Water Meter Dispute
in Water bills
9 replies 1.5K views
in Water bills
I have recently had a water meter fitted and my bill has gone down from £45 a month to £19 can i claim back the last 18 years of over charging?
This discussion has been closed.
Latest MSE News and Guides
Did you know there's an MSE app?
It's free & available on iOS & AndroidMSE App
Regifting: good idea or not?
Add your two cents to the discussionMSE Forum
Energy Price Guarantee calculator
How much you'll likely pay from AprilMSE Tools
You haven't been overcharged!
You have had the option to switch to a meter at any time in those 18 years but chose not to do so - or hadn't read the literature that comes with the bill that tells you about meters.
You didn't need to read through 20+ pages from Thames Water. A meter has been well known to be cheaper for many people for many years so I don't think TW will be returning any money to you. You weren't charged a "guesstimate" You were charged according to the rateable value of your house (as set in about 1991)
You were not charged an "inflated guesstimate", you were charged a set fee based on the rateable value of your home which was calculated before 1990 by an independent party. This is not something you can challenge and is a fixed value.
Like Cardew said the only person to blame is yourself for not getting a water meter before now. The water companies actually want everyone on a meter (all properties built since 1990 have one) so they wouldn't put barriers in place to stop you getting one.
The 20 approx pages was in regard to the installation so did need to be read thoroughly :T as you mentioned "cheaper for many people" but not all :A Thames Water had no idea how many people lived at the property so yes was a guesstimate :T
So how was the rateable value worked out then when the "independent party" had no idea of consumption or how many people lived at the adress :T
If only there were sites that told you the simple calculation they used ;-)
You seem to be completely missing the point we are making. To quote the water regulator ofwat:
"Rateable Values were an assessment of the annual rental value of a property"
(Read all about it here: https://www.ofwat.gov.uk/households/your-water-bill/unmetered/)
The Rateable Value has Nothing to do with how much water they think you will use.
So if you don't have a water meter you simply pay a charge based on this value which then lets you use water at your property.
If you decide it's too high you have the option to change to a water meter and pay only for what you use.
They are two different ways of paying for water usage and the important bit is that when you pay water rates they aren't guessing how much you will use and it has nothing to do with how much they think you will be using.
The main purpose of the Rateable Value(RV) of a property was for collection of 'local taxes' before the introduction of 'Poll Tax' and the current Council Tax.
You can research 'RV assessment' yourself, but essentially it was based on the estimated rent the property could command - not the value of a property. Many factors affected RV - size, location, modernisation, local amenities etc etc. For England and Wales most properties were last assessed in 1971, or in any case before April 1990 when RV was abolished for collection of local taxes.
In April 1990 water meters were mandatory for new properties. However existing properties had the choice of remaining on RV based charges. Some properties with a low RV and several occupants were better off remaining on RV charges.
Leaving aside the 20 page document, most water companies refer to meters in the bumph they send out with the annual water bill.