EXTENDED: You've got another week to add your travel & holiday deals questions for expert MSE Oli as part of the latest Ask An Expert event.

Are speed checkers honest?

2»

Replies

  • edited 5 August 2021 at 3:48AM
    Marvel1Marvel1 Forumite
    6.9K Posts
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper
    Forumite
    edited 5 August 2021 at 3:48AM
    brandbandspeedchecker give me 4.30Mb - yes I had to run it twice!

    speedtest.net give me 28.43Mb

    Google one gives me 35.4Mb

    Uswitch -  7.8Mb (yet provides me with other companies that are faster.)  Even better I changed my provider to say I had one of  the major ones it provided me on my first one and it changed to 35.4Mb!
  • RetrogamerRetrogamer Forumite
    4.2K Posts
    Tenth Anniversary 1,000 Posts Name Dropper Photogenic
    Forumite
    Also do not do speed tests over wireless, as the results are not reliable.  Always wired.

    The only way to get reliable speed tests from any website these days is to:

    Turn off Wireless on the router
    Have only 1 device connected to the router via ethernet to do speed tests.
    If it's a windows device, boot the device up into Safe Mode with Networking.

    Perform some speed tests on a reputable site over different servers - I like Speedtest.net
    All your base are belong to us.
  • edited 7 August 2021 at 12:22PM
    tallmansixtallmansix Forumite
    1.9K Posts
    1,000 Posts Fourth Anniversary Name Dropper Photogenic
    Forumite
    edited 7 August 2021 at 12:22PM
    Also do not do speed tests over wireless, as the results are not reliable.  Always wired.

    The only way to get reliable speed tests from any website these days is to:

    Turn off Wireless on the router
    Have only 1 device connected to the router via ethernet to do speed tests.
    If it's a windows device, boot the device up into Safe Mode with Networking.

    Perform some speed tests on a reputable site over different servers - I like Speedtest.net
    Or just run the speed test on the router itself which will bypass all the other variables in the PC and LAN.

    Even then it all depends on where the speed test server is located on the internet, your pipe to the ISP might be working at full speed but then the hop to the speed test server itself might then become the bottle neck. 

    For slow internet such as ADSL/VDSL it shouldn't be an issue but when using a proper internet connection with say 500mpbps - to gigabit speeds then a lot of other external factors come into play.

    One thing that is often overlooked is that most cheap routers simply can't achieve those high speeds through the WAN to LAN interface and will crap out well before hitting the maximum line speed.

    But speed tests are only really useful in confirming your ISP is giving you what you pay for in terms of the pipe into your home.
    YNAB enthusiast and extreme coupon-er.
    Discounts, coupons and cashback:
    2019 = £1,443.52
    2020 = £1,191,76
  • RetrogamerRetrogamer Forumite
    4.2K Posts
    Tenth Anniversary 1,000 Posts Name Dropper Photogenic
    Forumite
    Also do not do speed tests over wireless, as the results are not reliable.  Always wired.

    The only way to get reliable speed tests from any website these days is to:

    Turn off Wireless on the router
    Have only 1 device connected to the router via ethernet to do speed tests.
    If it's a windows device, boot the device up into Safe Mode with Networking.

    Perform some speed tests on a reputable site over different servers - I like Speedtest.net
    Or just run the speed test on the router itself which will bypass all the other variables in the PC and LAN.

    Even then it all depends on where the speed test server is located on the internet, your pipe to the ISP might be working at full speed but then the hop to the speed test server itself might then become the bottle neck. 

    For slow internet such as ADSL/VDSL it shouldn't be an issue but when using a proper internet connection with say 500mpbps - to gigabit speeds then a lot of other external factors come into play.

    One thing that is often overlooked is that most cheap routers simply can't achieve those high speeds through the WAN to LAN interface and will crap out well before hitting the maximum line speed.

    But speed tests are only really useful in confirming your ISP is giving you what you pay for in terms of the pipe into your home.
    I've worked for several ISP's over the years and i use a couple of Asus routers in my home instead of the ISP supplied one, but none of these routers are able to run throughput speed tests. You can only view the sync speed and someones the BRAS line profile.

    Which router do you use to run throughput speed tests on?

    Also, that's why i suggested running a test over different servers

    For me, throughput speed tests are helpful as part as fault diagnosis. 

    All your base are belong to us.
  • MattMattMattUKMattMattMattUK Forumite
    6.5K Posts
    1,000 Posts Second Anniversary Name Dropper
    Forumite
    Also do not do speed tests over wireless, as the results are not reliable.  Always wired.

    The only way to get reliable speed tests from any website these days is to:

    Turn off Wireless on the router
    Have only 1 device connected to the router via ethernet to do speed tests.
    If it's a windows device, boot the device up into Safe Mode with Networking.

    Perform some speed tests on a reputable site over different servers - I like Speedtest.net
    The issue with speedtest.net is that sometimes network providers work to specifically prioritise traffic through that site, as well as against the hosts it uses for the tests. It is still the most reliable option around for all but IT professionals with access to multiple high speed connections.

    In reality, despite having lots of devices connected via Wifi and even connecting via wifi or wired it makes little difference to my speed. At home I have 150Mbps fibre and I get within a few percent of that regardless of time of day, number of devices connected etc. At work I have 900Mbps and that caps out within a few percent as well on wired, on wireless it caps out at the max rate of the wifi, I have a Google Nest Wifi as the router on the network both which is ac, no ax kit to test it on that way. 

    I guess issues could occur when someone had problems with their home network or wifi and they thought that was a problem with their broadband speed, but for most people a test over wifi is more than adequate. 
  • tallmansixtallmansix Forumite
    1.9K Posts
    1,000 Posts Fourth Anniversary Name Dropper Photogenic
    Forumite
    Which router do you use to run throughput speed tests on?

    Asus ROG GT-AC5300 - has it built in the firmware.

    However any Linux based router with SSH capability should be able to install something like iPerf3 / Speedtest-cli for example and run it directly on the device.

    For me, throughput speed tests are helpful as part as fault diagnosis. 


    Yes definitely useful but segmenting the speed tests helps determine where to bottleneck is, something like Lan Speed Test can be used between devices on the internal network to determine throughput.
    YNAB enthusiast and extreme coupon-er.
    Discounts, coupons and cashback:
    2019 = £1,443.52
    2020 = £1,191,76
  • RetrogamerRetrogamer Forumite
    4.2K Posts
    Tenth Anniversary 1,000 Posts Name Dropper Photogenic
    Forumite
    Also do not do speed tests over wireless, as the results are not reliable.  Always wired.

    The only way to get reliable speed tests from any website these days is to:

    Turn off Wireless on the router
    Have only 1 device connected to the router via ethernet to do speed tests.
    If it's a windows device, boot the device up into Safe Mode with Networking.

    Perform some speed tests on a reputable site over different servers - I like Speedtest.net
    The issue with speedtest.net is that sometimes network providers work to specifically prioritise traffic through that site, as well as against the hosts it uses for the tests. It is still the most reliable option around for all but IT professionals with access to multiple high speed connections.

    In reality, despite having lots of devices connected via Wifi and even connecting via wifi or wired it makes little difference to my speed. At home I have 150Mbps fibre and I get within a few percent of that regardless of time of day, number of devices connected etc. At work I have 900Mbps and that caps out within a few percent as well on wired, on wireless it caps out at the max rate of the wifi, I have a Google Nest Wifi as the router on the network both which is ac, no ax kit to test it on that way. 

    I guess issues could occur when someone had problems with their home network or wifi and they thought that was a problem with their broadband speed, but for most people a test over wifi is more than adequate. 

    Over the last 14 or so years i've worked for 4 UK based ISPs but none of them either specifically prioritized traffic through that site.

    One of the main problems i got when i done customer tech support was slow speeds on speed tests. Probably accounted for about 70% of the calls coming in. (literally hundreds of calls per week)
    Out of about 70% of those calls. i'd say about 5% or less had an actual issue that was the ISP's responsibility. Other times it was either wifi issues, or other devices saturating the bandwidth. 
    All your base are belong to us.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Latest MSE News and Guides

Energy Price Cap change

Martin Lewis on what it means for you

MSE News

Best £1 you've ever spent?

Share your most impressive bargains

MSE Forum