Ready, steady… save!
You don’t need a chart to join in. Here are 2 ways to record your savings:
1. Cross it off
Pop a chart into your first post. Saved an amount? Cross it out! Read more »
£0.01 £0.02 £0.03
2. Write it down
Skip the chart and add updates to your first post. Read more »
“Another +£3 saved today. Go me!”
Use +£ before each new saving so it counts towards your total.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Energy news in general
Comments
-
ludicrous. The green transition must happen for energy security , cost reduction and environmental protection. Glad your not running the country!
4 -
Agree with most of that, where I disagree is that some how net zero doesn't mean we will have periods where we (have to) burn lots of gas.
Initial expectation is about 5% of annual power consumption in a 'typical weather' year. So perhaps about 20 days of dankenflaute?
I think....1 -
Must Happen
Even if you agree with that - and bearing i mind I do - but eventually - I even used to work on renewables power - it does not need to happen at the pace - and so cost - being imposed on UK households and businesses.
Why can nations like Germany make pragmatic decisions to utilize their coal reserves for another decade - but we closed our last coal plant 2 years ago - at the same time they were recommissioning and operating theirs.
Energy security.
You have seriously got to go and study the reality of the precarious grid balancing in UK - thanks to over reliance on others (often foreign companies often using chinese technology) investing in unreliable renewables for their profit.
The UK has not been so regularly energy insecure in terms of ability to supply electricity in last 50 years plus - since unions brought us the 3 day week - by starving our generation plants of coal in 70s.
Our dependence in interconnects for import occurring far too regularly. And the problem is our "dankelflautes" - as the name suggests - our even longer atmospheric wind blocks (upto 7-10 days at a time in winter and summer alike) - are shared by many of the European nations feeding those interconnects (or buying likes of French nuclear output too) - and likely to be struggling with their own growing dependence on renewables. (Franc3 itself current short term target is 10% lower nuclear in mix)
And that lack of generation security in no small part thanks to green policy and green objection to nuclear.
We have decades of coal, oil and gas - going to waste - more so if Rosebank not granted - but happily import others productions - often itself produced to a lower environmental standard.
Cost reduction - when ?
There are essentially 3 wars going on right now - Ukraine, Iran and that has now spread to Yemen/Saudi - impacting UK and European gas pricing - and yet renewables is yet to deliver cheaper power to our meters.
Thanks to ludicrous levies like £122 RO as upto April on bills, still being paid - just c£92 via taxes/ deficits / £30 bills.
Of course that largely only impacted electricity prices - so the 85% on mains gas for their heating werent so worried by that - or apparently the CO2 emissions from their home gas boilers.
And CfD rates for modern renewables especially off shore wind long past ar4 lows - and like increasingly set above normal wholesale market rates (despite still elevated by Ukraine war ) - like the premium paid for offshore wind in ar7 in 2025 - despite now a 20 yr not 15 yr profit guarantee.
So all to often UKs renewables rush - leading to
- supply more expensive to generate at wholesale,
- more expensive to connect
and
- more expensive to transmit to our doors.
Not to mention £100s millions per annum in curtailment to wind farm operators.
The not treble but quadruple whammy of the UKs out of sync and rushed renewables roll out.
Environmental protection
Every barrel of oil we import, every ton of LPG - transported thousands of miles at additional environmental cost - and we will still be shipping it in after 2050.
UK total MTCO2e sub 1% is already pretty small in global terms - and getting smaller by the day as the world adds on average well over 60 million in population every year from 2015 to 2050. 2.4 bn in total UN central projection.
Almost everyday UK has part of he emissions from USA and Canada blown over it - c 6x the population and around 3x the emissions per capita - 18x the levels generated in UK. USA not even under Paris accord currently.
Even if electricity was 100% carbon free - we would reduce our 0.8% of global emmissions by just 0.08%.
WE never will - because it doesn't matter how much renewables you add at any sensible affordable scale - on days like Sunday with its low output - it will produce virtually no meanigful contribution to UK power demand
To meet full UK peak demand - based on Sundays sub 2,5% output - you would have needed 40x the wind theoretical capacity - over 1600GW - to supply c40GW demand.
Solar produces zero for upto 16 hrs in winter, often not covering peak demand c5pm at all.
The hard truths that the green lobby now need to grasp if serious about eliminating fossil or even making investment in installed renewables more usable.
And the idea of not only maintaining but now actually as wecare having to replace aging 10s GW of gas plant as a standy by fleet of generation - like the 20.x GW on average for Sunday - for "occassional use" again just makes the fixed cost component of gas generation more expensive.
So a quintouple whammy in fact.
And the cost of adding storage to do anything about renewables unreliablility hour to hour day to day - again unaffordable at future required generation scale.
The sextuple whammy of costs.
We should cancel all new wind and grid solar - and start building more storage for what we already have in place and far more nuclear generation instead. 10s GW more modern nuclear with its designed in load following capacity.
And if we do so now - at a far more serious pace - we will be in a far better position to meet our 2050 net zero commitments - than more of the same current unreliable (intermittent) wind or solar will ever allow.
Because right now the reality is that for every GW of new net zero demand we are going to be adding - for gch to ashp, for ice to ev, as stands looks like we plan not just additional GW (on average industry capacity factors not lows) c3GW minimum - but 1GW of nuclear and or gas to replace it when it fails to deliver.
So why continue to do both ?
4 -
With all the new wind and solar already in the pipeline (AR7) we are on target to hit 85% zero carbon by 2030. The last 15, then 10 then 5% becomes exponentially more costly to achieve. The transmission grid is already struggling with the renewables we have and while on paper we might be able to commission more renewables to hit 95%, the cost in grid upgrades and constraints makes it uneconomic if one considers the benefit the same money might achieve spent on fossil fuel reduction elsewhere in the economy. For instance, phasing out gas cooking would produce CO2 savings of 8-18 % points of the electric power sector’s CO2 emissions and would also eliminate fugitive methane emissions plus we would also reduce NO2 emissions and considerably improve public health. That would though be a real political hot potato.
Northern Lincolnshire. 7.8 kWp system, (4.2 kWwest facing panels , 3.6 kWeast facing), Solis inverters installed 2018, 5kW SSE facing system (shaded in afternoon) added in 2025 with Tesla PW3 battery, Mitsubishi SRK35ZS-S and SRK20ZS-S Wall Mounted A2A Heat Pumps, ex Nissan Leaf owner.0 -
With all the new wind and solar already in the pipeline (AR7) we are on target to hit 85% zero carbon by 2030.
I think that's 85% zero carbon electricity? Not total UK energy? So there's still plenty of scope to reduce oil and gas consumption, and that's likely to be replaced by electricity, so requiring more generation and transmission capacity.
For instance, phasing out gas cooking
While I don't have any statistics to hand, I would expect that most gas cooking is done in locations that also have gas heating. So gas cooking is likely to be phased out at a similar rate to gas heating (not quite as fast as you'll have the occasional kitchen that retains gas even when the heating switches to electricity).
That would though be a real political hot potato.
Putting cooking puns to one side for a minute, would it really be a political problem? Out of my immediate family, I think I'm the only one with a gas stove (unless you count my parents' campervan). How many people are going to march in the streets if they're told their next stove will have to be electric?
N. Hampshire, he/him. Octopus Intelligent Go elec / Fuse gas / Vodafone BB / iD mobile. Kirk Hill Co-op member.Economy 7 cap explainer. Gas vs E7 vs peak elec heating costs, Ecoflow Stream, Best kettle :-)
2.72kWp PV facing SSW installed Jan 2012. 11 x 247w panels, 3.6kw inverter. 37 MWh generated, long-term average 2.6 Os.2 -
Domestic gas use uses c14-15 of UK gas use total 22% of official MTCO2e emissions as of last gov data set i read
Electricity generation 10%.
Time gas heating felt the pain of its dirty emissions, the way electric heating has for decades.
Before Apr RO alone was nearly 15% of my electricity costs per annum in all electric home.
On unit rates 3.54p inc vat on every kWh.
Then add modern renewables CfD- c£39 ex vat in April at cap tdcv in wholesale costs..
Then add 0.71p - upto 3% for FIT etc.
Then add network connection costs in £bns pa, curtailment running at up to £7m per day direct to farm operators, higher CMS abd balancing costs etc all hidden in network costs - and as some of that infrastruture - added to our far higher - near double electricity vs gas - standing charges.
All for renewables that have never once reduced my bills by a penny even at height of Ukraine pricing.
And even more true - never on average during the 24 years RO has been adding to our bills.
From 2002 in most of UK - until last award 2017 iirc - so running to 2037 iirc - 35 years for old projects.
CfD basis was 15 - now 20. AR7 delivery upto 4 years typically - so c2029 - indexed rates and profits therefore right up to c2049.
0 -
Have to agree with you re the targeting (or lack of) of the UK approach - take Jackdaw. It will do wonders for UK in terms of balance of payments and govt revenue. If that revenue was spent on carbon reduction (things like insulation grants) it could more than outweigh any extra carbon from the extraction and burning of the gas.
Also as mentioned above, squeezing the last few percent out of electricity generation seems to be a much more costly way of achieving the same carbon reduction than for example making gas users pay the full environmental cost of their gas use and using the revenue to support them in moving to lower carbon alternatives like heat pumps and induction hobs. (My current favourite is to support A2A heat pumps, an easier sell as they do cooling as well and leave in the gas which can do the hard bits like hot water and the coldest nights without overstraining the grid but you could still have a 80% reduction in domestic gas use).
I would like to steer clear of the 'but we are too small to matter' argument. It is very easy for that to be extended to: no one might as well try and do anything because on their own it makes no difference - my analogy is litter, I might as well drop my litter as in the scheme of things it will make no odds as to whether the local area looks clean or not.
I think....4 -
Yes I meant 85% zero carbon in electricity generation (not the whole economy).
Gas cooking is more popular in some communities for certain types of traditional dishes and banning gas hobs might be perceived as impacting some communities more than others.
Northern Lincolnshire. 7.8 kWp system, (4.2 kWwest facing panels , 3.6 kWeast facing), Solis inverters installed 2018, 5kW SSE facing system (shaded in afternoon) added in 2025 with Tesla PW3 battery, Mitsubishi SRK35ZS-S and SRK20ZS-S Wall Mounted A2A Heat Pumps, ex Nissan Leaf owner.2 -
True however the government should be phasing out for other reasons too
0 -
Like with many things that carry some "risk to health" they should be taken in the round along with many other lifestyle factors.
How's it going, AKA, Nutwatch? - rolling 12 month spends to date = 2.85% of current retirement "pot" (as at end October 2026)0
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 355.9K Banking & Borrowing
- 255K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 456.2K Spending & Discounts
- 248.5K Work, Benefits & Business
- 606.2K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 179.1K Life & Family
- 264K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards


