MSE News: Victory for passengers on flight delay claims in European court ruling 17 September 2015 at 9:44AM edited 18 September 2015 at 9:22AM in Flight delay compensation 40 replies 8K views

Former_MSE_Helen

The ECJ has ruled that technical problems are not "extraordinary circumstances", meaning passengers can claim...

Read the full story:

Victory for passengers on flight delay claims in landmark European court ruling




Click reply below to discuss. If you haven’t already, join the forum to reply. If you aren’t sure how it all works, read our New to Forum? Intro Guide.

glentoran99

is this new?

fermi

glentoran99 wrote: »

is this new?

Yes, it is a result hand down by the ECJ today.

http://curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/2015-09/cp150105en.pdf

Vauban

It's Van dear Lans - the airline was arguing an interpretation of Wallentin along the lines of spontaneous technical faults being extraordinary circumstances. Oddly, the ECJ didn't agree ...

Tyzap

It's groundhog day!

I'm sure I've seen a judgement almost identical to that before, what a surprise - not.

IMO this case should never have been referred up to the ECJ, it was a weak link (judge) who should have know better.

glentoran99

Tyzap wrote: »

It's ground hog day!

I'm sure sure I've seen a judgement almost identical to that before, what a surprise - not.

IMO this case should never have been referred up to the ECJ, it was a week link (judge) who should have know better.

Yeah that's what I thought,

Dr_Watson

So if you are a litigant with your claim on hold/stayed because of this, particularly with Ryanair-
Now is the time to contact your court and get the stay lifted...
Surgery is open, and i'm expecting it to be busy.
Good luck and keep going.

NoviceAngel

and I thought we were having a holiday for a few weeks, get your Ryanair claims in, and get any stays lifted NOW!!

Good luck

NoviceAngel

Smudge's_Lot

I am afraid that as I work for an airline,this will only be self defeating.

Does anybody out there think that paying say £100 for a flight should then be entitled to £300 compensation when a crucial part on the plane fails for whatever reason?

Do you get compensation from National Express coaches when a coach gets a tyre puncture and you are delayed?

Do you get compensation that is 3 times your ticket cost for when your train is delayed by strong winds bringing down power cables?

Parts can and do fail and yet with the strongest safety ethic in almost any industry,do you think some airlines will now just go ahead and fly rather than delay the flight so they are not liable for compensation......

Is your £300 worth that risk that has been imposed by the ECJ.??

The compensation culture will only mean that businesses will increase costs,and guess who ends paying that-look at car insurance-part of everyone's insurance pays for the sore neck culture out there,so with airlines,fares WILL go up and some airlines WILL cut corners

Is that what we want?

111KAB

No what we want is an efficient punctual flight and I for one do not mind paying the 50p extra per person per flight as proven by Jet2's own figures in respect of the cost to them for 261/2004 claims.

Smudge's_Lot

I am not suggesting that Jet 2 would cut corners but some airlines WILL because the flood gates have been opened by the ECJ which means they will have to pay out if a technical fault affects the flight-do you think your extra 50p guarantees that no part will fail-no,that's the nature of machines!does everybody's car run faultlessly every day,every year,even with servicing,does your car run with no defects-ever?