Ready, steady… save!
You don’t need a chart to join in. Here are 2 ways to record your savings:
1. Cross it off
Pop a chart into your first post. Saved an amount? Cross it out! Read more »
£0.01 £0.02 £0.03
2. Write it down
Skip the chart and add updates to your first post. Read more »
“Another +£3 saved today. Go me!”
Use +£ before each new saving so it counts towards your total.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
PAYG vs Sim Only Plans?
JosephDuffy
Posts: 14
Forumite
in Mobiles
Hello,
I'm getting an iPhone 4S for Christmas, and I would like the move from GiffGaff (O2) to get better signal in my area. I've found Vodafone have good signal, so I'm currently looking a them.
I'm stuck between PAYG and Sim Only Plans. With GiffGaff, I get Unlimited Internet and Texts and like 100 minutes for a tenner a month. Looking at Vodafone, it's a very good deal. I'm seeing a PAYG deal for £10 which gives you 500MB internet (enough for Siri?) 300 texts and the £10 credit (equivalent to 40 minutes). I think this is pretty much my usage, but I'd like a few more minutes.
Looking at the SIM only plans, for £10.50, you get 100 minutes (a bit more like it), 3000 texts (more than enough), and 250MB of Internet (not quite enough). However, they only charge £1 per extra 100MB.
Is this the sort of thing you can haggle? Can I ask for less texts, and more Internet, or something like that? I have also seen (might have been T-Mobile or another carrier) that they offer unlimited internet for browsing, and that the included Internet is for streaming or something like that.
I've got a few things to look over, but I can't find a deal that looks ok, which is why I'd like to haggle this, IF you can. I think I could get away with Orange or T-Mobile, too, but they both seem worse than Vodafone.
Any ideas?
I'm getting an iPhone 4S for Christmas, and I would like the move from GiffGaff (O2) to get better signal in my area. I've found Vodafone have good signal, so I'm currently looking a them.
I'm stuck between PAYG and Sim Only Plans. With GiffGaff, I get Unlimited Internet and Texts and like 100 minutes for a tenner a month. Looking at Vodafone, it's a very good deal. I'm seeing a PAYG deal for £10 which gives you 500MB internet (enough for Siri?) 300 texts and the £10 credit (equivalent to 40 minutes). I think this is pretty much my usage, but I'd like a few more minutes.
Looking at the SIM only plans, for £10.50, you get 100 minutes (a bit more like it), 3000 texts (more than enough), and 250MB of Internet (not quite enough). However, they only charge £1 per extra 100MB.
Is this the sort of thing you can haggle? Can I ask for less texts, and more Internet, or something like that? I have also seen (might have been T-Mobile or another carrier) that they offer unlimited internet for browsing, and that the included Internet is for streaming or something like that.
I've got a few things to look over, but I can't find a deal that looks ok, which is why I'd like to haggle this, IF you can. I think I could get away with Orange or T-Mobile, too, but they both seem worse than Vodafone.
Any ideas?
0
Comments
-
Have a look at my post over in the three signal thread - they are cheapest (£10 for 300min/3000sms/1GB, 12 months with £54.54 back via Topcashback). Worth checking their coverage.Certain OTT members have caused me to add this disclaimer: all advice given is free of charge & as such should be taken to be IIRC (as I don't spend hours researching all answers :eek: )!0
-
T-mobile are doing 12x£7.50 for 300+300+Unltd(browsing)/500Mb(downloading).
£50.50 cashback through TCB.0 -
-
Take a look at the sim only deals with Talkmobile but go via Quidco for better deals.
They use the Vodaphone network which you seem to prefer.
http://www.quidco.com/talkmobile/0 -
Take a look at the sim only deals with Talkmobile but go via Quidco for better deals.
They use the Vodaphone network which you seem to prefer.
I was wondering whether or not there would be an alternative like this (GiffGaff --> o2). Due to o2 having bad signal here, I always though that it was just o2, and not GiffGaff, however, do these companies who use their signal (in this case, talkmobile), have some sort of restrictions on them? For example, is the internet speed capped or anything?
If not, this is my perfect deal! I would seem a 6 months plan @ £8 (£48) with £30 cashback is very good. I am now liking T-Mobile, so might get a PAYG deal from both and see which is better signal
0 -
I'm certainly interested in Talkmobile but I wouldn't touch Quidco - by the time they eventually pay out, i'll have likely paid off the whole contract
0 -
jasonwatkins wrote: »I'm certainly interested in Talkmobile but I wouldn't touch Quidco - by the time they eventually pay out, i'll have likely paid off the whole contract

They actually have the same deal at TCB. My main question is, can you get the cashback every 6 months? If so, that makes it better than T-Mobile, if not, it makes it worse (over 12 months).0 -
JosephDuffy wrote: »They actually have the same deal at TCB. My main question is, can you get the cashback every 6 months? If so, that makes it better than T-Mobile, if not, it makes it worse (over 12 months).
Very highly unlikely. Some of the smaller value Quidco transactions will track pretty quickly, but some of the higher priced ones, like the TalkMobile ones, could take anywhere between 30-90 days to track. Then potentially another 90 days to confirm payment, and it'll be paid out in one lump sum as well.
There are people on the Quidco thread still waiting for transactions made back in January.
So as i've said on here before, it's a bit of a false economy because when the payout eventually gets to you it's a lot more like you've won a little lump sum on the lottery because the original transaction is a long, distant memory.0 -
JosephDuffy wrote: »I was wondering whether or not there would be an alternative like this (GiffGaff --> o2). Due to o2 having bad signal here, I always though that it was just o2, and not GiffGaff, however, do these companies who use their signal (in this case, talkmobile), have some sort of restrictions on them? For example, is the internet speed capped or anything?
If not, this is my perfect deal! I would seem a 6 months plan @ £8 (£48) with £30 cashback is very good. I am now liking T-Mobile, so might get a PAYG deal from both and see which is better signal
Very well spotted & then missed - there are differences between billing types on a network; take the O2/Giffgaff/Tesco scenario - allegedly O2 contract customers get the best, Giffgaff & O2 pay and go are the same, but many reports have suggested that O2 pay and go also get better than Giffgaff. No idea if the full ranking is O2 contract then tesco contract then O2 pay & go then Giffgaff & tesco pay & go.JosephDuffy wrote: »They actually have the same deal at TCB. My main question is, can you get the cashback every 6 months? If so, that makes it better than T-Mobile, if not, it makes it worse (over 12 months).
You probably can, but you will need to port out to another provider & back - perhaps talk mobile for 6 months, then t-mobile for 12 & repeat?Certain OTT members have caused me to add this disclaimer: all advice given is free of charge & as such should be taken to be IIRC (as I don't spend hours researching all answers :eek: )!0 -
Very well spotted & then missed - there are differences between billing types on a network; take the O2/Giffgaff/Tesco scenario - allegedly O2 contract customers get the best, Giffgaff & O2 pay and go are the same, but many reports have suggested that O2 pay and go also get better than Giffgaff. No idea if the full ranking is O2 contract then tesco contract then O2 pay & go then Giffgaff & tesco pay & go.
You probably can, but you will need to port out to another provider & back - perhaps talk mobile for 6 months, then t-mobile for 12 & repeat?
This is my main issue. It is currently between T-Mobile (£42 for a year) and Talk Mobile (£33 for 6 months, but 700 more texts).
I think between the two, I'll go for T-Mobile. Once I get Orange 3G, I'll have great signal!
My only issue now is getting a Micro-SIM. I can just get a thing that cuts it, right?0
This discussion has been closed.
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 356K Banking & Borrowing
- 255K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 456.3K Spending & Discounts
- 248.5K Work, Benefits & Business
- 606.2K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 179.1K Life & Family
- 264K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards
