📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!

ESA Medical

Hi All

My father has been on ESA for a few months now and has just had the decision on a "Limited Capability for work assessment" to which he was awarded 12 points, 3 short of the needed 15 to be allowed the benefit.

I should point out that this is the 3rd time he has had a medical and they have ruled him fit to work. He has appealed to all three, won quite a few and lost 2. Illness wise he has Degenerative disc disease (lower back and neck-diagnosis from specialist consultant), incontinence, sleep problems, walking difficulty and depression.

As my father has a chequered history with these medical I decided to go his latest one and record the interview he had. Probably illegal but, was needed to cover our back in the eventuality that he didn’t get enough points! In the recording I made, you can clearly hear my dad saying that he has all the problems above, but in his decision letter it hasn’t awarded him for:

Incontinence

Bending or kneeling (which he couldn't do)

Memory and concentration (which was stated in the medical)

Coping with change (discussed with depression)

Doing/finishing jobs & Starting jobs and keeping on with them

With all these factors and the fact that my father is too stubborn to admit his disabilities (which is another reason why I went!!), Does anyone think we have a case to appeal, and telling the ESA assessors that we have a recording of the medical would help our case?

Any experiences or knowledge relevant to this I'd be grateful for.

P.S. If anyone tells you that the medical assessors are highly professional Dr's- don't trust them. I work for the NHS and I wouldn't employ them!
«134

Comments

  • nogginthenog
    nogginthenog Posts: 2,649 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture Combo Breaker
    moped_mark wrote: »
    Hi All

    My father has been on ESA for a few months now and has just had the decision on a "Limited Capability for work assessment" to which he was awarded 12 points, 3 short of the needed 15 to be allowed the benefit.

    I should point out that this is the 3rd time he has had a medical and they have ruled him fit to work. He has appealed to all three, won quite a few and lost 2. Illness wise he has Degenerative disc disease (lower back and neck-diagnosis from specialist consultant), incontinence, sleep problems, walking difficulty and depression.

    As my father has a chequered history with these medical I decided to go his latest one and record the interview he had. Probably illegal but, was needed to cover our back in the eventuality that he didn’t get enough points! In the recording I made, you can clearly hear my dad saying that he has all the problems above, but in his decision letter it hasn’t awarded him for:

    Incontinence

    Bending or kneeling (which he couldn't do)

    Memory and concentration (which was stated in the medical)

    Coping with change (discussed with depression)

    Doing/finishing jobs & Starting jobs and keeping on with them

    With all these factors and the fact that my father is too stubborn to admit his disabilities (which is another reason why I went!!), Does anyone think we have a case to appeal, and telling the ESA assessors that we have a recording of the medical would help our case?

    Any experiences or knowledge relevant to this I'd be grateful for.

    P.S. If anyone tells you that the medical assessors are highly professional Dr's- don't trust them. I work for the NHS and I wouldn't employ them!


    Do not tell them about the recording!..They will not be pleased,and it will not be counted as evidence...At a appeal. Hearing
    Child of a Fighting Race.
  • cit_k
    cit_k Posts: 24,812 Forumite
    Do not tell them about the recording!..They will not be pleased,and it will not be counted as evidence...At a appeal. Hearing

    Depends who deals with the case at the end of the day.

    There is no law stating that is categorically will not be usable in a appeal.

    In fact, previous precedence indicates it could well be accepted, as it was a covert recording. If it had been done overtly, and your benefits had been stopped because you told them you were going to record, then that would be a different matter entirely - you would lose....

    It is up to the tribunal on the day what evidence is accepted.

    You should appeal, you should also see a welfare rights advisor (free) as success rates are higher if you go to the appeal with one. You may not even need the recording, but its handy to have just in case. You may be able to win simply from how bad the medical report is likely to be, and giving evidence on the day.

    If you have not already received a full copy of the medical report, ring up the esa people and ask them to send you one, they will do so for free.

    You should also complain to ATOS ( go via your mp for best results, but dont expect any, although if you can tell him you have a recording, see what he says...)

    Its far to common, they have done it to me multiple times (ib medicals)...
    [greenhighlight]but it matters when the most senior politician in the land is happy to use language and examples that are simply not true.
    [/greenhighlight][redtitle]
    The impact of this is to stigmatise people on benefits,
    and we should be deeply worried about that
    [/redtitle](house of lords debate, talking about Cameron)
  • nogginthenog
    nogginthenog Posts: 2,649 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture Combo Breaker
    cit_k wrote: »
    Depends who deals with the case at the end of the day.

    There is no law stating that is categorically will not be usable in a appeal.

    In fact, previous precedence indicates it could well be accepted, as it was a covert recording. If it had been done overtly, and your benefits had been stopped because you told them you were going to record, then that would be a different matter entirely - you would lose....

    It is up to the tribunal on the day what evidence is accepted.

    You should appeal, you should also see a welfare rights advisor (free) as success rates are higher if you go to the appeal with one. You may not even need the recording, but its handy to have just in case. You may be able to win simply from how bad the medical report is likely to be, and giving evidence on the day.

    If you have not already received a full copy of the medical report, ring up the esa people and ask them to send you one, they will do so for free.

    You should also complain to ATOS ( go via your mp for best results, but dont expect any, although if you can tell him you have a recording, see what he says...)

    Its far to common, they have done it to me multiple times (ib medicals)...


    Audio and video taping of examinations

    Should a claimant attend the assessment requesting permission to either audio or videotape the medical assessment you should politely refuse on the following grounds:
    The Department for Work and Pensions never requires that a medical assessment for the purpose of advising on entitlement to state sickness or disability benefits be recorded on audio or videotape.
    Child of a Fighting Race.
  • dmg24
    dmg24 Posts: 33,920 Forumite
    10,000 Posts
    cit_k wrote: »
    In fact, previous precedence indicates it could well be accepted, as it was a covert recording.

    I assume that you mean precedent? If so, could you point us in the direction of the relevant case law please?
    Gone ... or have I?
  • nogginthenog
    nogginthenog Posts: 2,649 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture Combo Breaker
    Unauthorised taping
    It is for Atos Healthcare, in conjunction with their legal advisers, to determine the
    action to be taken in the event of a claimant making an audio or video recording
    without the prior knowledge and consent of the examining practitioner, or without
    ensuring that the safeguards defined above are in place
    Child of a Fighting Race.
  • Garry_Anderson
    Garry_Anderson Posts: 11,896 Forumite
    If the taping was made because of possible attempt to defraud claimant of their legal entitlement - and the taping shows there was an attempt - I cannot see ATOS taking any action - can you Nog?
  • spikeysoul
    spikeysoul Posts: 146 Forumite
    edited 24 August 2009 at 7:13PM
    Don't tell them you recorded it, you really arn't supposed to, you need professional sound equiptment and a qualified sound engineer and Atos permission to do this. As far as I am aware you maybe able to use a transcript though. I'm not totally sure on the last part - but if you admit you made the recording at best it will be ignored. Use it to 'aid' your own memory of the medical though - that can't hurt. Welfare Rights Officers are worth their weight in gold.

    Edit: Gary, Yes to discredit the claiment in any legal way they can - and to discourage others from doing the same, not to do so would set a dangerous precident for them
  • NASA_2
    NASA_2 Posts: 5,571 Forumite
    If the taping was made because of possible attempt to defraud claimant of their legal entitlement - and the taping shows there was an attempt - I cannot see ATOS taking any action - can you Nog?
    They would be within their right to say that the claimant or their coconspirators could have edited the tape to make them look bad. One of the reasons it isnt allowed (Without agreement) in the first place.
  • nogginthenog
    nogginthenog Posts: 2,649 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture Combo Breaker
    If the taping was made because of possible attempt to defraud claimant of their legal entitlement - and the taping shows there was an attempt - I cannot see ATOS taking any action - can you Nog?

    Strictly off the record,...We had a discussion in our Union legal department about the Dwp being allowed to tape you ..pertaining to fraud
    ...and the double standards saying you cannot tape them!

    Again off the record....WE where told if a recording was done without the knowledge of the dwp doctors...It must never been used exept in the most serious cases of malpractice. involving the courts or the GMC..
    ..........i HAVE USED VOICE RECORDS MYSELF...in a legal case against HMTR..at preston combined court......I had to write to the judge asking permission for the recordings to be used as evidence,My mp also wrote a letter in support.
    I doubt very much if a ESA appeal will allow voice records, a gmc council may...IF YOU ASK THEM FIRST.
    Child of a Fighting Race.
  • nogginthenog
    nogginthenog Posts: 2,649 Forumite
    Part of the Furniture Combo Breaker
    NASA wrote: »
    They would be within their right to say that the claimant or their coconspirators could have edited the tape to make them look bad. One of the reasons it isnt allowed (Without agreement) in the first place.

    It has to be done by a approved person,..ie qualified.
    Child of a Fighting Race.
This discussion has been closed.
Meet your Ambassadors

🚀 Getting Started

Hi new member!

Our Getting Started Guide will help you get the most out of the Forum

Categories

  • All Categories
  • 350.4K Banking & Borrowing
  • 252.9K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
  • 453.3K Spending & Discounts
  • 243.4K Work, Benefits & Business
  • 597.9K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
  • 176.6K Life & Family
  • 256.4K Travel & Transport
  • 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
  • 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
  • 37.6K Read-Only Boards

Is this how you want to be seen?

We see you are using a default avatar. It takes only a few seconds to pick a picture.