Advice on Nokia mobile please

Ruthann

Hi,

I would appreciate some opinions. I have an O2 X2 phone which i hate (crap buttons and crap battery life) and am coming up to the end of my contract next month. I use about 50 texts a month and a few calls. My husband is on Vodafone and it costs me quite a bit to call him at the moment when he works away. Its mostly evenings (use work phone during the day). I want a good diary function as my old organiser is getting close to giving up and I can't afford to replace it.

I have seen the deals on the bootsphones websites and the 1000 off peak vodafone minutes (same network and landlines) with 250 texts for £16 a month looks good. I don't mind changing phone number.

But I can't decide which phone to get, please help
Choice A has £150 of boots points after 7 months
http://www.bootsphones.com/incentiveDetails.aspx?ret=0&pc=5&tc=13&np=9&m=1&p=1942&i=562001&pkg=MVSZ133KP02339901&st=1&offset=0&hp=0&rt=0&t=1815
Reviews
http://www.mobile-phones-uk.org.uk/nokia-6230i.htm

Choice B is marginally my second choice but very close and has £290 of boots points after 7 months
http://www.bootsphones.com/incentiveDetails.aspx?ret=0&pc=5&tc=13&np=9&m=1&p=1255&i=562016&pkg=MVSZ133KP02309901&st=1&offset=0&hp=0&rt=0&t=1815
Reviews
http://www.mobile-phones-uk.org.uk/nokia-6170.htm

Can anyone help me decide? It would really be appreciated.

jf2404

The 6230i, is a nice little phone. It has everything you need without being too fancy.

The Nokia 6170 has been out a while now and is nothing special.

Out of the two phones i'd pick the 6230i.

Stervo

I agree with jf2404, the 6230i is a quality phone.

Ruthann

Thanks for the advice