Windows UPVC vs. Timber

oz0707

Be really appreciated if as many people as possible would vote/give opinions on this.

For context this is regarding what to put into a newbuild bungalow with low maintenance in mind
The windows are stipulated as white on the planning permission.

Given the above which do you think the end user would prefer, timber or plastic? I'll hold my opinions back until i'ver got a few answers so as not to influence! Forget cost, it has no bearing on my decision.

Not to clever with attaching a poll, bear with me!

jkpd

Timber

You cant beat pre-finished timber windows,cost a third more than upvc,look much nicer,less parts to wear,but for resale in a average new build everyone wants upvc,shame but true.

Nile

UPVC

I won't take it personally that as soon as I posted on your other thread, you asked for it to be deleted.;)

Here's what I said:

A new build bungalow won't have period features/style, so I would vote for upvc white windows.

The bungalow is for older persons who might prefer to wipe their window frames with a cloth, rather than having to paint them periodically............so I would vote for upvc white windows.

The occupiers might like the ease of opening (and the option to lock the windows open) upvc windows, compared with the tendancy of wooden windows to stick and need a shove to open or close..............so I would vote for upvc white windows.

Over the years, I've lived in homes with wooden sash windows, wooden (non sash type) windows and upvc windows.

I'm a big fan of upvc windows because:

They stop draughts completely
They cut out noise and sounds from outside
They help to insulate/keep the home warm
They are maintenance free/no painting

You get the picture?:D

oz0707

Ha, it was because the poll wasn't attached! Thanks though, much appreciated...
More the merrier!

leveller2911

As a joiner I can't bring myself to click the Upvc button, however on a new build,constructed for an older couple,low maintenance etc I would have to say Upvc....

Having said that as a general rule I would say timber every time. A well made hardwood timber window will outlast any Upvc window, timber will need maintaining but with modern materials this can be carried out every 5-8 yrs on most occaisions.The sealed units will need replacing on bothe Upvc and timber well before the window frames need replacing. When a window needs replacing it can provide energy to heat the home so its Carbon neutral...


.How many 150 yr old Upvc windows are there?...;)

Once the old couple have pegged it a young couple could buy it and invest in some quality wooden windows that will add to the style and value of the house, Upvc doesn't add any value to a house.. I replace more and more Upvc with wooden ones..

MX5huggy

Timber

I voted timber, but actually you want to consider Aluminium clad wood. VELFAC being one manufacture. I would want a grey, blue grey or green grey finish, if you could get the planning changed. What's the target u value on your SAP calculation?

Hintza

Timber

We had thi debate on our new build the Timber won easily in the end. They are just so much smarter. Try and find a good family timber window firm and if you are in Scotland can I suggest Skotland Joinery.

oz0707

I'm certain the end user would prefer UPVC in this context. The poll seems to say otherwise!

Yorkie1

UPVC

Given the stipulations of the original post re. target owners and criteria, upvc would win my vote.

That's not the same as asking which I'd prefer, all else being equal.

oz0707

I think that's the way this question has been answered in the poll results. To read the replies UPVC seems to win hands down. UPVC seems to make sense to me.

To be fair timber would have been less outlay for me as I wouldn't of had to pay myself to make & paint them. I'd like to save the money to be honest, but I can just envisage someone saying "it's lovely, but...timber windows, draught paint etc etc etc".

Hintza

Timber

oz0707 wrote: »

draught paint etc etc etc".

Where is the draught in decent timber windows?

Stick in UPVC and you are getting close to make it easier just to board up the window they are thick and heavy set. They will need replacing much sooner too. Decent timber will last 150+ years.

OK timber are a pain in that they are painted but with modern timber windows and decent paint that shouldn't be too onerous.