IAS decisions at a real court

The_Deep

[FONT=Times New Roman, serif]Has anyone been taken to court by a PPC after the IAS adjudicator has refused their appeal?[/FONT]

[FONT=Times New Roman, serif]If so, have they shown the real judge the kangaroo court's .decision, and if so, what has been his/her comment?[/FONT]

Are there any such cases in the pipeline?

enfield_freddy

I would like to add , has anyone (as above) and asked the judge to find who the "mysterious" barristers were that denied the claim

bazster

I have often said that if an IAS "adjudication" makes an appearance in a real court the defendant should request it be disallowed as evidence on the grounds that it is anonymous.

bargepole

bazster wrote: »

I have often said that if an IAS "adjudication" makes an appearance in a real court the defendant should request it be disallowed as evidence on the grounds that it is anonymous.

I've been in court a couple of times where an adverse POPLA decision has been brandished by the claimant's representative.


Judges have dismissed it as non-statutory and therefore irrelevant, and taken a similar stance with the BPA Code of Practice.


I doubt that an IAS adjudication would get anything other than short shrift.

bazster

Perhaps a cheeky defendant in possession of a typical disregard-the-facts-and-the-law IAS adjudication could include it himself as evidence of the claimant's bad faith!

BenefitMaster

bazster wrote: »

Perhaps a cheeky defendant in possession of a typical disregard-the-facts-and-the-law IAS adjudication could include it himself as evidence of the claimant's bad faith!

As soon as an IAS member is dumb enough to ticket me - I will...

hoohoo

Here are some of the more bizarre rulings it would be interesting to put in front of a judge.

"There is no case law on this yet as the statute is too new so I will not make a ruling"
"This does not apply because of [quotes legislation long since superceded]"
"A contract can be offered and accepted by driving past at 30mph, even if the motorist cannot possibly read all the words"

and my personal favorite
"The onus is on the motorist to prove their case. The motorist did not provide evidence of signage"
...from an airport where the only way to get photographs of signage would be to...er stop

trisontana

Are you sure they are proper barristers and not baristas moonlighting from Starbucks?

enfield_freddy

we will never know as this is all hidden and performed over morning coffee by the two apprentices at the PPC

Half_way

If I was to receive an ipc ticket any so called ias reply would be greeted with a barrage of complaints, together with a put up or shut up letter to the ppc and landowner

enfield_freddy

or simply go to court , show your appeal and there reply , and ask for those that wrote it , to appear