We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.
This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
The Forum now has a brand new text editor, adding a bunch of handy features to use when creating posts. Read more in our how-to guide
Stocks and Shares ISA
TractorFactor
Posts: 155 Forumite
I have no idea where to start with this.
Although I am reading through the guides now, I have no idea where to invest my money.
This money amounts to £1000 a year, of which gets paid in monthly.
Can I pay this direct into the ISA account or does it have to get paid to the intermediary account and I have to manually put it in the ISA?
It will be there for 10+ years, possibly 15+.
I see most places charge some money for investing.
HSBC charge a flat £2.50 per year (I think?) but others charge 0.45% of the money invested. While they're probably within £5 of each other, is there a reason to use one of the other? I'm not really bothered who I use but don't want to pick someone who is obviously expensive to run compared with others.
Any advice?
I know we're all different, but what platform do you use and do you find it easy?
Although I am reading through the guides now, I have no idea where to invest my money.
This money amounts to £1000 a year, of which gets paid in monthly.
Can I pay this direct into the ISA account or does it have to get paid to the intermediary account and I have to manually put it in the ISA?
It will be there for 10+ years, possibly 15+.
I see most places charge some money for investing.
HSBC charge a flat £2.50 per year (I think?) but others charge 0.45% of the money invested. While they're probably within £5 of each other, is there a reason to use one of the other? I'm not really bothered who I use but don't want to pick someone who is obviously expensive to run compared with others.
Any advice?
I know we're all different, but what platform do you use and do you find it easy?
0
Comments
-
Where is the money coming from? It's unlikely you'll be able to pay the money directly from this source into your S&S ISA, but adding it manually isn't a big deal, I do it monthly and it's added and invested before the kettle has finished boiling.
There are plenty of platforms. As you're looking at a relative low balance/contribution, you should consider platforms with percentage based platform fees, or ideally no platform fees. While there are many that charge % fees, there are only a handful that charge no platform fee- the most reputable probably being Trading 212.
I have a Cash ISA and S&S ISA with Trading 212 and it's one of the best platforms I've used. Their app is modern, and withdrawals (at least from Cash ISA) are typically instant. You can set up your bank account so you can click the account to deposit/withdraw to, so you're not typing in your bank details each time. Couple this with biometrics and your banking app on your phone and you can add money in literal seconds.
You will then need to pick a fund. Lots more reading to be done on there, but a global index fund is a good place to start. VWRL (Vanguard FTSE All World), FWRG (Investo FTSE All World) or ACWI (SPDR MSCI All World) are popular options.
Yes there's lots of factors. Some funds (like Vanguard) only offer their own funds. Some funds (like Trading 212) only offer ETF's. Some funds have dealing fees, some don't. Some have good mobile phone apps or data, some don't.TractorFactor said:I see most places charge some money for investing.
HSBC charge a flat £2.50 per year (I think?) but others charge 0.45% of the money invested. While they're probably within £5 of each other, is there a reason to use one of the other? I'm not really bothered who I use but don't want to pick someone who is obviously expensive to run compared with others.
Vanguard appears cheap on the surface (0.15% platform fee) or least compared to 0.45% for Hargreave Lansdown, but they introduced a penalty for accounts with balances under £32k.
There's no one-size fits all unfortunately.Know what you don't2 -
A bank account.Exodi said:Where is the money coming from? It's unlikely you'll be able to pay the money directly from this source into your S&S ISA, but adding it manually isn't a big deal, I do it monthly and it's added and invested before the kettle has finished boiling.
At the moment, I standing order some money from Current Account 0 to Savings Account 1, Savings Account 2 and Savings Account 3 - all automated every month.
But now I'm being caught by earning too much interest (the savings accounts are just in Chase 2.5%). Shame I can't automate this as, while it may be simple for you, it's not for me. I just want it automated so I can invest and leave / not monitor for a few years.
Maybe I'll re-look at Trading212, especially as I can see through MSE, they're giving away some free shares.
I'd prefer a more well known company like a bank, ideally one that I bank with to make things easy / less apps / less accounts, but if it's relatively modern and simple, then will certainly be worth a look.
Plus, if I can open a cash ISA with them, then that might be a good way of keeping everything together in once place.0 -
If you want easy then consider the Dodl app (run by AJ Bell a respected FTSE250 company) who can give you access to their own AJ Bell or cheaper Vanguard multi asset funds aimed at a various risk levels. For 10-15 years most people would find a Balanced aka 60% shares and 40% bonds portfolio would get the right balance of risk/reward but everyone is different in what impacts of a market crash they find acceptable.TractorFactor said:I know we're all different, but what platform do you use and do you find it easy?
https://dodl.co.uk/investment-isa (S&S ISA at 0.15% ongoing fee minimum £1 pm, cheaper than Vangaurd's min)
https://dodl.co.uk/investments/funds (AJ Bell multi-asset funds) or
https://dodl.co.uk/investments/themed (click All-in-one for Vanguard multi-asset funds)
For a cheaper slightly more complicated platform consider Scottish Widows (was iWeb, owned by Lloyds Bank) who have no ongoing platform charge and offer free regular scheduled investing (and £5 for adhoc trades). On SW you can invest in multi-asset fund such as Vanguard LifeStrategy or HSBC Global Strategy.
https://www.scottishwidows.co.uk/investing/ways-to-invest/share-dealing-services/share-dealing-isa.html
https://www.vanguardinvestor.co.uk/investing-explained/what-are-lifestrategy-funds
https://www.assetmanagement.hsbc.co.uk/en/intermediary/capabilities/multi-asset/hsbc-global-strategy-portfolios
Trading 212 mentioned above are also free but they don't support low cost multi-asset funds but if you wanted to go at a high risk level you might consider using them for Global Tracker ETFs such as the as All World ETFs mentioned above or just Developed World ETFs which would be my preference at that risk level if you don't want emerging markets exposure. This kind of stuff might drop around 50% in a bad crash. Or you could construct your own portfolio from multiple ETFs for lower risk but that's more advanced and would require regular rebalancing.
Also have you considered if making higher contributions into your pension would be more beneficial?1 -
I have reviewed your previous post below, and it is not at all clear to me why you have changed your requirement from a good interest paying cash ISA, to stocks and shares ISAs -TractorFactor said:
A bank account.Exodi said:Where is the money coming from? It's unlikely you'll be able to pay the money directly from this source into your S&S ISA, but adding it manually isn't a big deal, I do it monthly and it's added and invested before the kettle has finished boiling.
At the moment, I standing order some money from Current Account 0 to Savings Account 1, Savings Account 2 and Savings Account 3 - all automated every month.
But now I'm being caught by earning too much interest (the savings accounts are just in Chase 2.5%). Shame I can't automate this as, while it may be simple for you, it's not for me. I just want it automated so I can invest and leave / not monitor for a few years.
https://forums.moneysavingexpert.com/discussion/6645419/is-multiple-isas-the-best-way-forward#latest
It's clear you are entirely new to ISAs as a way to shelter your money from tax, but I do wonder if it is wise for you to make a big leap to risky stocks and shares ISAs without properly exploring what higher interest rate cash ISAs can do for you intially.
I am accepting at face value, that you do indeed have a £1000 per month you can commit for the next 10 to 15 years without needing to access.
However rather than deliberating over the mechanics of how to do so, I think it would be sensible for you to first broaden your comprehension of investing generally, understand your own appetite for what degree of risk you are prepared to take and how you would feel partway through your investment period if your investments were to markedly fall in value as a result of a stock market crash.
Given your current lack of knowledge regarding saving and investing, are you (more importantly) also neglecting pension provision?
Are you in an employers scheme and taking full advantage of what they offer? Are you keeping track of your entitlement to a state pension based on your NI history? It could be that part of your available £1000 monthly saving/ investment monies might be best diverted to long term pension provision.
Perhaps time for you to step back a moment, take stock of your longer term objectives and how these can be best served by a mix of pensions and ISA savings /investing. At that point you will probably be better equipped to look at specific products and service providers mentioned by the other posters here.
0 -
I haven't changed my requirements, but people are free to change their mind based on advice, no?poseidon1 said:
I have reviewed your previous post below, and it is not at all clear to me why you have changed your requirement from a good interest paying cash ISA, to stocks and shares ISAs -TractorFactor said:
A bank account.Exodi said:Where is the money coming from? It's unlikely you'll be able to pay the money directly from this source into your S&S ISA, but adding it manually isn't a big deal, I do it monthly and it's added and invested before the kettle has finished boiling.
At the moment, I standing order some money from Current Account 0 to Savings Account 1, Savings Account 2 and Savings Account 3 - all automated every month.
But now I'm being caught by earning too much interest (the savings accounts are just in Chase 2.5%). Shame I can't automate this as, while it may be simple for you, it's not for me. I just want it automated so I can invest and leave / not monitor for a few years.
Given your current lack of knowledge regarding saving and investing, are you (more importantly) also neglecting pension provision?
Funnily enough, for some savings, I will put them in Cash ISAs, for others, I am happy to look at Stocks and Shares.
Nobody has particularly pointed out the basics - go here, open this ISA, so it's difficult to even know where to begin with an example.
I was happy with just leaving it in the 2.5% Chase account but it seems I can't do that without being taxed.
Any old account that will pay interest is what I am looking at.
I don't like the idea of stocks and shares as I know in the short term, my £1000 investment will go down - that doesn't settle nicely with me. But I also appreciate (and looking at the stats of the FTSE100), that within months and very likely over the years, the value of that £1000 will go up. I'm not one for looking every minute, every hour, every week at how much my £1000 is worth, so long as it goes up after a few months / years, then it's been a good choice.
But it seems most people are hesitant to give advice in case they get sued or whatever, so a basics of how to even begin and some good, safe(ish) starting pointers are very lacking.
The money I will be saving in ISAs, I will need before I retire (but won't need for nearly 20 years).
I will be entitled to the full state pension, I have a private work pension and a seperate additional pension scheme that I pay in to.
The goal is to stop me paying tax on the interest I have on my savings.0 -
TractorFactor said:
I haven't changed my requirements, but people are free to change their mind based on advice, no?poseidon1 said:
I have reviewed your previous post below, and it is not at all clear to me why you have changed your requirement from a good interest paying cash ISA, to stocks and shares ISAs -TractorFactor said:
A bank account.Exodi said:Where is the money coming from? It's unlikely you'll be able to pay the money directly from this source into your S&S ISA, but adding it manually isn't a big deal, I do it monthly and it's added and invested before the kettle has finished boiling.
At the moment, I standing order some money from Current Account 0 to Savings Account 1, Savings Account 2 and Savings Account 3 - all automated every month.
But now I'm being caught by earning too much interest (the savings accounts are just in Chase 2.5%). Shame I can't automate this as, while it may be simple for you, it's not for me. I just want it automated so I can invest and leave / not monitor for a few years.
Given your current lack of knowledge regarding saving and investing, are you (more importantly) also neglecting pension provision?
Funnily enough, for some savings, I will put them in Cash ISAs, for others, I am happy to look at Stocks and Shares.
Nobody has particularly pointed out the basics - go here, open this ISA, so it's difficult to even know where to begin with an example.
I was happy with just leaving it in the 2.5% Chase account but it seems I can't do that without being taxed.
Any old account that will pay interest is what I am looking at.
I don't like the idea of stocks and shares as I know in the short term, my £1000 investment will go down - that doesn't settle nicely with me. But I also appreciate (and looking at the stats of the FTSE100), that within months and very likely over the years, the value of that £1000 will go up. I'm not one for looking every minute, every hour, every week at how much my £1000 is worth, so long as it goes up after a few months / years, then it's been a good choice.
But it seems most people are hesitant to give advice in case they get sued or whatever, so a basics of how to even begin and some good, safe(ish) starting pointers are very lacking.
The money I will be saving in ISAs, I will need before I retire (but won't need for nearly 20 years).
I will be entitled to the full state pension, I have a private work pension and a seperate additional pension scheme that I pay in to.
The goal is to stop me paying tax on the interest I have on my savings.Savings accounts are easy: look at Moneyfacts. When looking at the tables change the 'sort' filter to 'rate.'
https://moneyfactscompare.co.uk/savings-accounts/If you have a Chase account and you're new to investing you could look at JP Morgan Personal Investments (formerly Nutmeg): you'll find a link in Chase's app. It's a robo-investor: it'll ask you some questions about the level of risk you're willing to take and then create a portfolio for you. Lower risk will equal more bonds and fewer equities and vice versa.
https://www.personalinvesting.jpmorgan.com/
0 -
If your motivation for investing is to avoid paying tax on savings I’m unsure that’s a sensible reason. 2.5% interest on your cash is also really low, you can get almost double this, and even after tax this is better for you.I would honestly start with your objectives. Cash savings are important to have, but shelter these in a cash ISA where it makes sense to. You could for example earn a good high rate of interest using regular savers which will net you a higher return than a cash ISA after tax, you can automate payment into these too. For instance you can get 6% with Monthmouthshire BS, max £500 per month pay in.I drip feed in cash from my flexible cash ISAs to regular savers to maximise my return, but make sure I put the cash back in to the isa before the end of the tax year.
Then any money you won’t need for 10+ years minimum you’re best to put that into investments, again use a S&S isa as that’ll save you a ton of admin. Investing will protect you from inflation eating into your cash savings, but each saving type is best for different objectives.
There are many ways to skin the onion so to speak, and some options you won’t be comfortable with which is fine, but it’s important to be happy they meet your objectives.1 -
It does sound like you need to understand the basics.
1. Anything to do with money will have some form of risk attached to it.
All that changes is the type & size of the risk.
That includes a low risk savings account covered by the FSCS Savings Protection up to £120,000.
Here the risk is inflation. This is where the same amount of money will buy less as time goes by.
Example: Pay for a skilled man in 1960 about £1000 per year.
Pay for a skilled man in 2020 about £ 25000 per year
2. Savings means cash in the bank/building society (these are Low Risk)Investing means you are putting your money at risk; Think shares, bonds, gold etc.(Risk levels vary)
3. Use tax shelters wherever possible.
Pensions: give you a tax rebate, (You pay no tax going in but on the way out)
Cash ISA (is a savings account where you do not pay tax)
Stocks & Shares ISA ( an investment account where you pay no tax. At least for now)
4. Some banks & building societies have easy access Cash ISA accounts where you can make regular electronic deposits (up to the ISA allowance) To find them use an AI chat bot like:
https://www.perplexity.ai/
5. Best savings accounts:
https://moneyfactscompare.co.uk/savings-accounts/
6. Any money you know will need within 5 years should be held in either(a) NS&I, where it is protected 100% as you are loaning money to the UK Government.(b) Bank or building Society Account on the FSCS list where it will be protected up to £120,000.
7. Investing means putting your money at risk, it is a long term gamble
You hope to get out more than you put in. There is no guarantee you will win,
8. Investing is for money you know you will not touch for at least 10 years.
This is because your odds of winning are high
9. Before investing make sure you have cleared any high interest debt such as credit cards etc.
10. Have an emergency savings account to cover at least 6 to 12 months of household bills and car/boiler break downs. You do not want to sell investments when their price is low.
11. You can make investing as simple or as complex as you like.
12. SIMPLE INVESTING IN DETAIL (advantages, easy to understand & implement)(a) First watch this: https://www.kroijer.com/(b) Then read these:
If after reading about "simple investing" you still want to continue, comeback and the forum can suggest suitable
platforms for what you have chosen to invest in.
3 -
https://youtube.com/@damientalksmoney?si=P8q3rQrRZ3Kvule9Is great to watch, he has taught me a lot to get started in investingNurse striving for financial freedom0
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 354K Banking & Borrowing
- 254.3K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 455.2K Spending & Discounts
- 247K Work, Benefits & Business
- 603.6K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 178.3K Life & Family
- 261.1K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards


