New shiny slice the pie thread

tinkerbel

maybe its nearing the end of the scout room? or else all of the usa people are online and so are the uk people? I'm not too sure of the time differences!

BusyGirl

Yes very slow and stilted...makes the job even more frustrating!

WHUdaman

I'm finding it ok at the moment. for those who find it slow. if you have the face book app open at the same time try logging out of it as I find that significanly slows me doen at times

theamazingduck

Heres my latest one, although its not very constructive due to the rubbishness of the song...

I like the cheesey, over dramatic intro, but said over dramatics gets a bit old quickly. Too serious and over blown. Good energy but theres reasons why this kinda thing doesnt sell...vocals are more like shouting that singing and there isnt even a decent tune. Calm things down and work on tune and melody before going bezerk with little substance behind it.

a nicer one:

Quite a nice little track, tells a good story and vocally quite appealing. Guitar riff is simple but effective. Some good lines in the lyrics. Have to mark it down a little as commercially a purely acoustic track isnt all that viable - but would really like to hear a full band version of this, could be really good.

tinkerbel

ive been told off for my reviews being too similar!! I guess I've just sort of developed a style now

iwanttogoonholiday

i got told off for that too!!it said that its going to become very strict on it in the future as well!!oh dear!!

joeyjimbles

I've just done a review and it said that I was the 40th scout to review it. When they put the pennies down in the last scout room there were meant to be more reviews per track so does that hold for this room too I wonder or is it still around 40 per track? Anyone know?

misspixierocktastic

joey i was wondering wether this would be extended too because surely the same amount of people reviewing last time will review in this scout room too

joeyjimbles

I've just trawled the forums on STP and can't find anything about how many reviews this room is going to take. Sorry it took a while, I got distracted by the arguments on there. I think you have to be quite brave to post on there as almost everything seems to annoy someone! I'll stay here where its much more friendly I think.

Off to check the FAQs to see if they shed any light.

joeyjimbles

Not found anything useful - on the Scouting guide it still says 10-20 reviews per track. Anyway I've just reviewed something that said I was the 28th scout so its obviously pretty random or there were some late entrants.