We'd like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum... Read More »
PLEASE READ BEFORE POSTING: Hello Forumites! In order to help keep the Forum a useful, safe and friendly place for our users, discussions around non-MoneySaving matters are not permitted per the Forum rules. While we understand that mentioning house prices may sometimes be relevant to a user's specific MoneySaving situation, we ask that you please avoid veering into broad, general debates about the market, the economy and politics, as these can unfortunately lead to abusive or hateful behaviour. Threads that are found to have derailed into wider discussions may be removed. Users who repeatedly disregard this may have their Forum account banned. Please also avoid posting personally identifiable information, including links to your own online property listing which may reveal your address. Thank you for your understanding.
We're aware that some users are experiencing technical issues which the team are working to resolve. See the Community Noticeboard for more info. Thank you for your patience.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Buying house (no mgage) 'renting' to son questions
Options

nictry
Posts: 29 Forumite
I need some advice, am considering buying a second property (no mortgage) and then allowing my son to live in the property, he would pay 'rent' to us at a nominal level but would not plan to make this official as a rental as essentially it would be transferring his housekeeping at home to payments made whilst he 'house sits' for us
I realise that this may be seen as questionable but principally I am concerned about the legality/taxable implications as you might expect, also whether there are any obvious pitfalls of purchasing the property for cash and ultimately when I come to sell (retirement ~20 years) would I then be liable for anything other than CGT on the profit?
As above, property and all bills would be in my name. Are there any other concerns/issue I should be considering before deciding to progress this idea further
Thanks for any advice as really not sure about the pros/cons of this idea
I realise that this may be seen as questionable but principally I am concerned about the legality/taxable implications as you might expect, also whether there are any obvious pitfalls of purchasing the property for cash and ultimately when I come to sell (retirement ~20 years) would I then be liable for anything other than CGT on the profit?
As above, property and all bills would be in my name. Are there any other concerns/issue I should be considering before deciding to progress this idea further
Thanks for any advice as really not sure about the pros/cons of this idea
0
Comments
-
I can think of far too many cons and not enough pros with this idea, regardless of the tax-implications.
The moment you accept a penny in rent you will have to declare it on your tax-return as income, regardless of whose names are on the bills or who pays them0 -
Ok, so we go the route of 'declaring' on the tax return, assume this can be in my wife's name (20% taxpayer) and as such we would comply legally with the HMRC in all regards, do we then have any other issues to consider?
I am not trying to do anything illegal/immoral but simple looking to provide an option for my son to live on his own without being penalised myself0 -
You'll be a landlord. Simple.
Rent is income for income tax.
Capital Gains Tax.
Gas Safety Certificate/EPC.
Basically all the legal responsibilities that come with being a landlord.
I'm not saying don't do it. I'm just saying if you decide to do it, do it properly!
NewLandlords (information for new or prospective landlords)0 -
I think your motives are very generous indeed. But by accepting rent you will be acquiring all of the many legal responsibilities of a landlord and your son all of the rights of a tenant.
If buying another property was never in your long-term investment plans I would question why this route would be a good idea. If it was, a tenant who is not related to you would be more sensible and more profitable.
Renting to friends or relatives can bring terrible complications. Most especially if circumstances should change in the future.0 -
Is your son likely to need to be in receipt of housing benefit? If so, you need to look up 'contrived tenancy' because an arrangement such as you describe is likely to mean that he won't be given it.0
-
Please run an advanced search, this comes up several times a week. If your son is paying rent - and even sometimes if he is not - he is a tenant according to the Inland Revenue, your lender and the law. I don't see how you can claim house sitting: this doesn't appear to be your only or main home, it does appear it will be his only or main home, and you haven't mentioned it being a temporary arrangement.
The council tax at the very least should be in your son's name, also he should be on the electoral register. If your son is in receipt of any benefits or means tested payments like student finance he will have to declare that you are subsidising his lifestyle, it is not just cash income. Agree 'contrived tenancy' may be relevant.
If your son has mental or behavioural reasons for not being responsible for his own bills, you may consider Power of Attorney or joint accounts so that you can help manage his income without actively taking money off him. This should mean you won't have to declare all your incomings and outgoings in respect of bills to the taxman so reducing the liability and hassle. If there is no such reason I'd question how much you are helping by treating a grown adult like an irresponsible child.Declutterbug-in-progress.⭐️⭐️⭐️ ⭐️⭐️0 -
I appreciate you may be trying to be helpful but your post comes across as rather patronising and in parts disrespectful
I am not saying and have not said anything other than trying to help my son become self sufficient in a climate that would render this situation impossible through his own means ie his income does not allow any possibility of him buying his own him
He does not claim anything and all I was trying to achieve was allowing him to 'live' on his own in a property I would purchase and he old pay an amount allowing me to essentially receive the same as if the funds were still in my own account
I do not want to profit from him and do not want to cause him or me to be penalised, nothing more nothing less
Please do not jump to conclusions without knowing more facts or assume this is anything other than dealing with an economic climate that does not support children being able to become homeowners by themselves!Please run an advanced search, this comes up several times a week. If your son is paying rent - and even sometimes if he is not - he is a tenant according to the Inland Revenue, your lender and the law. I don't see how you can claim house sitting: this doesn't appear to be your only or main home, it does appear it will be his only or main home, and you haven't mentioned it being a temporary arrangement.
The council tax at the very least should be in your son's name, also he should be on the electoral register. If your son is in receipt of any benefits or means tested payments like student finance he will have to declare that you are subsidising his lifestyle, it is not just cash income. Agree 'contrived tenancy' may be relevant.
If your son has mental or behavioural reasons for not being responsible for his own bills, you may consider Power of Attorney or joint accounts so that you can help manage his income without actively taking money off him. This should mean you won't have to declare all your incomings and outgoings in respect of bills to the taxman so reducing the liability and hassle. If there is no such reason I'd question how much you are helping by treating a grown adult like an irresponsible child.0 -
I appreciate you may be trying to be helpful but your post comes across as rather patronising and in parts disrespectful
I am not saying and have not said anything other than trying to help my son become self sufficient in a climate that would render this situation impossible through his own means ie his income does not allow any possibility of him buying his own him
He does not claim anything and all I was trying to achieve was allowing him to 'live' on his own in a property I would purchase and he old pay an amount allowing me to essentially receive the same as if the funds were still in my own account
I do not want to profit from him and do not want to cause him or me to be penalised, nothing more nothing less
Please do not jump to conclusions without knowing more facts or assume this is anything other than dealing with an economic climate that does not support children being able to become homeowners by themselves!
Jump to conclusions, what conclusions??? You appear to be reading between the lines, ascribing opinions, motivations or 'tone of voice' to me that are not based in reality. Should I get offended that you make erroneous assumptions and describe me in less than flattering terms when I have tried to help? Try reading my posts in a blunt or brusque tone of voice, it's quite possible with the exact same wording.
I don't give a monkeys whether your son is claiming benefits or has mental health problems or is a student: I used the word IF four times so no conclusions. If you didn't like "I don't see how you can claim ... " that meant to the aforementioned Inland Revenue, lender or the law and I stand by it. The last sentence was the only part that was my opinion, the remainder was factual.Declutterbug-in-progress.⭐️⭐️⭐️ ⭐️⭐️0 -
Ok, so we go the route of 'declaring' on the tax return, assume this can be in my wife's name (20% taxpayer) and as such we would comply legally with the HMRC in all regards, do we then have any other issues to consider?
I am not trying to do anything illegal/immoral but simple looking to provide an option for my son to live on his own without being penalised myself
If you want the income to be your wife's (for HMRC purposes) then presumably you are happy for her also to own the house?0 -
I appreciate you may be trying to be helpful but your post comes across as rather patronising and in parts disrespectful
I am not saying and have not said anything other than trying to help my son become self sufficient in a climate that would render this situation impossible through his own means ie his income does not allow any possibility of him buying his own him
He does not claim anything and all I was trying to achieve was allowing him to 'live' on his own in a property I would purchase and he old pay an amount allowing me to essentially receive the same as if the funds were still in my own account
I do not want to profit from him and do not want to cause him or me to be penalised, nothing more nothing less
Please do not jump to conclusions without knowing more facts or assume this is anything other than dealing with an economic climate that does not support children being able to become homeowners by themselves!
You are not helping your son become self sufficient if you are going to buy him a house and only charge him 'keep'.
By all means buy another house BUT rent to your son at a normal rate and have the bills in his name, he needs to learn to stand on his own to feet OR stay at home.Pay ALL your debt off by Xmas 2023 #59 £7008 Paid £570 Owing £6438 #1 H1 £151, #2 H2 £100, #3 O £200, #4 M £1500, #5 Z £295, #6 C1 £340, #7 L £1084, #8 N £840, #9 C2 £19300
This discussion has been closed.
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply

Categories
- All Categories
- 350.9K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.1K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 453.5K Spending & Discounts
- 243.9K Work, Benefits & Business
- 598.8K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 176.9K Life & Family
- 257.2K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.6K Read-Only Boards