We'd like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum... Read More »
We're aware that some users are experiencing technical issues which the team are working to resolve. See the Community Noticeboard for more info. Thank you for your patience.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Official MSE Economy 7 Guide discussion
Options
Comments
-
I live in a flat with underfloor heating ( no storage heaters & no gas) Cannot use washing machine /drier at night because of noise am in all day have been told by southern electric my best deal would be economy 10 can anyone tell me if this sounds right?
We also have 1960's underfloor heating with economy 10 tariff which is served by radio switch (a wireless signal) and Southern electric could not tell us the prices when we moved in! Our hours are 4.30am to 2.30pm so we have to use peak rate electric in a panel heater in the evening. We could not find a fixed tariff deal when we moved in May. The radio signal will be turned off "sometime in 2014" at which point they will change/upgrade our meter foc.0 -
It's rubbish and you have even given your prices as 20p/kWh. That is a terrible rate. You would be better off on a standard online managed tariff paid by direct debit using electricity whenever you want with no restrictions. The article mentions average standard rates as 13p/kWh. To save anything (a penny per year) you would have to have a minimum of 60% usage during the off peak hours. To save anything worthwhile considering the hassle factor you would have to have 80% usage on the off peak hours. It's only good if you have a high powered ground source heat pump such as 15kW 3 phase heat pump heating underfloor heating as a background heat and have an alternative heating source outside of the off peak hours such as gas or solid fuel. Moving 80% of your usage to those limited hours is impossible otherwise.
Our yearly peak rate consumption is about 2000KWH and our off peak about 13000KWH. As stated before the off peak is about 6 pence per KWH and peak is about 20 pence per KWH.
We do all our washing/tumble drying/water heating and cooking(when practical) in off peak times. No hassle, just saving about 2000 units at 20 pp unit and paying 6 pp unit. Doesn't sound like rubbish to me.0 -
Our yearly peak rate consumption is about 2000KWH and our off peak about 13000KWH. As stated before the off peak is about 6 pence per KWH and peak is about 20 pence per KWH.
We do all our washing/tumble drying/water heating and cooking(when practical) in off peak times. No hassle, just saving about 2000 units at 20 pp unit and paying 6 pp unit. Doesn't sound like rubbish to me.
Or picking a good tariff online 10,000 * 5.613p plus 5,000 * 12.237p would be £1,173...which is essentially the same cost but you don't need to keep an eye on the time as much. I'd find it highly unlikely that 3,000kWh would move from the off peak rate to the day rate but it gives you some allowance to use a heater in the evening at any time at full day rate. Don't move as much and you can only save.:footie:Regular savers earn 6% interest (HSBC, First Direct, M&S)
Loans cost 2.9% per year (Nationwide) = FREE money.
0 -
Well that makes much more sense. All dual rate "no standing charge" tariffs are being removed from the market and are no longer available to new customers so eventually you will be transferred to a standard single rate tariff so need to be thinking about 11p/kWh rather than 23p/kWh when comparing tariffs.
The washing machine and dishwasher when heating water might use 2kw for the immersion element...then use 0.1kw pumping water or turning the drum. It will vary a lot during the cycle. You need the total usage per cycle figure from the manual to figure out your savings. It might be about 1kWh. The eco cycle on the dishwasher tends to be the long one using a lower water temperature and much lower amounts of power for a longer period of time which would suit a solar panel.
Thanks for this. Actually when comparing tariffs I simply put in my current scheme details and then my usage details although I might play around with the usage figure to account for some level of generation.
I am going to look at the solar panel forum for some more advice but thanks for your help.0 -
John_Pierpoint wrote: »
link removed as I am a new poster - not allowed to post links
Once you are generating your hot water with "free" electricity, further savings are likely to be considerably less than £100 a year, so not worth too much effort.
Your problem could be understanding if the gizmo is busy putting power into the water tank when you want to turn on the washing machine.
I will look at the solar panel forums and many thanks for pointing me in that direction. The gizmo for putting power into the water tank is very easy to see and understand. It is right by the water tank and there is lots of information in the display including the amount of power currently going into the tank (I think this is accompanied by a blue flashing light), the amount of power into the tank today, yesterday, this month and since start)
My generation meter looks similar to yours and has attachment sending a signal to a display so I can see what is being produced at any time. The live wire has two clamps on it (or surrounding it) which produce signals, one to the gizmo for switching on the solar panel generated immersion (see above) and the second for an old e-on usage display.
My importing meter has a cycling display, night, day and total with a little flashing bit to indicate the current being used. I have not had a mechanical clock for a long time (although it was wonderfully out of step with reality when I did have it). My friendly electrician installed a double socket that only runs on cheap/night rate electricity which is quite handy.
I would like to ask why you think that further savings are likely to be less than £100 a year after generating hot water with free electricity but fear that I may be diverting this forum from its Economy 7 focus so I am going to raise the question in the solar panel forum (unless I find the answer there already).
Many thanks for your assistance.0 -
The 40% figure seems far higher than the beak even point in my area (southern).
12000 kWh pa, cheapest = £1519 (£1478 20% E7)
6000 kWh pa, cheapest = £793 (£777 20% E7)
3000 kWh pa, cheapest = £430 (£427 20% E7)
Figures from energy helpline by just giving my post code, those annual kWh figure and then seeing what it says is the cheapest.0 -
New to the forums!
I'm a single person living in a flat that has 1960s underfloor heating. I can't use washing machine at night and work full time so don't benefit from underfloor heating as it's gone cold by the time I'm back from work.
I've read all the posts and replies and think my brain is about to explode!
Can anyone recommend a heating engineer/ company with expert knowledge who could come round and advise me on how to either make better use of the underfloor heating and Economy 7 that I am on, or cut my losses and switch to a new system?
I am currently paying about £400 a quarter to EOn who recently fitted new meters cos they said the old ones needed replacing (so no cost to me).
Thanks folks!0 -
Below are the generalised % spit figures, there are region code variations and all figures are expressed as an 'ish'. They show by supplier the off-peak % use a household needs, to make an E7 tariff more beneficial than a standard tariff. Perhaps someone can fill in any other missing supplier splits they know of !
BG - 45%
Coop- 35%
Ebico - 33%
Ecotricity - 20-35% [region code]
E.On - 34%
npower - 35%
OVO - 30% [region code]
SPower - 15%
SSE - 35%
Utility Warehouse - 40%Disclaimer : Everything I write on this forum is my opinion. I try to be an even-handed poster and accept that you at times may not agree with these opinions or how I choose to express them, this is not my problem. The Disabled : If years cannot be added to their lives, at least life can be added to their years - Alf Morris - ℜ0 -
I moved into a one-bedroomed house in March this year, with storage heaters and an electric boiler - absolutely no gas supply whatsoever. It was jarring, after having had gas central heating and a gas combi-boiler for the ten years prior at my old flat.
I soon realised that the storage heaters were useless: boiling hot in the morning as I left for work, and stone cold by the time I got home every night. And yes, I downloaded instruction manuals from the net, as to how best set the controls on the things. No amount of knob-twiddling gave the desired effect (that being heat when I came home from work).
I decided to buy cheap free-standing fan-heaters & convector heaters, and rid myself of the storage heating.
My energy supplier, EDF Energy, told me that they couldn't bill me on a Single-Rate tariff, so long as I had a Two-Rate meter. I was aware that e.On allow you to add together day & night reads, without any need for a meter exchange - so I'm unsure why other electricity suppliers can't offer the same service. But I'm happy with EDF at the moment, so didn't want to swap supplier.
I did have to lie to EDF though, before they'd agree to exchange the meter... I told them I was renovating the property and would be fitting gas central heating. :cool:
When the meter engineer arrived with the new Single-Rate meter, he was reticent to fit it. I practically had to beg him on my doorstep. He asked if I had any other form of heating system in my home, and when I said not, he replied, "I'll have to ring me gaffer, mate."
Luckily, he couldn't get through to his "gaffer" and fitted the meter - but not before he asked to look at my fuse-box and ripped out the fuse for the storage heaters, pocketing it. It was really odd behaviour. I'd already turned-off the storage heaters at their power points on the walls, weeks beforehand. They're now covered up behind furniture, screens, etc. - I asked my landlord if I could rip them out entirely, but they wouldn't allow me to.
I have an electric shower, so I never turn the electric water boiler on either. I have a cheap ASDA Smart Price kettle in a bedside cabinet. I boil it to have a shave in the morning, before showering. I hide the kettle again, once I'm dressed, in case I have guests.
When I wash dishes, I just boil the kettle in the kitchen. I never use more than a kettle & a half of boiling water. I live alone, so there's never many dishes really.
Yes, I have to wash my hands with cold water after going to the loo, but I use anti-bacterial hand soap-gel, and I've not died of scurvy yet.
As for the heating now, it's fine. I use one Dimplex convector heater in my living room, when I'm home. My bedroom is open-plan, overlooking the living room on a balcony, so the heater heats the entire house really.
I usually leave the thermostat set at the III mark (which appears to be halfway), and I can hear it click off-and-on when in use. It's honestly off more than on. I've left the output setting at 1KWH since I bought it in April (although 2KWH and 3KWH are available) and it's more than warm enough.
I have a Dimplex fan heater in my bedroom, for nights when I'm not downstairs at all. I've hardly had to switch this on at all.
I believe that the convector heater (set at 1KWH output) would use one unit of electricity every hour, if constantly on. But because of the thermostat, it isn't even constantly on.
I'm using around £50 a month electricity now, which is comparable to the £60 a month duel-fuel I used at my old flat.
All the conventional wisdom out there, states that using standalone heaters (instead of an actual heating system) is more costly.... Take a look at this webpage for instance: http://www.cse.org.uk/advice/advice-and-support/room-heaters
Well, I personally haven't found this to be true.
To reiterate:
I live alone;
I boil kettles to shave in the morning, and wash dishes in the evening;
I have an electric shower, and never put the boiler on to take a bath;
The house is empty between 09:00 till 18:00 most days;
My main source of heat is a convector heater, with the output set at 1KWH and the thermostat never turned higher than halfway.
If you're a similar single person, living alone and out at work most days, I can't stress enough how useless Economy 7 heating is.
p.s. This is the convector heater I have in my living room:
http://www.argos.co.uk/static/Product/partNumber/4151955.htm0 -
I just had my single rate meter replaced with a simple dual rate one. The new one has no teleswitch or anything smart -- it should just switch between rates at 00:30 and 07:30 according to its clock, set (roughly) to GMT. Following an earlier incident , I don't trust those meters or what the suppliers says, so I will have to monitor. Am I right in thinking that if its clock is indeed fixed to GMT, my only option is to vary my consumption pattern, so that eg I use the washing machine from 1:30am in the summer months?!
What is really puzzling me is the Horstmann Economy 7 timeswitch controling the water heater. The ticking dial shows summer and winter time, and according to the manufacturer the peak and off-peak times are set internally during installation. Again, I will have to monitor its behaviour to make sure these were set correctly. However, how does it know when it is summer time and winter time? There is no button for that. The meter doesn't know either. Does the meter have separate circuits, one for peak and one for off-peak, supplying the timeswitch, so basically the switch is syncronised with what the meter 'thinks' it should register as peak and off-peak, regardless of the actual time? Otherwise, how can the switch know?0
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply

Categories
- All Categories
- 351K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.1K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 453.6K Spending & Discounts
- 244K Work, Benefits & Business
- 598.9K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 176.9K Life & Family
- 257.3K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.6K Read-Only Boards