📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!

Expert advice needed on issues with a car bought from a dealer

2»

Comments

  • Joe_Horner
    Joe_Horner Posts: 4,895
    Ninth Anniversary Combo Breaker
    Forumite
    A trade sale [STRIKE]usually happens[/STRIKE] only ever between two motor traders, you don't get a warranty or any after-sales stuff, it's sold as seen but for a lower trade price(can be £100s off). A dealer who tries to claim he sold on these terms to a consumer is breaking the law.

    Fixed that and expanded it a little for you. Assuming the car was advertised to the general public (includes being on his forecourt as for sale) there is absolutely no way he can claim "trade sale". Taking your car as a trade-in also rules it out.

    Invite him to either sort the problems, part refund to allow for them, or get ready to explain how this could possibly have been a "trade sale" to his local Trading Standards.

    If he sorts it for you, then report it anyway because dealers trying that one on give ALL dealers a bad name which many of them don't deserve!
  • adamlewis216
    adamlewis216 Posts: 15 Forumite
    Thank you again.. well considering I didnt know what a trade sale was I cant see how he can claim thats what it was.. the car was advertised on autotrader, their own website and it was on his forecourt.. I have a sales invoice that makes no mention of trade sale.

    Is the misleading advert for two seperate vehicles something trading standards will be interested in.. ie.. the car i bought not being of the spec they advertised, and the car i part ex'd being found to be clocked with a true mileage of 140,000 yet they were advertising it after that with the clocked mileage of 90,000??

    I seem to be getting no assistance from them to even discuss a resolution.. what do i do next if after one more try.. do i repair the car and take them to small claims for the repair bill.. or not throw good money after bad and pursue them to accept the car in return for a refund..

    Is there anyway I could be in the wrong.. if we forget the spec differance and just deal with the faults on the car.. is three months acceptable to expect repair.. my research suggests it is but does anyone have any contrary reshearch or experiences.

    Thanks again for all your help
  • Joe_Horner wrote: »
    Fixed that and expanded it a little for you. Assuming the car was advertised to the general public (includes being on his forecourt as for sale) there is absolutely no way he can claim "trade sale". Taking your car as a trade-in also rules it out.

    Invite him to either sort the problems, part refund to allow for them, or get ready to explain how this could possibly have been a "trade sale" to his local Trading Standards.

    If he sorts it for you, then report it anyway because dealers trying that one on give ALL dealers a bad name which many of them don't deserve!

    Having the car on sale to the general public does not rule out a trade sale. Two of our previous cars have been purchased by OH's father who is in the business as trade sales. One was on the forecourt on general sale. When it came to buying it OH's dad said put it down as a trade sale (cheaper price) and it was driven away on trade plates. OH's dad sorted out tax etc.
    Save £200 a month : [STRIKE]Oct[/STRIKE] Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr
  • Well I have never even heard of a trade sale, and it certainly wasnt mentioned to me.. I recieved no discount and paid a fair market price for the vehicle, no mention of this in my paper work either.. so guess he doesnt have a leg to stand on with this claim?

    just replied to his last email.. although im so peeved I keep writing too much im sure.. so sorry about its length again..

    Dear Sirs,

    If you bothered to read the emails I have sent you you would realise that I am the person that purchased the vehicle from you, so why you would write 'firstly your husband purchased the car. he left us a balance of 100 to pay which he never did' shows the lack of effort you are putting into assisting me.

    I write you a detailed email only to receive a poor response not answering any of the points I raise.

    In response to your previous email.

    'firstly your husband purchased the car. he left us a balance of 100 to pay which he never did'

    Of course I did not pay the remainding £100 of the balance. I agreed a price before arrival and travelled a long way to Bradford. I provided you with my vehicle reg the day before attendance. I brought with me the exact balance due. £2500, and my vehicle for part exchanged for which you agreed to pay £795. The vehicle I was buying was advertised at £3295.

    Upon arrival I was shown the vehicle, I agreed to buy it at the deal agreed previously. It was only when it came to the point of sale you informed me there was a problem and that you required £100 more because your checks had shown that my part ex vehicle had been clocked. Firstly you could have done checks on the vehicle in the 24 hours before I attended as you had the reg. But instead you agreed a price and left it until I was paying for the vehicle to suddenly change the deal and charge me £100 more, almost like a hijack. I had travelled along way and was excited at the prospect of a new car. I told you I did not have it and so you phoned a male who you told me was the business owner and he refused to allow me to drive the vehicle away unless I agreed to forward one hundred pounds two weeks later when I got paid.

    I subsequently realised the car was not of the spec you advertised, and that despite reducing the p/x price of my vehicle (your reasoning being that as a dealer you could only sell it on at its true mileage thus reducing its value) you completely ignored this and started advertising it with its false mileage - thus penilising me £100 for the mileage - whilst dishonestly trying to mislead a future customer into believeing the car had less miles meaning you could make more profit from the sale.

    'the contract was broken when he didnt pay the balance'.

    I tried calling you numerous times regarding this £100 to inform you that I would be withholding the £100. You did not answer or call me back and so I sent a text. From the date of purchase you have not emailed, phoned, text or written to me regarding this balance, therefore I could only presume you accepted it.

    If in any way you are correct that not paying the balance ended the contract - then surely that means you agree to the return of this vehicle for a full refund? As you deem the contract as broken and not complete, so the purchase was never completed and I can reject the car. Is this correct?

    'we did the deal on a trade sale basis'


    I have had to research what a trade sale basis is as I have not heard this frase before. Therefore, it is impossible that this is true. I am not a motor dealer - nor have I ever been. I was buying a family car. I was placing my current family car in part exchange. You advertised the vehicle on auto trader, your own website and on your forcourt. I paid a fair market value for the car and did not recieve any discount.

    According to my research claiming it was a deal on a trade sale basis is illegal and a tool used by scrupulous car dealers to mislead a customer into believing he has no rights. I have been informed to report you to your local trading standards for attempting this. So please give me a full explanation as to how this could ever be a trade sale, or get ready to explain it to trading standards. I am sure they will also be interested in the evidence of false advertising.

    'the roof was working when your husband checked the car. no lights were showing. har was fault free'
    Please read the document OFT guidance to second had car dealers I enclosed in my previous email. The fact the car roof retracted fine on one occasion does not mean there was not a fault, and I am not liable that on the second occasion it failed. As it is within the first six months it is presumed the fault exsisted and it is your responsibilty to repair. The same applies with engine faults. They occured soon after and are again presumed to be exsisting faults in the eyes of the law, and again you are liable for them.

    This is my final offer of coming to a satisfactory solution without the need for legal action. Please confirm to me if you are willing to repair the vehicle or have it repaired at a cost to you.. or whether you are prepared to take the vehicle in return for a full refund. If you refuse to assist me in this my third and final attempt I will pursue legal action and report you to trading standards for the beeches I believe you have commited.

    Regards,
  • thegirlintheattic
    thegirlintheattic Posts: 2,761 Forumite
    edited 4 June 2012 at 11:18PM
    Focused but still too long winded. You need to be simple and to the point - you don't have to pick his replies apart. Your reply is too emotional and convoluted - this gives it less of an impact and makes it look like you don't know what you are doing.

    Literally needs to be no longer than -

    Dear xxx,

    The car xxx which you sold to me on xxx has the following faults:
    -
    -
    -
    -

    Legally you are required to either repair the car or provide a full refund. You have 7 days to respond with either option or I will pursue legal action.

    As for the trade sale - it's obvious you knew nothing about it - he's playing a well known scam on that one and knows he's in the wrong.
    Save £200 a month : [STRIKE]Oct[/STRIKE] Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr
  • I am emotional and don't know what I am doing lol.. guess I'm trying to sound like I do to scare him into action.. obviously not coming across that way and why am failing. will try to refrain from the waffle from now on. thanks for all your help guys.. see what reply tomorrow brings.
  • adamlewis216
    adamlewis216 Posts: 15 Forumite
    Found this article today which happened a month before i bought.. why oh why did i not thoroughly google them prior to buying.. cant believe that they were allowed to continue trading after this.. im guessing I am gonna have no hope with my claim..?? what does everyone think.. surely they will just fold up and wangle it to start up again under a new name.. cant see them confessing and paying everyone off?



    GARAGE IS RAIDED IN WRITE-OFFS SCAM PROBE

    8:00am Thursday 2nd February 2012
    By David Knights »

      Police raided a Keighley garage this week as part of a major operation against alleged car sales fraudsters.
      A man was arrested at Pennine Motor House, in Bradford Street, Lawkholme, by officers from West Yorkshire Police’s Economic Crime Unit.
      A total of five men were arrested in raids on four garages in Keighley, Bradford and Dewsbury on Tuesday morning.
      Four cars were seized, including a Porsche and two Audis, during the joint operation with West Yorkshire Trading Standards.

      Police also seized a quantity of cash from the garages.
      The searches formed part of an investigation into expensive vehicles that had their official insurance status altered in order for them to be sold on at a higher value.
      A total of 52 cars were found to have been written off by an insurance company only to be badly repaired and then sold to unsuspecting customers at a higher price.
      HPI checks on the vehicles were shown as being clear with no acknowledgement to the damage that they had suffered.
      All of the owners whose vehicles have had their histories edited have been notified.
      Police believe those involved in the alleged conspiracy have profited by £500,000.
      Men aged 44, 38, 33, 31, and 26 were all arrested on suspicion of conspiracy to commit fraud.


      Chief Trading Standards Officer Graham Hebblethwaite said: “Cars recorded as repairable motor salvage lose 50 per cent of their retail value.
      “This is a fact not lost on certain individuals who will go to any lengths to make illegal profits from motor trading.
      “By botching repairs to return crashed vehicles to the road and effectively erasing their histories, innocent car buyers have been defrauded and all road users have been put at risk.
      "We will continue to work with the West Yorkshire Police to bring legal proceedings against those responsible. Buyers should always consider an independent mechanical report on vehicles before purchase."
      Temporary Detective Chief Inspector Fran Naughton, of the Economic Crime Unit, said: “Despite these vehicles having been declared as ‘write offs’, this information was not recorded and therefore the HPI checks highlighted that these vehicles were clear of damage.
      “These vehicles would then be sold on having had substandard repairs carried out causing substantial risk to the car owner and other members of the public.
      “We will continue to work with the Trading Standards to establish those responsible in this conspiracy and ensure that they can no longer pose a threat to road users.”
      Police this week said Pennine Motors, at the junction of Bradford Street and Lawkholme Lane, was formerly known as Blue Ocean.
      In March 2008, while trading as Auto Transform, the garage was attacked by a gunman who fired four bullets from a handgun into the workshop.
      A mechanic and the manager, who were working on a car at the time, escaped injury as the gunman and his accomplice ran off.
      All of the men who were arrested have been released on police bail.
    • adamlewis216
      adamlewis216 Posts: 15 Forumite
      patman99 wrote: »
      Btw, OP, it is not good to include email addresses and car reg numbers in your postings. Also, your initial posting of the email exchange was back-to-front as this is the way email clients work ie newer responses ahead of older ones. This makes your opening post hard to get to grips with.

      As you had no need to open the roof prior to the sunny weather you would have had no idea there was an issue with it. As for a claim under the SOGA, you may need more expert advice (IE CAB). You say it was a trade sale so the garage may have done this in order to reduce your rights so you may have a complaint about that, as T/S take a dim view of dealerships doing this and will take great interest in them.[/QUO

      Thanks, edited it
    • I'm really sorry to hear about your problem, and I hope the below can help a bit.

      I had a similar problem with a company called Platinum Motorhouse, a now dissolved car dealer which had links to Pennine Motor House. I won't bore you with the details of my issue but I ended up taking them to small claims court. I won and they were ordered to repay me the money for the car, the court fees and some compensation. A year later I am still waiting for the money (and this is now 2 years after the event).

      So I'm not sure it's a route I'd recommend from personal experience, but unfortunately it may be your only option. But if you do take them to small claims court you must make sure to get the judgement in the name of the company AND an individual (owner/director). This means that when they don't pay up and inevitably dissolve the company there is still someone you can chase for the money. Although the guy I'm still chasing (now through court bailiffs) lets his kids or wife answer the door when the bailiffs come round instead of doing it himself, which indicates just what lowlives they are. I don't really know what happens from here and am facing the infuriating prospect, after having forked out for court fees, of seeing nothing at all.

      So, I can't recommend whether you should take them to court or not, but at least (I think you already have done?) make sure trading standards are aware and hopefully they will shut these guys down before they can rip off and endanger anyone else.

      All the best.
    • motorguy
      motorguy Posts: 22,650
      Part of the Furniture 10,000 Posts Name Dropper
      Forumite
      I'm really sorry to hear about your problem, and I hope the below can help a bit.

      I had a similar problem with a company called Platinum Motorhouse, a now dissolved car dealer which had links to Pennine Motor House. I won't bore you with the details of my issue but I ended up taking them to small claims court. I won and they were ordered to repay me the money for the car, the court fees and some compensation. A year later I am still waiting for the money (and this is now 2 years after the event).

      So I'm not sure it's a route I'd recommend from personal experience, but unfortunately it may be your only option. But if you do take them to small claims court you must make sure to get the judgement in the name of the company AND an individual (owner/director). This means that when they don't pay up and inevitably dissolve the company there is still someone you can chase for the money. Although the guy I'm still chasing (now through court bailiffs) lets his kids or wife answer the door when the bailiffs come round instead of doing it himself, which indicates just what lowlives they are. I don't really know what happens from here and am facing the infuriating prospect, after having forked out for court fees, of seeing nothing at all.

      So, I can't recommend whether you should take them to court or not, but at least (I think you already have done?) make sure trading standards are aware and hopefully they will shut these guys down before they can rip off and endanger anyone else.

      All the best.

      Any particular reason why you replied to a thread from five months ago?

      We'd have to assume there is progress by now...
    This discussion has been closed.
    ★ ★ ★ Meet your Ambassadors

    🚀 Getting Started

    Hi new member!

    Our Getting Started Guide will help you get the most out of the Forum

    Categories

    • All Categories
    • 355.9K Banking & Borrowing
    • 255K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
    • 456.2K Spending & Discounts
    • 248.4K Work, Benefits & Business
    • 606.1K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
    • 179.1K Life & Family
    • 264K Travel & Transport
    • 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
    • 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
    • 37.7K Read-Only Boards
    Quick Search

    Is this how you want to be seen?

    We see you are using a default avatar. It takes only a few seconds to pick a picture.