We'd like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum... Read More »
PLEASE READ BEFORE POSTING: Hello Forumites! In order to help keep the Forum a useful, safe and friendly place for our users, discussions around non-MoneySaving matters are not permitted per the Forum rules. While we understand that mentioning house prices may sometimes be relevant to a user's specific MoneySaving situation, we ask that you please avoid veering into broad, general debates about the market, the economy and politics, as these can unfortunately lead to abusive or hateful behaviour. Threads that are found to have derailed into wider discussions may be removed. Users who repeatedly disregard this may have their Forum account banned. Please also avoid posting personally identifiable information, including links to your own online property listing which may reveal your address. Thank you for your understanding.
We're aware that some users are experiencing technical issues which the team are working to resolve. See the Community Noticeboard for more info. Thank you for your patience.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Sudden £9k section 20 notice - can I do anything?
Options
Comments
-
eddddy said:What worries me is that if I have to take legal advice, book in someone else to do a survey, get someone to do quotes etc., this doesn't seem like loads of time to get all that done.
The law says that costs must be 'reasonable'.
You can interpret 'reasonable' as meaning...- It's 'reasonable' to do all the work - i.e. the repairs and painting are needed. And, for example, it's 'reasonable' to scaffold the whole building (e.g. as opposed to using scaffold tower, cherry picker, etc)
- The price being charged for the work is 'reasonable' - e.g. They're not paying a firm £5k for scaffolding, when other firms would charge £2k.
That's the kind of thing an suitable building surveyor should be able to tell you.
You don't have to get quotes. You just have to give the council the name of the company. The council will then ask the company for quotes. (But you should probably ask the companies if they'd be interested in quoting and doing the job - before putting their name forward.)pannonica said:
Regarding right to manage, the other flat is owned by the local authority, so my understanding is that there isn't a lease. Does this mean right to manage isn't an option for me? I'd be interested in looking into buying the freehold as well (as a more long term thing I guess, not to deal with this issue now) but I'm not sure if this is doable either in this situation.
I think you're scuppered in that case. You won't have the legal Right to Manage, or the legal right to buy the freehold.
In theory, the council could 'voluntarily' sell you the freehold - put I doubt they'd do that while they have a tenant in the other flat.
As for the prices, reasonable is definitely not a word any sane person would use to describe them.
So do I need to find both a building surveyor (to give a second opinion on how much of this work is actually necessary) as well as some contractors (decorators?) to give quotes to do the work? Should I find some who are willing to do the work and then pass their details on to the management company in my response?
Regarding the right to manage/buying freehold - I was worried that's what you were going to say. I'll see if I can investigate it a bit more anyway, it'd definitely make sense to do if it is possible. Couldn't the council sell me a share of the freehold, rather than the whole freehold?0 -
eddddy said:pannonica said:
This is the third section 20 notice I’ve had in the last year and a half since I bought the flat (the other two seemed similarly unnecessary but were less expensive at least).
Will all the service charges amount to more than £15k if you're in London, or £10k if you're outside London?
There are some rules for social landlords...There is a potential cap on the costs for major works if the mandatory reduction for service charges applies.The Mandatory reduction directions for social landlords (councils or housing associations) came into force in England on 12 August 2014.
The Directions limit the amount of service charges recoverable from leaseholders of social landlords, who occupy their flat or house as their only or principal home.
Within any 5-year period, the maximum a landlord can recover is limited to £15,000 within London and £10,000 outside London.
See also: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/342737/140811_Mandatory_signed.pdf
I'm not really familiar with those rules, so I don't know if there are exemptions etc. Maybe start by asking the council if those rules apply to you.0 -
pannonica said:
Couldn't the council sell me a share of the freehold, rather than the whole freehold?
"Share of freehold" is a misleading term used by estate agents. It means joint ownership of a building.
So you're asking about jointly owning an end-of-terrace building with the council. (In some ways, it would be a bit like jointly owning, say, a car with the council.)- So one of you wants to repaint the building that you jointly own, the other doesn't want to repaint it. How do you decide what to do?
- One of you wants to use Global Luxury Decorators Ltd to do the repainting, the other wants to use George and Bill from the pub. How do you agree who to use?
TBH, I'm pretty sure that the council won't want to jointly own a building with you anyway - it would be too much hassle for them - especially as the building is housing one of their tenants.
(For example, the council's tenant might phone the council to say the roof leaks when it rains. So the council would then have to phone you to tell you. Then you and the council would have to make a plan together for fixing the roof.
And you might refuse to cooperate - so the council's tenant is left with a leaking roof.)pannonica said:
Regarding the right to manage/buying freehold - I was worried that's what you were going to say. I'll see if I can investigate it a bit more anyway, it'd definitely make sense to do if it is possible.- The rules that allow you to qualify for "Right To Manage" are here: https://www.lease-advice.org/advice-guide/right-manage/
The legal term for compulsorily buying the freehold of flats is "Collective Enfranchisement".- The rules that allow you to qualify for Collective Enfranchisement are here: https://www.lease-advice.org/advice-guide/ce-getting-started/
Unfortunately, you'll see that your building doesn't qualify for either (based on what you've said so far in your posts).
1 -
pannonica said:eddddy said:What worries me is that if I have to take legal advice, book in someone else to do a survey, get someone to do quotes etc., this doesn't seem like loads of time to get all that done.
The law says that costs must be 'reasonable'.
You can interpret 'reasonable' as meaning...- It's 'reasonable' to do all the work - i.e. the repairs and painting are needed. And, for example, it's 'reasonable' to scaffold the whole building (e.g. as opposed to using scaffold tower, cherry picker, etc)
- The price being charged for the work is 'reasonable' - e.g. They're not paying a firm £5k for scaffolding, when other firms would charge £2k.
That's the kind of thing an suitable building surveyor should be able to tell you.
You don't have to get quotes. You just have to give the council the name of the company. The council will then ask the company for quotes. (But you should probably ask the companies if they'd be interested in quoting and doing the job - before putting their name forward.)pannonica said:
Regarding right to manage, the other flat is owned by the local authority, so my understanding is that there isn't a lease. Does this mean right to manage isn't an option for me? I'd be interested in looking into buying the freehold as well (as a more long term thing I guess, not to deal with this issue now) but I'm not sure if this is doable either in this situation.
I think you're scuppered in that case. You won't have the legal Right to Manage, or the legal right to buy the freehold.
In theory, the council could 'voluntarily' sell you the freehold - put I doubt they'd do that while they have a tenant in the other flat.0 -
eddddy said:pannonica said:
Couldn't the council sell me a share of the freehold, rather than the whole freehold?
"Share of freehold" is a misleading term used by estate agents. It means joint ownership of a building.
So you're asking about jointly owning an end-of-terrace building with the council. (In some ways, it would be a bit like jointly owning, say, a car with the council.)- So one of you wants to repaint the building that you jointly own, the other doesn't want to repaint it. How do you decide what to do?
- One of you wants to use Global Luxury Decorators Ltd to do the repainting, the other wants to use George and Bill from the pub. How do you agree who to use?
TBH, I'm pretty sure that the council won't want to jointly own a building with you anyway - it would be too much hassle for them - especially as the building is housing one of their tenants.
(For example, the council's tenant might phone the council to say the roof leaks when it rains. So the council would then have to phone you to tell you. Then you and the council would have to make a plan together for fixing the roof.
And you might refuse to cooperate - so the council's tenant is left with a leaking roof.)pannonica said:
Regarding the right to manage/buying freehold - I was worried that's what you were going to say. I'll see if I can investigate it a bit more anyway, it'd definitely make sense to do if it is possible.- The rules that allow you to qualify for "Right To Manage" are here: https://www.lease-advice.org/advice-guide/right-manage/
The legal term for compulsorily buying the freehold of flats is "Collective Enfranchisement".- The rules that allow you to qualify for Collective Enfranchisement are here: https://www.lease-advice.org/advice-guide/ce-getting-started/
Unfortunately, you'll see that your building doesn't qualify for either (based on what you've said so far in your posts).0 -
CSI_Yorkshire said:pannonica said:eddddy said:What worries me is that if I have to take legal advice, book in someone else to do a survey, get someone to do quotes etc., this doesn't seem like loads of time to get all that done.
The law says that costs must be 'reasonable'.
You can interpret 'reasonable' as meaning...- It's 'reasonable' to do all the work - i.e. the repairs and painting are needed. And, for example, it's 'reasonable' to scaffold the whole building (e.g. as opposed to using scaffold tower, cherry picker, etc)
- The price being charged for the work is 'reasonable' - e.g. They're not paying a firm £5k for scaffolding, when other firms would charge £2k.
That's the kind of thing an suitable building surveyor should be able to tell you.
You don't have to get quotes. You just have to give the council the name of the company. The council will then ask the company for quotes. (But you should probably ask the companies if they'd be interested in quoting and doing the job - before putting their name forward.)pannonica said:
Regarding right to manage, the other flat is owned by the local authority, so my understanding is that there isn't a lease. Does this mean right to manage isn't an option for me? I'd be interested in looking into buying the freehold as well (as a more long term thing I guess, not to deal with this issue now) but I'm not sure if this is doable either in this situation.
I think you're scuppered in that case. You won't have the legal Right to Manage, or the legal right to buy the freehold.
In theory, the council could 'voluntarily' sell you the freehold - put I doubt they'd do that while they have a tenant in the other flat.0 -
I doubt they are painting the walls if they are not painted currently - firstly it would cost a lot more than £145 to paint a building and secondly that would be seen as 'improvement' rather than maintenance, which isn't usually allowed.Are you sure there are no painted parts - lintels, window ledges etc? First question is to ask them is what parts are they painting.Regardless of whether you own the freehold or have RTM on a flat, you still have to adhere to the terms and conditions of the lease, so let's say you have RTM and the lease says the exterior must be repainted every 5 years, then you would still have to do that, RTM isn't a way of avoiding having to pay for maintenance it just means you can choose who does it.0
-
I think you’re right actually, after looking at the items on the list a bit closer it seems like they’re just proposing painting some window sills and the back door and some other little bits (it seems - it’s not completely clear).
Which makes a bit more sense in a way, although it seems even more silly to go to such a massive expense on scaffolding for such minor bits of work. Once all their percentages plus VAT is added the cost of the scaffolding itself is actually over 10k.I wonder if I should suggest other ways of going about this work without using scaffolding as going to this expense to put scaffolding around the whole building just to do a bit of paint and a minor cosmetic repair on a window sill seems completely crazy. The ground floor stuff obviously wouldn’t need scaffolding so it would all be just for a couple of little jobs on the first floor window. Surely there must be easier ways of doing that?
I don’t object to paying to maintain the exterior of the building at all, what I object to is having to pay hugely inflated prices. But it seems like RTM wouldn’t be an option in any case.0 -
If it is just window sills, are they paintable from inside the property with the window open? I doubt very much any decorators would think of scaffolding the whole building for such a small job if it wasn't the council paying them !
1 -
It also seems quite weird the stuff they have included on the letter they have sent. 4% profit for the contractors? really? I don't know any tradesmen who would work for a 4% profit, even on a £10K job.0
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply

Categories
- All Categories
- 350.9K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.1K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 453.5K Spending & Discounts
- 243.9K Work, Benefits & Business
- 598.8K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 176.9K Life & Family
- 257.2K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.6K Read-Only Boards