PLEASE READ BEFORE POSTING: Hello Forumites! In order to help keep the Forum a useful, safe and friendly place for our users, discussions around non-MoneySaving matters are not permitted per the Forum rules. While we understand that mentioning house prices may sometimes be relevant to a user's specific MoneySaving situation, we ask that you please avoid veering into broad, general debates about the market, the economy and politics, as these can unfortunately lead to abusive or hateful behaviour. Threads that are found to have derailed into wider discussions may be removed. Users who repeatedly disregard this may have their Forum account banned. Please also avoid posting personally identifiable information, including links to your own online property listing which may reveal your address. Thank you for your understanding.
We're aware that some users are experiencing technical issues which the team are working to resolve. See the Community Noticeboard for more info. Thank you for your patience.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!

Non disclosure of property defects - Sound Proofing and drainage issues

Options
We bought a semi detached 1950's bungalow that we moved into in March this year. Since living there we have noticed that noise travels through the walls more than we expected. Whilst our neighbour isn't particularly loud as an individual and is just living a semi social life we can hear conversations and music word for word some times.

 She recently revealed to us that the previous owners complained a lot about the sound issues and even slept in the back smaller bedroom as a result. We had wonder why when we viewed the property they were using the smaller room as their master bedroom but it makes sense now as it's at the back on the detached side so sound would be less. Also she said they had people go round her house with decibel readers and that they had soundproofing added to the walls. She said she had to have builders in her house as a result and it was a bit of a nightmare as it caused tension between them.

 Now non of this was disclosed to us when purchasing the property so are they in breech of non disclosure as they have had remedial work (not very good work as it's still rather loud) and a neighbour dispute? Would we have a case against them for this.  

Additionally our house nearly flooded the other day due to the heavy rain and it turns out the property has some drainage issues under larger volumes of water. This didn't show up on surveys as under normal conditions the drains work fine. When speaking to Southern Water they confirmed that they had been called out to the property before but due to GDPR couldn't confirm the nature of the call out. We don't believe that they had never experienced that before and again all the neighbours in the are have said they suffer flooding in heavy water downpours so could this be another thing they did not disclose?  
«13

Comments

  • Neither of those things they had to disclose, move on and fix them if they are that bad.
  • user1977
    user1977 Posts: 17,780 Forumite
    10,000 Posts Seventh Anniversary Photogenic Name Dropper
    Under which specific enquiry(ies) do you think these matters ought to have been disclosed, and what were the answers given?
  • MaryNB
    MaryNB Posts: 2,319 Forumite
    1,000 Posts Third Anniversary Name Dropper

     She recently revealed to us that the previous owners complained a lot about the sound issues and even slept in the back smaller bedroom as a result. We had wonder why when we viewed the property they were using the smaller room as their master bedroom but it makes sense now as it's at the back on the detached side so sound would be less. Also she said they had people go round her house with decibel readers and that they had soundproofing added to the walls. She said she had to have builders in her house as a result and it was a bit of a nightmare as it caused tension between them.

     Now non of this was disclosed to us when purchasing the property so are they in breech of non disclosure as they have had remedial work (not very good work as it's still rather loud) and a neighbour dispute? Would we have a case against them for this.  

    They should have disclosed the complaints on the TA6 Property Information Form

    Have there been any disputes or complaints regarding this property or a property nearby? If Yes, please give details:
  • It doesn't sound like something serious enough to go down on a TA6 as a dispute - if a neighbour complained I was a little noisy at times I wouldn't put it down either. 
    Drains are also a non-issue, as long as they work correctly during 'normal' weather I'd say that's good enough. 

    You bought a 60 year old house, if you want a new house with a warranty then buy a new-build. 
    Unfortunately older stuff (including houses) usually comes with an issue or two. 

    Some people are also more sensitive to noise than others - I had to buy detached and lower my expectations in terms of space as I'm quite intolerant of neighbour noise.
  • MaryNB
    MaryNB Posts: 2,319 Forumite
    1,000 Posts Third Anniversary Name Dropper
    It doesn't sound like something serious enough to go down on a TA6 as a dispute - if a neighbour complained I was a little noisy at times I wouldn't put it down either. 
    Drains are also a non-issue, as long as they work correctly during 'normal' weather I'd say that's good enough. 

    You bought a 60 year old house, if you want a new house with a warranty then buy a new-build. 
    Unfortunately older stuff (including houses) usually comes with an issue or two. 

    Some people are also more sensitive to noise than others - I had to buy detached and lower my expectations in terms of space as I'm quite intolerant of neighbour noise.
    Given the seller appeared to have noise consultants out, the neighbour had to have builders in to mitigate the issue and it caused tension between them I would say that it would very difficult to argue that there was no complaint about a nearby property. Whether they are over sensitive to noise or not doesn't change the fact that it appeared to be a fairly significant issue between the neighbours. The question is very open - have there been any disputes or complaints and the neighbour very much confirmed this. If they were still sleeping in the smaller room at the time of the viewing it would indicate that the issue wasn't resolved. 
  • MaryNB said:
    It doesn't sound like something serious enough to go down on a TA6 as a dispute - if a neighbour complained I was a little noisy at times I wouldn't put it down either. 
    Drains are also a non-issue, as long as they work correctly during 'normal' weather I'd say that's good enough. 

    You bought a 60 year old house, if you want a new house with a warranty then buy a new-build. 
    Unfortunately older stuff (including houses) usually comes with an issue or two. 

    Some people are also more sensitive to noise than others - I had to buy detached and lower my expectations in terms of space as I'm quite intolerant of neighbour noise.
    Given the seller appeared to have noise consultants out, the neighbour had to have builders in to mitigate the issue and it caused tension between them I would say that it would very difficult to argue that there was no complaint about a nearby property. Whether they are over sensitive to noise or not doesn't change the fact that it appeared to be a fairly significant issue between the neighbours. The question is very open - have there been any disputes or complaints and the neighbour very much confirmed this. If they were still sleeping in the smaller room at the time of the viewing it would indicate that the issue wasn't resolved. 
    Only if the complaint goes down the legal/written route which hasn't been confirmed.
  • What do you want them to do about it? Pay for remedial work? Might help if you had an idea what that might cost.
  • user1977
    user1977 Posts: 17,780 Forumite
    10,000 Posts Seventh Anniversary Photogenic Name Dropper
    MaryNB said:
    It doesn't sound like something serious enough to go down on a TA6 as a dispute - if a neighbour complained I was a little noisy at times I wouldn't put it down either. 
    Drains are also a non-issue, as long as they work correctly during 'normal' weather I'd say that's good enough. 

    You bought a 60 year old house, if you want a new house with a warranty then buy a new-build. 
    Unfortunately older stuff (including houses) usually comes with an issue or two. 

    Some people are also more sensitive to noise than others - I had to buy detached and lower my expectations in terms of space as I'm quite intolerant of neighbour noise.
    Given the seller appeared to have noise consultants out, the neighbour had to have builders in to mitigate the issue and it caused tension between them I would say that it would very difficult to argue that there was no complaint about a nearby property. Whether they are over sensitive to noise or not doesn't change the fact that it appeared to be a fairly significant issue between the neighbours. The question is very open - have there been any disputes or complaints and the neighbour very much confirmed this. If they were still sleeping in the smaller room at the time of the viewing it would indicate that the issue wasn't resolved. 
    Only if the complaint goes down the legal/written route
    No, that's not what the question asks. In fact it's not even restricted to written complaints, or complaints which have actually been made - it includes things which you know are likely to lead to a complaint.
  • MaryNB
    MaryNB Posts: 2,319 Forumite
    1,000 Posts Third Anniversary Name Dropper
    MaryNB said:
    It doesn't sound like something serious enough to go down on a TA6 as a dispute - if a neighbour complained I was a little noisy at times I wouldn't put it down either. 
    Drains are also a non-issue, as long as they work correctly during 'normal' weather I'd say that's good enough. 

    You bought a 60 year old house, if you want a new house with a warranty then buy a new-build. 
    Unfortunately older stuff (including houses) usually comes with an issue or two. 

    Some people are also more sensitive to noise than others - I had to buy detached and lower my expectations in terms of space as I'm quite intolerant of neighbour noise.
    Given the seller appeared to have noise consultants out, the neighbour had to have builders in to mitigate the issue and it caused tension between them I would say that it would very difficult to argue that there was no complaint about a nearby property. Whether they are over sensitive to noise or not doesn't change the fact that it appeared to be a fairly significant issue between the neighbours. The question is very open - have there been any disputes or complaints and the neighbour very much confirmed this. If they were still sleeping in the smaller room at the time of the viewing it would indicate that the issue wasn't resolved. 
    Only if the complaint goes down the legal/written route which hasn't been confirmed.
    Neither the TA6 form nor the official guidance states this. Where did you read this? Obviously if there has been an official compliant to the council, police etc you have to put it down - there's no ambiguity there.

    In other instances though it can be open to interpretation. A knock on the door asking someone to turn the music down and the neighbour apologies and complies isn't really an issue. If there is an ongoing noise complaint that involves noise consultants, remedial building work and ongoing tension between neighbours, it is going to be a lot harder to avoid categorising it as a complaint.
  • It doesn't sound like something serious enough to go down on a TA6 as a dispute - if a neighbour complained I was a little noisy at times I wouldn't put it down either. 
    Drains are also a non-issue, as long as they work correctly during 'normal' weather I'd say that's good enough. 

    You bought a 60 year old house, if you want a new house with a warranty then buy a new-build. 
    Unfortunately older stuff (including houses) usually comes with an issue or two. 

    Some people are also more sensitive to noise than others - I had to buy detached and lower my expectations in terms of space as I'm quite intolerant of neighbour noise.
    It's not that we expect no noise at all in a semi detached older property. We previously lived in a 1970's terrace house where we could hear our neighbours although it does seem much more prominent in this house. I also appreciate people will have different sensitivity to noise. Generally we are ok with it but there are times when it's much louder and disrupting.  

    It's more that there clearly has been an issue and work has been carried out but nothing provided to us regarding that work or the issue, especially as it doesn't appear fully rectified. Our neighbour also seemed shocked that we knew nothing about it as she implied it was a pretty big deal. She also has said that we are not supposed to hang anything on the party wall as this will damage the soundproofing. Surely this is something that should have been mentioned on the TA6 form, especially if they have contacted the council regarding sound problems, had people out to measure the sound and building work done on the property as a result? 

    As mentioned above it says: "Have there been any disputes or complaints regarding this property or a property nearby? If Yes, please give details." Whilst rather open surely this does count as a complaint as it resulted in the properties having to have work. 

    The drain issues is slightly separate as we have also discovered our solicitors didn't pick up on an indemnity insurance policy that had been taken out at some point ( not sure if it was Southern Water or a previous owner) regarding flooding from overloaded public sewers.   

Meet your Ambassadors

🚀 Getting Started

Hi new member!

Our Getting Started Guide will help you get the most out of the Forum

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 350.9K Banking & Borrowing
  • 253.1K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
  • 453.5K Spending & Discounts
  • 243.9K Work, Benefits & Business
  • 598.8K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
  • 176.9K Life & Family
  • 257.2K Travel & Transport
  • 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
  • 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
  • 37.6K Read-Only Boards

Is this how you want to be seen?

We see you are using a default avatar. It takes only a few seconds to pick a picture.