Ready, steady… save!
You don’t need a chart to join in. Here are 2 ways to record your savings:
1. Cross it off
Pop a chart into your first post. Saved an amount? Cross it out! Read more »
£0.01 £0.02 £0.03
2. Write it down
Skip the chart and add updates to your first post. Read more »
“Another +£3 saved today. Go me!”
Use +£ before each new saving so it counts towards your total.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Two-Storey Extension
Comments
-
You could look at your local council planning portal to see if there are any similar extensions in the locality to see how they handled it.
1 -
I'm not what you thinking, having a structural engineer will result in foundation that meeting building control requirements, why would you think otherwise?
"Because most domestic work doesn't need a SE to design the foundations." The OP is asking about a problem site and does not answer the question asked. So I think we can agree that it would result is a compliant solution.
"Its all a bit "best guess" until the foundations proper are dug. " or "A local architect should have a good feel for the ground conditions and likely"
Indeed you could rely on a good feel, best guess or employ a structural engineer who would focus on the physical integrity, load-bearing capacity, and safety of a building. The 2.5m foundations my father-in-law had dug cost 3 times that of standard foundations. So had he not been committed to the project, the cost would have kill the project. I think he paid around £3k for the SE all in and the foundations around £15,000.
0 -
The OP is asking about a problem site and does not answer the question asked. So I think we can agree that it would result is a compliant solution.
But as both stuart45 and I have said, the problem as described by the OP is not a particularly serious one - unless there is more to the situation (that the OP's architect will be paid to discover) then building on clay soil is a relatively routine thing in areas where clay soil predominates.
Indeed you could rely on a good feel, best guess or employ a structural engineer who would focus on the physical integrity, load-bearing capacity, and safety of a building.
The point I'm trying to get across is that even a structural engineer will work - to a greater or lesser extent - on a best guess or good feel. Trainee civil/structural engineers are often reminded that the only comprehensive ground investigation you get is when you dig the foundation trench.
The OP might need a SE later in the project. Just not now. The architect will know if one is needed for the foundations.
The 2.5m foundations my father-in-law had dug cost 3 times that of standard foundations. So had he not been committed to the project, the cost would have kill the project. I think he paid around £3k for the SE all in and the foundations around £15,000.
Your father-in-law was really unlucky. But that kind of situation can happen whenever you first appoint a SE to investigate the foundations on a project.
Also, it isn't an either/or situation. I don't know the details of your father-in-law's case, but paying £3k for a SE won't necessarily save the £15k foundations cost, unless their advice leads to the project being ditched at a very early stage.
If the OP's situation was really bad enough that they needed a SE now (for example building on an unstable slope), then the SE would be advising on which of the very expensive foundation solutions was the better one, not offering a much cheaper way out.
1 -
I know 😓, just crazy how much stuff has gone up in price. We did try look for a new house but we couldn't find anything close to what we have here unless you look in the 650-750k region. That would have been around £2500-£3000 in mortgage repayment and would mean cutting back on stuff we can do with the kids and holidays/socials etc…
In end, I just came to term with the price by thinking "its more expensive than 5 years ago but its a lot cheaper than doing it in 5 years time!".
I've got 2m+ deep basement around clay with some historical mining recorded nearby. These things can cause stress but (almost) everything has a solution.
0 -
@Gonk1967 That's a great idea, thank you. Some of the other properties identical to ours have extended out the back rather than side so I'll try having a look to see what docs are available for them. Although some were only single storey so I don't know if they'll have needed planning permission. But I'll also have a general trawl for info in the area.
0 -
@mighty2022 "In end, I just came to term with the price by thinking "its more expensive than 5 years ago but its a lot cheaper than doing it in 5 years time!". " That's a very good point!
Also you're very brave, I don't think I could cope with the stress of clay soil PLUS historical mining activity 🤣
2 -
Thanks for all the comments and advice on foundations, clay soil etc. Due to family chaos I haven't been able to properly take it all in yet but I'm working my way through the info 😊
0 -
This is an important point. You can't be certain until the foundation is dug out and passed. Generally with extensions there's no issues, although with an older property there could be an old well close to the house.
Builders who are experienced in your area, architects, BCO's etc will usually have a good idea of the type of clay anyway.
1 -
n end, I just came to term with the price by thinking "its more expensive than 5 years ago but its a lot cheaper than doing it in 5 years time!".
I can understand your assumption that it will be more expensive in 5 years time, but it might not be the case.
Post Covid was a rather unique situation. As Covid retreated demand shot up, and at the same time there were low stocks and global supply chain issues. Prices of bricks; steel; concrete; plastics etc doubled in some cases. Although the situation has changed, prices never really dropped back ( not helped by higher oil/energy prices) A global slowdown, combined with a resolution in Iran/Ukraine could see these prices dropping.
Labour costs also shot up post Covid, mainly due to EU tradesmen not returning after Covid due to Brexit. This might also change in future.
Plus even if building costs do rise, if they rise slower than general inflation/wage increases, then in real terms costs go down. A proper recession could see builders having to look harder to get jobs and cut their prices.
Not a prediction, just a possible scenario.
1 -
Of course, you are right. Whilst I don't mind waiting for that possible scenario, which may never arrive, I don't think my wife can!
0
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 356K Banking & Borrowing
- 255K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 456.3K Spending & Discounts
- 248.5K Work, Benefits & Business
- 606.2K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 179.1K Life & Family
- 264K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards