously haven't innovated since splitting from LBG
    • Kroo: symbols aren't allowed in payment references (not even hyphens)
    • Virgin Money: standing orders don't appear (or get deleted) promptly; you may have to wait until the next working day for anything to be reflected in the interface
  • edited 20 January at 1:18PM
    StrictGold5208StrictGold5208 Forumite
    959 Posts
    500 Posts Second Anniversary Name Dropper Photogenic
    edited 20 January at 1:18PM
    Lots of factors. My mood, the feel I get off the bank, and practice day to day stuff. 

    I am currently with Barclays, because I wanted to try them out for a year. However they refuse to give me an overdraft currently so that annoys me. They also limit their overdrafts to £1000. They suggest getting a Premier account to get more, but want to charge £20 a month or not, I don't really understand the requirements, because I don't earn 75k a year but they keep suggesting the account to me, yet say no to any kind of overdraft. And there is no financial reason for this as I am in good standing. I may go back to RBS who I left because they closed all the branches, but banked with previously to Barclays.

    Prior to that I banked with HSBC (I opened at my local brach and actually met the bank manager when opening my account do to a fluke in my online application) I may go back to HSBC as with the RBS account, I still have it open with them. I left HSBC because they closed the local branch, however I now have a mortgage with them so perhaps it's prior better to have it all under one roof, but they took away my overdraft obviously as I was not using the account.

    Prior to that I banked with Lloyds, who I left because they had a very bizarre attitude on the phone in relation to my account, it just put my back up. Ironically their branch is still open for the time being. I briefly had an account with TSB also. But again I just didn't like the bank and the feel it gave me. Similar with Halifax, I had a secondary account with them.

    And before that it was my very first account at Abbey National, I left that bank because they had really terrible staff who were rude and unprofessional. Out of all of them, I must say was probably HSBC was the best. Both HSBC and RBS refunded when there was fraud on my cards of some £2000. So RBS would have to take second place. Santander were the worst! And Halifax almost as bad.

    Despite what some people have suggested on here, all these accounts had no baring whatsoever on getting a mortgage. Providing all your accounts are in good standing.

    *ps I know what an overdraft is and how to use one thank you. 
  • Eco_MiserEco_Miser Forumite
    4.6K Posts
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper Combo Breaker
    Perksy5 said:

    So, why do you bank with your bank?  Sentimental reasons? A feature you like? Maybe it's the UI of their app? 

    Back in 1955 the Yorkshire Penny Bank ran a school bank in the primary school I'd just become a pupil of. That account is long closed, but the current account I opened with them in 1970 is currently paying 2%, with access to a 3% flexible cash ISA. So sentiment or good returns or laziness?
    I've opened, and often closed, many other accounts with many other banks, for higher interest and or switching bonuses or other rewards, but I've kept that first proper adult current account, sometimes with only a nominal amount in as some other bank was paying more.

    Eco Miser
    Saving money for well over half a century

Sign In or Register to comment.
Latest MSE News and Guides

Energy Price Cap change

Martin Lewis on what it means for you

MSE News

Best £1 you've ever spent?

Share your most impressive bargains

MSE Forum