We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.
This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
The Forum now has a brand new text editor, adding a bunch of handy features to use when creating posts. Read more in our how-to guide
Faulty 3 Year old TV
Comments
-
Hi all, just to give you an update, finally had a response from Crampton & Moore 8 days over my original deadline,
They are now challenging the report by the engineer, advising it needs to be on their approved agent list. The TV engineer advised me they would try this and to tell them if they want to pay for their own engineer to come out, then they can, but they won't want to as it will cost them a fair chunk, he said if they decline to instruct their own engineer then they can't challenge his report?
Does that sound right?0 -
You can get an Independent report from any company you wish (notice what i highlighted) as an engineer on their list is not Independent, and will be bias towards themHi all, just to give you an update, finally had a response from Crampton & Moore 8 days over my original deadline,
They are now challenging the report by the engineer, advising it needs to be on their approved agent list. The TV engineer advised me they would try this and to tell them if they want to pay for their own engineer to come out, then they can, but they won't want to as it will cost them a fair chunk, he said if they decline to instruct their own engineer then they can't challenge his report?
Does that sound right?0 -
I was going to reply with
If you would like to instruct your own "approved" agent please feel free to do so at your own cost. But as far as I'm concerned the independent report carried out by #### is more than sufficient0 -
This won't help you OP but worth noting for your next TV purchase. My last TV came from Richer Sounds. A month shy of being 5 years old it packed up. Richer Sounds took it in for evaluation, couldn't get the parts to fix it so gave me a brand new TV with a new 5 year warranty.
IE buy from somewhere with good customer stories about how things are dealt with when they go bad.Pants0 -
This won't help you OP but worth noting for your next TV purchase. My last TV came from Richer Sounds. A month shy of being 5 years old it packed up. Richer Sounds took it in for evaluation, couldn't get the parts to fix it so gave me a brand new TV with a new 5 year warranty.
IE buy from somewhere with good customer stories about how things are dealt with when they go bad.
Completely agree, at the time I'd just bought a house so was transfixed by price which has bit me in the bum0 -
Yes, just add those few lines into your LBA.I was going to reply with
If you would like to instruct your own "approved" agent please feel free to do so at your own cost. But as far as I'm concerned the independent report carried out by #### is more than sufficient
Don't let their tactics delay you further.0 -
I'd already sent the LBA so I put on the bottom
"to make you aware as you missed my stated response time by 8 days, the LBA is on the way"0 -
Oh now its I need a Samsung Approved agent!!! changing their tune again!0
-
Hi all, just to give you an update, finally had a response from Crampton & Moore 8 days over my original deadline,
They are now challenging the report by the engineer, advising it needs to be on their approved agent list. The TV engineer advised me they would try this and to tell them if they want to pay for their own engineer to come out, then they can, but they won't want to as it will cost them a fair chunk, he said if they decline to instruct their own engineer then they can't challenge his report?
Does that sound right?
Sounds like your tv engineer is right.
The other party are entitled to seek their own report at their cost. So you should make the tv available for inspection if they wish, and at their cost.
If they don't do this and the matter goes to court then the court will decide based on the evidence.
I suspect the court would regard your testimony plus the report you commissioned to be sufficient to prove your case in the absence of any report from the other party.
If the other party do decide to pay for a report that disagrees with your report you could still take them to court and the court would again decide based on all the evidence what to believe.
Either party can challenge the other party's evidence so either party could challenge the qualifications or independence of anyone undertaking a report. (However this is a small claims matter so the court won't be expecting a report from some expert in the field merely a competent, unbiased report.)
As others have said tvs are generally expected to be very durable so I would have thought in the absence of physical damage, and in the absence of any report suggesting evidence of misuse, you would win a partial refund. (But of course that is just my layman's view.)
Just seen your post about a Samsung Approved agent. I would again leave that for the retailer to pay. (If they ask you to agree to pay the cost of the report should they find the problem was not inherent then refuse. You already have the evidence you need. Plus a Samsung Approve agent may have a vested interest to keep Samsung sweet.)0 -
Sorry could I have a bit of advice on my next response please, her reply is
"After the first six months the burden is on the customer to prove that the product was faulty at the time of delivery and it needs to be with a registered approved repair agent."0
This discussion has been closed.
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 353.7K Banking & Borrowing
- 254.2K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 455.1K Spending & Discounts
- 246.8K Work, Benefits & Business
- 603.3K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 178.2K Life & Family
- 260.8K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards