Experience of Tesco Home Phone & Broadband

Woggle

Hiya,

I'm currently with O2 for broadband (BT for home phone).

I'm going to be changing mobile provider which will put up my monthly bills from O2 and therefore wondered about switching to Tesco (get both home phone and broadband with them) or Orange (my wife has a mobile contract with Orange).

Their current offers seem pretty good (Tesco £19 although appears to exclude caller display; Orange £17 per month - not sure about caller display) and on face value appears to better what O2 are offering (£22 plus another £1.75 for caller display). You also get Clubcard points on top of this for Tesco...

Before I jump in I wanted to see whether anyone had any reviews of this service - perhaps compared to O2.

Any thoughts?

PS. Also see Talk Talk do a similar deal - £18.48 (caller display free)

Woggle

So phoned up O2 today and they can offer me £17 per month (phone and broadband) regardless of whether I have an O2 mobile with them. Caller display would be an extra £1.75 per month so looking at £18.75 per month all inclusive.

Tesco offer £19 per month (phone and broadband) plus the added benefit of 1,000 Clubcard points and points ongoing for phone and broadband. However, they can't offer guarantee caller display will work - they say it is inclusive but don't know if it will work until I've gone live (therefore effectively can't cancel the contract with them).

I want to go Tesco (also includes free wireless 'N' router) but I'm being pulled more down the O2 route....any thoughts?