Adrian Flux vs Chris Knott £4.50 difference, same underwriter, what would you do?

forgotmyname

Google highway, Not a brilliant review....

http://www.mazdarotaryclub.com/forums/showthread.php?t=28074

Lirin

I'm with Flux/Highway for the V6 Lum- they've been very easy to deal with so far. the only gripe I'd have is they're a bit slow in answering emails, but that's not a major issue at all.
Unusual year, as I've had to change a few details- made the V6 my main driver, married, and had to change name as a result- they didn't charge me any admin fees, and I had the updated policy emailed out in a day.
I've had the coupe with Highway before, and had no problems, they seemed decent enough. Never had to claim off them though.
Chris Knott I've heard good reviews, but have never insured with- they don't cover NI.

only_mee

Was with highway and needed to claim from someone who hit me went without a hitch.

Lum

Small update, the Flux quote is a 4000 mile limited policy. The Chris Knott quote is unlimited mileage.

To get unlimited mileage from Flux is £830 so this decision suddenly got a lot easier. Still got a few more companies to ring though.

Lum

Chris Knott have agreed to match Flux's price while still offering unlimited mileage. Here's the current state of play

[B]Company         Price   Excess  Underwriter  Notes[/B]
A-Plan          none
Sky Ins         none
Chris Knott     £730.00 £250    Highway      Unlimited mileage
Adrian Flux     £730.00 £250    Highway      4000 mile limit, £870 unlimited
Peter Best      none
Tett Hamilton   none
Direct Line     £579.82 £250    N/A          Boost cont. and filter not allowed
Brentacre       none
Lancaster       none
Nowell and Rich none
Basildon Ins    none
Lifesure        none
Performance Dir £766.74 £300    Highway

Looks like I'll be going with Chris Knott this year. Have asked them to email me a schedule of everything I've told them to make sure it's correct.