We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.
This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Has MSE helped you to save or reclaim money this year? Share your 2025 MoneySaving success stories!
S&S ISA platform Funds, Shares, ETF, IT
Comments
-
I am not sure of a definitive definition but I would say any buy or sell of an investment is a trade.matt1983 said:
Whats your definition of a trade?Albermarle said:
I have a general question which funds/sectors people here are invested in so I can do my own research and decideinkypinky999 said:
i sometimes do 4-8 trades / week and sometimes it's 1-2 trades/week, i am looking somewhere an average of 15 trades/monthgrumiofoundation said:sure about that - OP says 4-8 week to 4-5/month - not clear what exactly this means but use of / implies 4-5 per month - which would be fees of over £200 per year based on £5 per trade.
It is probably worth you knowing that most of the regular posters on this forum probably don't do 8 trades a year, never mind a week .
So in you invest monthly that is 12 trades. If you generally leave the investments alone you might have zero trades in a year.
Or if you are buying and selling on a daily basis then hundreds a month I guess.2 -
so to be clear on my funds buying -
i am buying £100 of LS80, LS100, HSBC Global Strategy Balanced Portfolio C Acc every week and holding onto them, in last 2 yrs i am seeing returns of 19% (annualized returns ~8%) on my overall portfolio
Share trading I am mainly into EV stocks but doing short term trading
so if i ask my question on trading strategy what is the approach on deciding what sectors to analyze
0 -
I'm not clear what you're asking. Trading, and frequency of trading have nothing to do with selecting sectors. You should only be looking at a sector if you consider yourself qualified, experienced or otherwise knowledgeable about it. I can understand tobacco, insurance, price comparison website and utility stocks well enough that those are the only ones I own individually aside from funds. I don't know enough about pharmaceuticals, healthcare, banks, miners, oil & gas, energy, industrials, airlines, technology to invest in them. If you genuinely believe that you know enough about a sector to make a decent return then go ahead, are you a car mechanic, electrical/EV engineer, car sales rep? Why do you believe you have more knowledge of the EV sector?inkypinky999 said:so to be clear on my funds buying -
i am buying £100 of LS80, LS100, HSBC Global Strategy Balanced Portfolio C Acc every week and holding onto them, in last 2 yrs i am seeing returns of 19% (annualized returns ~8%) on my overall portfolio
Share trading I am mainly into EV stocks but doing short term trading
so if i ask my question on trading strategy what is the approach on deciding what sectors to analyze
I don't care about sectors, I just own a few companies I understand that I bought when I thought they were cheap, aside from that I stick to index funds.Analyse is just a fancy way of saying "look at".1 -
Generating ideas is the biggest challenge that faces investors. Hence why you see bandwagons develop and gain momentum. Effortless to piggyback and feel security in what the herd is doing on the assumption that others have done their research . On occasions the herd does stampede though........inkypinky999 said:
so if i ask my question on trading strategy what is the approach on deciding what sectors to analyze2 -
How have you chosen those funds? If you use the same process then you'll be able to choose additional funds to buy although many people use VLS as the core or only holding in their portfolio so you really need to define what purpose the additional funds will be performing.inkypinky999 said:so to be clear on my funds buying -
i am buying £100 of LS80, LS100, HSBC Global Strategy Balanced Portfolio C Acc every week and holding onto them, in last 2 yrs i am seeing returns of 19% (annualized returns ~8%) on my overall portfolio
Share trading I am mainly into EV stocks but doing short term trading
so if i ask my question on trading strategy what is the approach on deciding what sectors to analyzeRemember the saying: if it looks too good to be true it almost certainly is.0 -
VL LS80, LS100 , HSBC I chose as they have been mentioned a lot in forums here, and then i looked at their past 5 yr performance which was better than me having my cash in bank account getting 0.3% , i did not do more research into their sector coverage, underlying breakdown etc.jimjames said:
How have you chosen those funds? If you use the same process then you'll be able to choose additional funds to buy although many people use VLS as the core or only holding in their portfolio so you really need to define what purpose the additional funds will be performing.inkypinky999 said:so to be clear on my funds buying -
i am buying £100 of LS80, LS100, HSBC Global Strategy Balanced Portfolio C Acc every week and holding onto them, in last 2 yrs i am seeing returns of 19% (annualized returns ~8%) on my overall portfolio
Share trading I am mainly into EV stocks but doing short term trading
so if i ask my question on trading strategy what is the approach on deciding what sectors to analyze
What I want to do know is to understand and approach investing in a proper way, i still see myself as an beginner and want to imrpove that0 -
well I need to start from somewhere, yes it is effortless to piggyback but knowing where the herd is going and why helps, there will be stampedes and lot other fallbacks but being able to decide at those moments is what i want to educate myself with, i am feeling here instead of guiding this thread has become more philosophical, if posters don't want to guide/teach that's fine, rather than creating riddles hereThrugelmir said:
Generating ideas is the biggest challenge that faces investors. Hence why you see bandwagons develop and gain momentum. Effortless to piggyback and feel security in what the herd is doing on the assumption that others have done their research . On occasions the herd does stampede though........inkypinky999 said:
so if i ask my question on trading strategy what is the approach on deciding what sectors to analyze0 -
You're not going to get a lot of hand holding. Like a lot of people you could start by reading the weekly publication Investors' Chronicle, published by the FT, and available at all good newsagents and online. It has lots of company results, commentary, ideas for funds, shares, ITs, and so forth. You could also read the FT and, although it's not as good as it used to be, its Saturday paper has a personal finance section that might give you some ideas.1
-
PensionCraft was a good resource for me, he goes into a lot of technical and academic detail.inkypinky999 said:
VL LS80, LS100 , HSBC I chose as they have been mentioned a lot in forums here, and then i looked at their past 5 yr performance which was better than me having my cash in bank account getting 0.3% , i did not do more research into their sector coverage, underlying breakdown etc.jimjames said:
How have you chosen those funds? If you use the same process then you'll be able to choose additional funds to buy although many people use VLS as the core or only holding in their portfolio so you really need to define what purpose the additional funds will be performing.inkypinky999 said:so to be clear on my funds buying -
i am buying £100 of LS80, LS100, HSBC Global Strategy Balanced Portfolio C Acc every week and holding onto them, in last 2 yrs i am seeing returns of 19% (annualized returns ~8%) on my overall portfolio
Share trading I am mainly into EV stocks but doing short term trading
so if i ask my question on trading strategy what is the approach on deciding what sectors to analyze
What I want to do know is to understand and approach investing in a proper way, i still see myself as an beginner and want to imrpove that
2 -
Performance over the last five years tells you absolutely nothing about performance over the next five years. The most that can be said is that performance has been very good for a very long time, and all assets are now expensive by historical valuations. That probably means that the performance going forward will be bad, but the bubble could continue to expand. Nonetheless, no one knows what will happen. You can do much better than 0.3%:inkypinky999 said:
VL LS80, LS100 , HSBC I chose as they have been mentioned a lot in forums here, and then i looked at their past 5 yr performance which was better than me having my cash in bank account getting 0.3% , i did not do more research into their sector coverage, underlying breakdown etc.
https://www.moneysavingexpert.com/savings/savings-accounts-best-interest/
2
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 352.9K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.9K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 454.7K Spending & Discounts
- 246K Work, Benefits & Business
- 602.1K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 177.8K Life & Family
- 259.9K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards
