We'd like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum... Read More »
PLEASE READ BEFORE POSTING
Hello Forumites! However well-intentioned, for the safety of other users we ask that you refrain from seeking or offering medical advice. This includes recommendations for medicines, procedures or over-the-counter remedies. Posts or threads found to be in breach of this rule will be removed.We're aware that some users are experiencing technical issues which the team are working to resolve. See the Community Noticeboard for more info. Thank you for your patience.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Tight wad gazette (merged)
Options

janb5
Posts: 2,673 Forumite



Hi,
I read references to the above book . Has anyone read it and is it worth getting from the library- if available/
All help gratefully received! :j
I read references to the above book . Has anyone read it and is it worth getting from the library- if available/
All help gratefully received! :j
0
Comments
-
it is has a LOT of info that is only for american useage
BUT if you're new to OS or just need inspiration then it's brilliant for that aspect
i would recommend requesting 'the complete tightwad gazette' as it has all three of her books plus some extras in it
also the universal recipes are fantastic, i keep my copy with my recipe books if that tells you anything
the universal muffin recipe is great!
i'd definately recommend getting it from your library first before buying unless you can get it really cheap as you may find it too american (i'm american and i find it too american :rotfl: ) but it's a great motivator and many things are the same no matter what country you're infounder of Frugal Genius UK (Yahoo Groups)0 -
There are various opinions on it. I love it, some just don't get it!
It is very much aimed at the US market, obviously, and a lot of products and things mentioned are not relevant - or I don't know what they are!
BUT...
What Amy Da-whatshername does do, is to show you how to work things out for yourself. She gives an illustration somewhere in the book, of a class of children being taught maths - after she has demonstrated some multiplication problems, a student says, "I suppose a few kids might need to know that 37 times 79 equals 2,923.... but I don't. I need to know what 83 times 22 equals. Your'e just not giving me answers that help me." Amy explains that the teacher is teaching the process of multiplying by giving specific examples, in order that the students would master that process. She then goes on to say that in the TG she is not giving a list of specific hints & tips, but teaching the process of how to live frugally.
I hope that explains why I find the book useful.
Forgot to mention that I too have the Complete TG with all the books in (got it from Amazon - has probably paid for itself)
I did try to get it from the library, but the only one listed was the first book, and that wasn't available anyway!0 -
it's amy dacyzyn proncounced decision
i love it too, really do and you can tell because my copy is sooooo greasestained (pages 466-470 being the worst, that's where the universal muffin recipe is in the complete tightwad gazette!)
think i may have a read through it again!
i have recommended it so many times i should get revenue for it but you always get those complaining it's too american but as chipps and i both say, it's about teaching you and the motivation...that's it's real treasure!
when i first discovered it back in the states 12 years ago it was a huge eye opener. i've always been frugal minded but this book really got me going big time!founder of Frugal Genius UK (Yahoo Groups)0 -
I have the complete tightwad gazette too and I love it! A lot of it is very American as previously stated, but I like it because of the format it is written in it is easy to just dip in and out of. If you find you are slipping a bit on the old moneysaving/old styling thing, it really gets you back on track.
My favourite bits are the universal recipes like HOLsale, but also how she organizes her kids wardrobes and the clothing inventories. I admit to being fascinated 'cos Im a bit organized with my kids wardrobes too, at least Im not the only one!
I think it is abook that you either really like, or you just dont get it at all, so I would recommend borrowing a copy first. I got mine from the American Amazon site.
I think that the Old Style book may be a bit like the TG when it is published.0 -
Love it to pieces!!!
I agree with Holsale and Chipps completely. I've just ordered myself a hardback copy second-hand from Amazon.com as the book is rather flimsy and like Holsale's a bit stained.
If you read the reviews on Amazon you'll see a lot of people think it is too American, but like Chipps says it doesn't matter, because the author constantly points out that she is showing you how to apply her ideas to your own situation and that is what I find so great about it.
The recipes are v.good, I use the muffin recipe several times a week. Her advice on stocking your pantry 'the pantry principle' is what inspired me to start the thread on 'not meal-planning' the other day. I love what she says about bringing up (or should I say raising) kids not to be unquestioning consumers.There's a fantastic essay on 'creative deprivation', that is, the idea that children can have too much of a good thing, and that a wise parent actively slows down the avalanche of stuff and experiences that children can all too easily get overwhelmed by. She also has a very sensible essay on weight loss without spending a lot of money.
I have sticky markers on all my favourite pages.I refer to it constantly and would recommend it over and over again.
Another brilliant American book which Amy Dacyczyn also recommends is the More With Less Cookbook by Doris Janzen Longacre. My favourite cookbook,I bought my first copy in Nov 2003 and it is spattered and stained and written on with constant use. I now have a 'best'copy for bedtime reading! This book is full of easy recipes which use basic,cheap ingredients.
I'm so pleased to find other people who like the same books as me0 -
I have 2 of her books (purchased at a local library book sale - thats frugality for you). One recipe I consistently use is the cuban bread recipe. Any method where you can make a loaf of bread from scratch, and have it out of the oven in 1 hr 15 mins is a good one. I agree that these books are helpful to get you into the appropriate frame of mind for frugality.
Jennifer0 -
Thank you for all your input - I feel quite inspired to find it now and also Thriftladdy`s mention of the `More with Less ` cookbook - sounds good!
Jan0 -
I found it!! Amazon.co.uk £10.330
-
Yes, I definitely agree with the recommendation of More with Less, too. My copies of both books are in an advanced state of decay - and parts of the TG also have very wrinkled pages due to having been read too many times in the bath!!!!! Well, it's so good for inspiration! One of these days they will probably both have to be replaced, but not just yet.0
-
Chipps wrote:parts of the TG also have very wrinkled pages due to having been read too many times in the bath!!!!!0
This discussion has been closed.
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply

Categories
- All Categories
- 350.9K Banking & Borrowing
- 253.1K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 453.5K Spending & Discounts
- 243.9K Work, Benefits & Business
- 598.8K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 176.9K Life & Family
- 257.2K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.1K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.6K Read-Only Boards