'Misleading' Walkers Crisps competition banned

Former_MSE_Faye

ASA has banned an ad for a Walkers Crisps competition which offered 20,000 holidays after more than 100 complaints...

Read the full story:
''Misleading' Walkers crisps competition banned'

Click reply below to discuss. If you haven’t already, join the forum to reply. If you aren’t sure how it all works, read our New to Forum? Intro Guide.

DynasticDux

Already posted here
https://forums.moneysavingexpert.com/discussion/5511564

and here
https://forums.moneysavingexpert.com/discussion/5511596

DynasticDux

'I spent over £50 on Walkers'

MoneySavingExpert.com's Coupon Kid Jordon Cox was among those scrabbling to find packs of crisps with the right letters.
He says: "The whole thing was a massive shambles! Being an avid comper, I was one of the first people to grab some Spell and Go packs when they first came out in May. Immediately it became apparent that the elusive letters would be 'C', 'D' and 'K' – every destination had at least one of those letters in.


"I collected over 100 packs of crisps during the promotion and spent over £50 on Walkers…

Reminds me of the famous saying
A fool and his money are soon parted


From the MSE Comping guide
Spending to enter competitions is NOT MoneySaving

mjm3346

The competition has not been "banned" they could run it again tomorrow if they wanted, they are just required to promote it differently.

I cannot believe an MSE employee had not sliced through the T&C's then crunched the numbers and crisply realised how little chance there was of getting the winning letters - there will have been 100's of millions of promotional packs produced and somewhere around 20,000 will have been winning ones.


Could have picked up some idea of how little chance there was of winning from forum posts in May

https://forums.moneysavingexpert.com/discussion/5459522

One-Eye

I won a "D" "O" "C" and a "K" but didn't want to go to the Docks so I chucked them away.

slbhill

Read the full story:
'EE recalls ALL power bars in new safety alert'

Think someone forgot to update their link text


But not the same person who spent 50p per pack on 100 packs. I'd be embarrassed to admit that!


I don't know why it came as a surprise that some letters were hard to find. These comps always work that way - don't Macdonalds do it fairly regularly with their monopoly thing.

VT82

The way it's written, that Coupon Kid seemed to expect to not need to spend more than about £50 on crisps to win a £2k holiday. Erm, if it was that simple, everyone would be doing it! Being an 'avid comper'. he obviously doesn't really believe that would be the case, and it's been written to be more sensationalist than it needs to be, but he comes across as really thick in the article as it stands.

ChamomileTao

I get the latest ASA rulings mailed to me so knew about this days ago, basically they got the customary slapped wrist. Nothing more.

hamsterfan1

this is the link to the ruling

https://www.asa.org.uk/Rulings/Adjudications/2016/8/Walkers-Snacks-Ltd/SHP_ADJ_340578.aspx#.V7WSL_krLcs

DynasticDux

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2010/sep/01/crisps-british

Walkers, is the biggest crisp factory in the world. It processes 800 tonnes of potatoes a day. It has six, 200m-long production lines, each of which turns out three tonnes of crisps an hour. That's maybe 120,000 small 25g packets. Per hour. Times six. And this is only one of Walkers's seven UK crisp plants. Between them, they produce 10 million packets a day, satisfying just under half this country's appetite for potato chips.

Comp run time
Enter between 00.01 GMT on 10th April 2016 and 23.59 GMT on 31st July 2016

So let's say they started producing packets 1st April - and stopped producing them 1st July - that's 92 days of producing 10 million packets a day

So that's 920,000,000 million codes in circulation
And "The Coupon Kid" expected to win a £2,000 holiday buying just 100 packets !!!


920,000,000 / 20,000 = 46,000
So that's 1 winning C, D or K in every 46,000 packets

toniq

And their new comp is meant to be fairer they say......