We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.
This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Amazon seller small claims court
jennystarpepper
Posts: 815 Forumite
An amazon seller is claiming X amount via small claims as Amazon restricted sale of an item.
Item sold had 2 serious faults, electrical and glass coming off item. Seller wants buyer to pay for return (no offer to pre-pay or refund postage, other buyers have stated the same), if seller sends the item back they cannot show proof of fault.
Review of the item left on Amazon to confirm the faults, no name left to confirm who the review was from. Seller is claiming Amazon stopped sale of the item in the future and it is the fault of a review left. Amazon stated to buyer, no not deal with seller, block emails and they will deal / refund. Amazon have x2 emails sent as proof of fault. No refund from amazon.
Item sold had 2 serious faults, electrical and glass coming off item. Seller wants buyer to pay for return (no offer to pre-pay or refund postage, other buyers have stated the same), if seller sends the item back they cannot show proof of fault.
Review of the item left on Amazon to confirm the faults, no name left to confirm who the review was from. Seller is claiming Amazon stopped sale of the item in the future and it is the fault of a review left. Amazon stated to buyer, no not deal with seller, block emails and they will deal / refund. Amazon have x2 emails sent as proof of fault. No refund from amazon.
MFW - 01.10.21 £63761 01.10.22 £50962 01.10.23 £39979 01.10.24 £27815. 01.01.25. £17538
01.03.25 £14794. 01.04.25 £12888
01.05.25. £11805. 12.05.25 £9997 05.06.25 £8898.
01.07.25. £7975 01.08.25 £6968 01.09.25 £5956. 01.10.25 £4979
01.03.25 £14794. 01.04.25 £12888
01.05.25. £11805. 12.05.25 £9997 05.06.25 £8898.
01.07.25. £7975 01.08.25 £6968 01.09.25 £5956. 01.10.25 £4979
0
Comments
-
I can't make much sense of that.jennystarpepper said:An amazon seller is claiming X amount via small claims as Amazon restricted sale of an item.
Item sold had 2 serious faults, electrical and glass coming off item. Seller wants buyer to pay for return (no offer to pre-pay or refund postage, other buyers have stated the same), if seller sends the item back they cannot show proof of fault.
Review of the item left on Amazon to confirm the faults, no name left to confirm who the review was from. Seller is claiming Amazon stopped sale of the item in the future and it is the fault of a review left. Amazon stated to buyer, no not deal with seller, block emails and they will deal / refund. Amazon have x2 emails sent as proof of fault. No refund from amazon.
Are you the buyer or the seller.
What is it that you want help with?6 -
I'm also confused.
Are you saying you bought something faulty, you want to send it back but the seller is refusing to pay return postage?
So you left a negative review on Amazon and then Amazon stopped them selling the item because of this?
So you still have item but want a refund and want the seller to pay to send it back?Should've = Should HAVE (not 'of')
Would've = Would HAVE (not 'of')
No, I am not perfect, but yes I do judge people on their use of basic English language. If you didn't know the above, then learn it! (If English is your second language, then you are forgiven!)2 -
Apologies, I have a medical condition which makes tasks like this a bit difficult at times.
I bought an item from Amazon which was faulty.
Amazon seller is claiming funds from me via the small claims court stating that as I left a review about the faulty item Amazon have stopped it's sale because of me.
Would Amazon tell them they stopped sale because of me? How would they have proof Amazon did this because of me?
Thank you
MFW - 01.10.21 £63761 01.10.22 £50962 01.10.23 £39979 01.10.24 £27815. 01.01.25. £17538
01.03.25 £14794. 01.04.25 £12888
01.05.25. £11805. 12.05.25 £9997 05.06.25 £8898.
01.07.25. £7975 01.08.25 £6968 01.09.25 £5956. 01.10.25 £49790 -
Have you received court papers or is this a seller (most likely far easten) chancing their hand?0
-
It doesn't matter, they don't have a case.jennystarpepper said:Amazon seller is claiming funds from me via the small claims court stating that as I left a review about the faulty item Amazon have stopped it's sale because of me.
Would Amazon tell them they stopped sale because of me? How would they have proof Amazon did this because of me?1 -
yes, uk seller.ssparks2003 said:Have you received court papers or is this a seller (most likely far easten) chancing their hand?MFW - 01.10.21 £63761 01.10.22 £50962 01.10.23 £39979 01.10.24 £27815. 01.01.25. £17538
01.03.25 £14794. 01.04.25 £12888
01.05.25. £11805. 12.05.25 £9997 05.06.25 £8898.
01.07.25. £7975 01.08.25 £6968 01.09.25 £5956. 01.10.25 £49790 -
Thank you, I thought this was the case.davidmcn said:
It doesn't matter, they don't have a case.jennystarpepper said:Amazon seller is claiming funds from me via the small claims court stating that as I left a review about the faulty item Amazon have stopped it's sale because of me.
Would Amazon tell them they stopped sale because of me? How would they have proof Amazon did this because of me?
apologies if my post/s are garbled.
(The court document also misspelt my name).MFW - 01.10.21 £63761 01.10.22 £50962 01.10.23 £39979 01.10.24 £27815. 01.01.25. £17538
01.03.25 £14794. 01.04.25 £12888
01.05.25. £11805. 12.05.25 £9997 05.06.25 £8898.
01.07.25. £7975 01.08.25 £6968 01.09.25 £5956. 01.10.25 £49790 -
Are you sure it's a real court claim? Does it have a court stamp on it? Have you tried logging on to MCOL (the password is on the court document) to check that the claim is real?
How much was the item and how much is the claimant claiming?Jenni x1 -
yes, I have been online to check via gov. website.Jenni_D said:Are you sure it's a real court claim? Does it have a court stamp on it? Have you tried logging on to MCOL (the password is on the court document) to check that the claim is real?
How much was the item and how much is the claimant claiming?
MFW - 01.10.21 £63761 01.10.22 £50962 01.10.23 £39979 01.10.24 £27815. 01.01.25. £17538
01.03.25 £14794. 01.04.25 £12888
01.05.25. £11805. 12.05.25 £9997 05.06.25 £8898.
01.07.25. £7975 01.08.25 £6968 01.09.25 £5956. 01.10.25 £49790 -
jennystarpepper said:
yes, I have been online to check via gov. website.Jenni_D said:Are you sure it's a real court claim? Does it have a court stamp on it? Have you tried logging on to MCOL (the password is on the court document) to check that the claim is real?
How much was the item and how much is the claimant claiming?And? Is it genuine?[EDIT: Sorry I don't understand if you mean "Yes - I've been on the website... " or "Yes - it's genuine..."]1
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 352.2K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.6K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 454.3K Spending & Discounts
- 245.2K Work, Benefits & Business
- 600.9K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 177.5K Life & Family
- 259K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards

