IMPORTANT: Please make sure your posts do not contain any personally identifiable information (both your own and that of others). When uploading images, please take care that you have redacted all personal information including number plates, reference numbers and QR codes (which may reveal vehicle information when scanned).

📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!

POPLA Decisions

1…510511513515516

Comments

  • Car1980
    Car1980 Posts: 3,781
    Part of the Furniture 1,000 Posts Name Dropper Combo Breaker
    Forumite

    It's complaints@

  • Oakley2702
    Oakley2702 Posts: 109
    Part of the Furniture 10 Posts Name Dropper Combo Breaker
    Forumite

    Decision

    Unsuccessful

    Assessor Name

    Michelle Drinkwater

    Assessor summary of operator case

    The parking operator issued the parking charge notice (PCN) for the vehicle not being authorised to park.

    Assessor summary of your case

    The appellant raised the following points from their grounds of appeal: • The signs are not prominent, clear or legible and there is insufficient notice of the sum. • ParkingEye v Beavis does not apply and refer to the Protection of Freedoms Act (PoFA) 2012 regarding the charge amount. • They refer to the Consumer Rights Act 2015 with respect to signage. • No signage at the entrance to the venue or inside it. • The operator has not shown that the individual who it is pursuing is the driver. • No evidence of landowner authority. • Unfair practices under active CMA Consumer Protection Investigation. • They are happy to take the matter to court. After reviewing the parking operator’s evidence, the appellant expands on their grounds of appeal regarding signage, Consumer Rights Act 2015, landowner authority and keeper liability. They say the exemption list does not prove that they failed to register. In support of their appeal, the appellant submitted the following: 1. Grounds of appeal (Summarised above). 2. Photographs of the entrance to the venue and inside. 3. Photographs of the car park. 4. Photograph of the car park entrance. This evidence has been considered in making my determination.

    Assessor supporting rational for decision

    The Protection of Freedoms Act (PoFA) 2012 is a law that allows parking operators to transfer the liability to the registered keeper in the event that the driver or hirer is not identified. Parking operators have to follow certain rules including warning the registered keeper that they will be liable if the parking operator is not provided with the name and address of the driver. In this case, the driver has not been identified; therefore, I must see whether the operator has complied with the relevant sections of the Protection of Freedoms Act (PoFA) 2012 for them to transfer liability to the keeper. I have reviewed the PCN, and I am satisfied all sections have been met therefore, I am considering Mr *** liability as the keeper of the vehicle.

    The parking operator provided evidence of the signs on the car park, which advise that a £100 PCN will be issued to drivers who do not register their full and correct vehicle registration on the console in the pub to obtain 3 hours free parking. The operator has provided a copy of their automatic number plate recognition images which show that the vehicle was on site for a total duration of 52 minutes. The operator has provided a copy of their permit report which shows that when they searched for the appellant’s vehicle registration against those vehicles where a permit had been obtained, no match was found. This demonstrates that the appellant did not register their full, correct vehicle registration as required and, therefore, the vehicle was not authorised to park on this day.

    The Private Parking Sector Single Code of Practice (The Code) sets the standards its parking operators need to comply with. Section 14.1 of the Code states that where controlled land is being managed on behalf of a landowner, written confirmation must be obtained before a parking charge can be issued. In this case the operator has provided a copy of the agreement they have with the landowner which shows they are authorised to operate on the land. I am satisfied that the agreement meets the requirements set out in section 14.1 of the Code.

    The operator has also provided photographs showing signage at the site and that ANPR cameras are in place at the site. On the balance of probabilities, if this equipment is placed on the land and the landowner hasn’t given permission, I doubt that they would allow them to operate on the land. I acknowledge that the appellant says that the signs are not prominent, clear or legible and there is insufficient notice of the sum. As the appellant has questioned the signage at the site, I will, therefore, need to determine whether the signage at the site meets the requirements set by the Code. I also acknowledge that the appellant has provided images of the car park. Section 3.1.3 of the Code contains the requirements for signs displaying the terms and conditions. The signs must be placed throughout the site, so that drivers have the opportunity to read them when parking or leaving their vehicle. The terms and conditions must be clear and unambiguous, using a font and contrast that is conspicuous and legible.

    Both the appellant and the operator have provided images of the entrance sign to the car park which tells motorists that parking must be validated at the console inside the premises and to see the signs within the car park for the terms and conditions. The operator has provided multiple images of the signage within the car park as well as a copy of their site map which demonstrates the location of the signs within the car park. The site map shows that the car park is very small site. The images provided by the appellant also demonstrates that there is signage within the car park and location of which matches the locations of the signs demonstrated by the operator’s evidence. The signs clearly display the terms and conditions for parking at the site and showing the PCN amount in bold. Based on the evidence provided by both the appellant and the operator, I am satisfied, that there is sufficient signage for the size of the car park and that the signs meet the requirements set by section 3.1.3 of the Code.

    The images of the signage are date stamped February and June 2026, demonstrating that these terms and conditions have been in place since February 2026. The evidence provided by the appellant also demonstrates these signs in place at the site, I am, therefore, satisfied that these signs were in place at the time of the parking event, as no evidence has been presented to demonstrate otherwise. The driver of the vehicle does not need to have read the terms and conditions of the contract to accept it. There is only the requirement that the driver is afforded the opportunity to read and understand the terms and conditions of the contract before accepting it. It is the driver’s responsibility to seek out the terms and conditions, and ensure they understand them, before agreeing to the contract and parking. Reviewing the photographic evidence of the signage on display at the site, I am satisfied that the appellant as the driver was afforded this opportunity.

    It must be noted that the operator manages the car park outside of the venue and, therefore, it is not required to place signage on the venue entrance or inside the venue, this would be down to the venue themselves to place if they so wish. It must be noted, however, that it is not the responsibility of the pub or their staff members nor are they required to bring the terms of parking to a motorist’s attention, this is on the driver alone to ensure they seek out, read and understand the terms before committing to parking. Section 5.1 of the Single Code of Practice states that parking operators must allow a consideration period of appropriate duration, subject to the requirements set out in Annex B to allow a driver time to decide whether or not to park.

    The operator must allow a motorist a minimum of 5 minutes from entering the site to park, read the terms and conditions and decide if they can comply with them, if they cannot, then they can leave without incurring a PCN. Where a motorist chooses to remain then they are deemed to have accepted the contract offered. In this case the vehicle remained on site for 52 minutes, I am, therefore, satisfied that the driver accepted the contract offered and agreed to register their vehicle to obtain a permit to park. I acknowledge that the appellant says that ParkingEye v Beavis does not apply and refer to the Protection of Freedoms Act (PoFA) 2012 regarding the charge amount. The Supreme Court considered private parking charges in a high-profile case, ParkingEye v Beavis.

    The Court recognised that parking charges have all the characteristics of a contractual penalty, but nevertheless were enforceable because there were legitimate interests in the charging of overstaying motorists. It concluded that a charge in the region of £85 was proportionate, and it attached importance to the fact that the charge was prominently displayed in large lettering on the signage itself. While the specific facts of the case concerned a free-stay car park where the motorist had overstayed, I consider the principles that lie behind the decision remain the same. Taking these principles into account, I am not going to consider whether the loss is a genuine pre-estimate of loss or whether it reflects a correct loss to the landowner. Rather, I am going to consider the charge amount in the appellant’s case, as well as the legibility of the signage. After reviewing the signage provided by the operator, I am satisfied that the signage is legible, and the charge amount is in the region of £85 and therefore allowable. The Court’s full judgement in the case is available online should the appellant want to read it.

    POPLA is satisfied that this court case applies to all private car parks, as it simply states that consequences of not complying with the terms and conditions and the amount of the charge has to be clear on the signage. In this case, I am satisfied it is clear that failure to comply with the terms and conditions will result in a PCN of £100. I also note that the appellant has referred to the Consumer Rights Act 2015 and it must be noted that while the Consumer Rights Act 2015 has not been considered by a court, its predecessor the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations (UTCCR) 1999 has been. For all intents and purposes, in relation to unfair terms, they are the same in substance. In ParkingEye-v-Beavis, the court considered whether an unpaid parking charge was (a) a penalty; and (b) unfair, according to UTCCR 1999. They concluded: “In our opinion, the same considerations which show that the £85 charge is not a penalty, demonstrate that it is not unfair for the purpose of the Regulations I understand that the appellant refers to alleged unfair practices that are the subject of a CMA consumer protection investigation.

    However, when assessing an appeal, POPLA considers whether the operator has complied with the BPA Code of Practice, not CMA requirements. Any concerns about how an operator manages the land should be raised with the BPA or the landowner, as these matters fall outside POPLA’s remit. The appellant is within their right to go to court if they choose. If they wish to do this, I recommend that they seek independent legal advice. After considering the evidence from both parties, did not obtain a permit authorising parking and therefore did not comply with the terms and conditions of the site. As such, I am satisfied the parking charge has been issued correctly and I must refuse the appeal. POPLA is not involved with the financial aspect of the parking charge. For any queries regarding payments, the appellant will need to contact the parking operator directly.

  • 9 Nov 2026

    Thank you to everyone on this forum and Coupon-mad in particular.

    Your advice on replying to notice of keeper for a PCN on Stansted Airport land was invaluable in guiding through the process to appeal the PCN.

    DecisionSuccessfulAssessor NameBethan WenhamAssessor summary of operator case

    The parking operator issued the parking charge notice (PCN) for parking in a restricted street during prescribed hours.

    Assessor summary of your case

    The appellant raised the following points from their grounds of appeal: • 1. No keeper liability – land is not “relevant land” under POFA 2012. • 2. Driver has not been identified. • 3. No contract can be formed – prohibitive “No Stopping” signage. • 4. Inadequate signage and lack of site‑specific evidence. After reviewing the parking operator’s evidence, the appellant reiterates their grounds of appeal but also expands on their grounds of appeal in relation to the "Letter of Authority" undermines the operator’s case. Failure to Prove "Relevant Land" and Misrepresentation of Byelaws. The appellant has also expanded on prohibitory Signage Cannot Form a Contract. Inadequate Signage / Lack of Site-Specific Proof. In support of their appeal, the appellant submitted the following: 1. Overall summary of appeal. This evidence has been considered in making my determination.

    Assessor supporting rational for decision

    I am allowing this appeal and will detail my reasoning below: By issuing a PCN the parking operator has implied that the terms and conditions of the private land have not been met. When an appeal is brought to POPLA, the burden of proof begins with the parking operator to demonstrate the breach they claim has occurred. I must therefore assess the terms and conditions of the site, any relevant code of practice, or legislation to determine if the PCN has been issued correctly. In this case the operator has issued the PCN for parking in a restricted street during prescribed hours. • 1. No keeper liability – land is not “relevant land” under POFA 2012. Schedule 4 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 defines "relevant land" at paragraph 3. Paragraph 3(1)(b) specifically excludes any parking place that is provided or controlled by a traffic authority from the definition of relevant land. The parking operator has provided a letter confirming that the site is under the control of a traffic authority. As Schedule 4 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 defines "relevant land" and specifically excludes land that is provided or controlled by a traffic authority, I am satisfied that the site is not relevant land for the purposes of the Act. I note the appellant has raised other issues as grounds for appeal, however, as I have decided to allow the appeal for the reason above, I did not feel they required further consideration.

  • Jenni_D
    Jenni_D Posts: 5,665
    Fifth Anniversary 1,000 Posts Name Dropper Photogenic
    Forumite

    OMG! An assessor who acttually understands PoFA?

    Jenni x
  • gentlex
    gentlex Posts: 5
    Name Dropper First Post
    Newbie
    edited 10 November at 8:13PM

    DecisionSuccessfulAssessor NameSultana YasminAssessor summary of operator case

    The operator has issued the Parking Charge Notice (PCN) vehicle remaining in the car park longer than the stay authorised or without authorisation.

    Assessor summary of your case

    The appellant has provided their grounds of appeal, which I’ve summarised below: • The appellant states they are the hirer of the vehicle and have not identified the driver. • The appellant argues that ParkingEye has failed to meet the POFA 2012 requirements for transferring liability to a hirer. • The appellant states that the required hire documents, including the Notice to Keeper, hire agreement, and statement of liability, were not provided with the Notice to Hirer. • The appellant argues that any failure to provide these documents within the statutory timeframe cannot now be corrected. • The appellant states that being the hirer does not make them liable as the driver has not been identified. • The appellant states that they raised these POFA concerns with ParkingEye during the appeals process, but the operator failed to address them. • The appellant requests that the appeal be allowed because the operator has not established hirer liability under POFA 2012. The appellant reiterates upon their grounds of appeal. The appellant states: • The appellant states that the operator's evidence confirms they are the hirer of the vehicle. • The appellant states that they raised the POFA hirer liability issue twice and did not identify the driver. • The appellant states that the operator has not provided evidence that the required hire documents were served with the Notice to Hirer. • The appellant states that the operator has relied on keeper liability requirements rather than the hirer liability requirements under POFA. • The appellant states that the operator has not demonstrated compliance with paragraphs 13 and 14 of POFA. • The appellant reiterates that the driver has not been identified. • The appellant requests that the appeal be allowed. The appellant has provided 1. Appeal text cleanly formatted 2. ParkingEye letter sent by email dated 2 September 2026 3. ParkingEye Notice to Hirer dated 4 August 2026 - both pages 4. ParkingEye rejection dated 12 September 2026 After reviewing the operator’s evidence, the appellant has provided all the above to support their appeal. All of the above has been considered in making my determination.

    Assessor supporting rational for decision

    I have allowed this appeal for the following reason: By issuing the Parking Charge Notice (PCN), the operator asserts that the vehicle was not parked in accordance with the terms and conditions of the site. In appeals of this nature, the evidential burden rests with the operator to demonstrate, through clear and sufficient evidence, that the PCN has been issued correctly. Having carefully considered the appellant’s grounds of appeal, along with the evidence provided by both parties, I note that the appellant states that they are the hirer of the vehicle, that they have not identified the driver, and that the operator has failed to comply with the requirements of Schedule 4 of the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012 relating to the transfer of liability to a vehicle hirer. The appellant submits that the mandatory documents required under paragraphs 13 and 14 of Schedule 4 were not supplied with the Notice to Hirer and, therefore, liability has not been established. Upon review of the evidence, I am not satisfied that the operator has demonstrated full compliance with the requirements necessary to transfer liability from the driver to the hirer. As the appellant has appealed solely as the hirer and has not identified the driver, I am not satisfied that the operator has established liability for the Parking Charge Notice against the appellant. Taking all of the above into account, I am not satisfied that the operator has adequately addressed the appellant’s grounds of appeal or that they have acted in accordance with the spirit and intent of the Code. Accordingly, I conclude that the PCN has not been issued correctly, and I allow this appeal.

    Full case details are in the following post:

  • Coupon-mad
    Coupon-mad Posts: 167,090
    Part of the Furniture 10,000 Posts Name Dropper Photogenic
    Forumite

    Very good NTH POPLA win!

    PRIVATE 'PCN'? DON'T PAY BUT DON'T IGNORE IT (except N.Ireland).
    CLICK at the top or bottom of any page where it says:
    Home»Motoring»Parking Tickets Fines & Parking - read the NEWBIES THREAD
★ ★ ★ Meet your Ambassadors

🚀 Getting Started

Hi new member!

Our Getting Started Guide will help you get the most out of the Forum

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 356K Banking & Borrowing
  • 255K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
  • 456.3K Spending & Discounts
  • 248.5K Work, Benefits & Business
  • 606.2K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
  • 179.1K Life & Family
  • 264K Travel & Transport
  • 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
  • 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
  • 37.7K Read-Only Boards
Quick Search

Is this how you want to be seen?

We see you are using a default avatar. It takes only a few seconds to pick a picture.