We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.
This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
ISA - Stocks and Shares
Comments
-
Anyone that uses Trading212 - is there a guide i could use or videos to help me understand how to use the platform please?My Signature is MY OWN!!0
-
There are probably youtube videos showing you what to do. However it's very simple, for the ISA anyway. Add money. Use the search facility to find the share or ETF you want to buy. Click on it and enter the amount, then Buy and it is done. Takes about 30 seconds.slenderkitten said:Anyone that uses Trading212 - is there a guide i could use or videos to help me understand how to use the platform please?
Are you stuck on something?0 -
Read that link and you can see the one star reviews are scammers, trying to get you to go to them for help! Disregard it.slenderkitten said:
I've responded to your invite in PM, thought I would add this here, why do they get bad reviews https://www.mywot.com/scorecard/trading212.com I have to admit it is alarming, thought from what i have read so far they seem to have invested huge amounts which I wouldn't be doing.Petriix said:
I'm not sure about transfers, but withdrawing cash seems pretty standard. I've just asked for a £1 withdrawal to my linked account and it says it will take 3 working days to arrive.slenderkitten said:
I looked on trustpilot some people saying the company makes it difficult to move the money elsewhere, this puts me off, what do you think about this?Albermarle said:
Yes they are legit.slenderkitten said:
That sounds interesting but how are they not charging fees as you say, how are they making money? Are they a legit company?Petriix said:Knowing nothing about buying shares, I've just opened a Stocks and Shares ISA with Trading 212. I got a free random share worth £44 by using a referral link. They give 1% cashback (which you can't withdraw for a year) on any ISA deposits and pay 5.2% variable interest on anything held as cash. They also seem to charge no commission on any trades.
I'm sure more experienced people can tell you the potential down sides, but this seems pretty decent in comparison to other platforms.
They will lose money gaining market share, and then either start to introduce charges for premium service, or get bought out for the customer base. ( especially if they still losing money after a couple of years)
Also they have a larger part of their business which is trading in CFD's. This is more profitable and much more risky for the punter ( it is just gambling really).
I suspect by getting customers for ISA's, they hope to tempt then into the CFD side.2 -
Philosophical question:
Suppose I wasn't going to use my ISA allowance otherwise... Would there be any issues say depositing £500 each month after payday then withdrawing it again? I could accumulate the cashback and earn a bit of interest without retaining the investment.0 -
In answer to my own question: I just did an experiment and transferred £10 from my ISA to the Invest account and back. It was instant and generated 10p cashback. I wonder if it would flag up if I transferred the same £500 18 more times to max out the cashback...Petriix said:Philosophical question:
Suppose I wasn't going to use my ISA allowance otherwise... Would there be any issues say depositing £500 each month after payday then withdrawing it again? I could accumulate the cashback and earn a bit of interest without retaining the investment.0 -
The problem is that I think the Trading212 ISA is not flexible. So by paying in and then withdrawing, you've used up £10 of your £20k allowance.Petriix said:
In answer to my own question: I just did an experiment and transferred £10 from my ISA to the Invest account and back. It was instant and generated 10p cashback. I wonder if it would flag up if I transferred the same £500 18 more times to max out the cashback...Petriix said:Philosophical question:
Suppose I wasn't going to use my ISA allowance otherwise... Would there be any issues say depositing £500 each month after payday then withdrawing it again? I could accumulate the cashback and earn a bit of interest without retaining the investment.1 -
Like the other person said you will use up your £20k allowance if you choose to do this.Petriix said:
In answer to my own question: I just did an experiment and transferred £10 from my ISA to the Invest account and back. It was instant and generated 10p cashback. I wonder if it would flag up if I transferred the same £500 18 more times to max out the cashback...Petriix said:Philosophical question:
Suppose I wasn't going to use my ISA allowance otherwise... Would there be any issues say depositing £500 each month after payday then withdrawing it again? I could accumulate the cashback and earn a bit of interest without retaining the investment.My Signature is MY OWN!!0 -
Yes, that's right. Only useful for people who weren't otherwise going to use it up. Maxing out the £200 cashback seems like a good plan.slenderkitten said:
Like the other person said you will use up your £20k allowance if you choose to do this.Petriix said:
In answer to my own question: I just did an experiment and transferred £10 from my ISA to the Invest account and back. It was instant and generated 10p cashback. I wonder if it would flag up if I transferred the same £500 18 more times to max out the cashback...Petriix said:Philosophical question:
Suppose I wasn't going to use my ISA allowance otherwise... Would there be any issues say depositing £500 each month after payday then withdrawing it again? I could accumulate the cashback and earn a bit of interest without retaining the investment.1 -
I've been looking around YouTube and online people saying Vanguard S&P 500 is a good one to invest in when I look on Trading 212 app (I'm brand new to all of this so don't understand terminology yet), there appear to be several of them, any help so I know which one i should be looking at here?My Signature is MY OWN!!0
-
I've been looking around YouTube and online people saying Vanguard S&P 500 is a good one to invest inAs part of your US equity allocation, then its not a bad option. However, that is just one part of the jigsaw. If you are going to use single sector funds, then you need a fund for each country or region. e.g. UK equity, Europe, Japan, Asia, emerging markets etc.
Maybe you should stop looking at youtube as it appears to be sending you down the wrong route as you acknowledge you are not an experienced investor.
I am an Independent Financial Adviser (IFA). The comments I make are just my opinion and are for discussion purposes only. They are not financial advice and you should not treat them as such. If you feel an area discussed may be relevant to you, then please seek advice from an Independent Financial Adviser local to you.1
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 352.4K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.7K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 454.4K Spending & Discounts
- 245.4K Work, Benefits & Business
- 601.2K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 177.6K Life & Family
- 259.3K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards
