Ready, steady… save!
You don’t need a chart to join in. Here are 2 ways to record your savings:
1. Cross it off
Pop a chart into your first post. Saved an amount? Cross it out! Read more »
£0.01 £0.02 £0.03
2. Write it down
Skip the chart and add updates to your first post. Read more »
“Another +£3 saved today. Go me!”
Use +£ before each new saving so it counts towards your total.
We’d like to remind Forumites to please avoid political debate on the Forum.
This is to keep it a safe and useful space for MoneySaving discussions. Threads that are – or become – political in nature may be removed in line with the Forum’s rules. Thank you for your understanding.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Items bought online hugely misrepresented
Comments
-
I'd start with the contract, the purpose for which the item is to be used, and for the normal meaning attached to the words item. A set of golf clubs is a set of golf clubs is a set of golf clubs - you cannot play a round of golf with a putting iron alone.
The constituent parts which form the item (because they can be bought separately) do not necessarily form the item.
0 -
To me the words and meaning of s75 are quite clear.
If the seller has chosen to attach a price of £100 or lower to any single item, then s75 does not apply to that single item. That is the literal meaning of the words of s75.
So if for example M&S sell "a suit" as a single item for £250, then s75 applies to the whole suit.
But if M&S decide to sell the suit coat separately for £150 and the trousers separately for £100, then the suit coat is covered but the trousers aren't.
If American Golf want to sell "a set of clubs" for more than £100, then the whole set is covered.
But if they want to sell each individual club separately (and that is usually the case) then s75 only applies to each club insofar as American Golf attached a price of over £100 to that club.
I may be mistaken, but the last time i bought what you might call "a suit" from M&S, the jackets and trousers were sold separately and appeared separately on the invoice. I would say they were separate items for the purposes of s75.
And I'd be amazed if you could buy "a set" of golf clubs individually where each club cost less than £100.
I want to know where this golf shop is as I'd like to lower my handicap as cheaply as possible!
[Edit: sorry - I agree with your opening point - what is the purpose of the contract. I'd say it's up to the consumer to make it clear when buying a suit that they want to buy a single suit and not individual jacket and trousers. If the retailer does not like that idea, go elsewhere. Ditto buying golf clubs. If you don't want to buy individual clubs, make that clear from the outset. Consumers need to be clearer somtimes about what they want so the contract is clear]
0 -
I am disappointed that there is a claque here which piles-on on anyone who raises the possibility that Section 75 may apply because the set constitutes the item. Only one person has accepted the possibility that there may be way in which this may be the case, whereas the self-appointed forum police have mocked and ridiculed anyone who suggests this.
For myself I'm not particularly bothered, but there was a genuine question from someone who had been clearly ripped-off and in will in all likelihood never see a penny back from the shysters who misdescribed tat.I'm sure you are all very amused with yourselves.
2 -
Not sure why you're trying to make this personal - as far as I'm concerned the debate has largely been civil and reasonably issue-based rather than being a 'pile-on' by a 'clique' of 'forum police', and I don't see any mocking or ridicule?
It seems obvious that there is scope for interpretation as to exactly what satisfies the 'single item' test in the legislation, so when you initially suggested that it's clear and offered a definition, I was simply asking for some meaningful backup, in terms of appropriate legal precedents, etc, but the dialogue ultimately gravitated to 'the case will turn on the individual facts' rather than there being a one-size-fits-all agreed definition, and this seems realistic.
In terms of OP's specific case, I accepted early on that there's likely to be merit in regarding a bedding set as a single item, but also suggested that their purchase (of four items) is unlikely to be a £100+ bedding set - obviously if they return to clarify exactly what they bought then more informed guidance can be given…
OP is undoubtedly in an unfortunate, but far from unique, position, and doesn't have many options, but I'm sure they'd be delighted to hear of any that haven't been mentioned so far?
1 -
I don't see a 'claque' (sic) here.
And - until the OP comes back…
0 -
I'm aware of the wording used in the legislation. I think the exact wording is important because it's the only way in which a court can decide what the legislature meant when it passed the legislation.
In the case of s75 of the consumer Credit act 1974 it talks about the price attached by a retailer to any single item
That wording seems unambiguous to me.
In particular it doesn't refer to any "cohesive whole" or to any collection of items that happen to be sold at the same time - irrespective of their purpose - which you seem to think it refers to, Rather it refers to "any single item"
I think what it actually says is how a court would interpret its meaning, rather than substituting its own words (or yours) for those used by the legislature.
That does not seem unreasonable to me.
But if you want to adopt some post-modernist approach where words actually mean something different from what they literally say… well good luck
You say you're disappointed.
I'm disappointed that despite several requests to do so, you've chosen not to give any evidence for your following claims:
"… but the law is clear, if the items are purchased at the same time and are part of a cohesive whole then S75 applies …"
and
"… it has been argued successfully multiple times in court …"
and
"I've seen credit card providers attempt to wriggle out of it, but where the items constitute a whole (hi-fi separates, camera and lenses etc.) and they are bought at the same time to be used as a coherent whole (and could not for example be used in any other way) then the law is clear that they constitute a single item …"
and
"And I was challenging the oft-stated but over-simplified view that any "item" under £100 does not come within scope of the Act "
and
"… I'm directly aware of several cases where precisely my point has been made, and the claimant persuaded a court of this"
If you think posters on these pages are giving wrong advice on the applicability of s75, and you are aware of court decisions or whatever confirming your view, please give us details so that we can correct the wrong information we are giving out
0 -
Consumer Credit Act Section 75.
Clause 75 (3) (b) states "so far as the claim relates to any single item to which the supplier has attached a cash price not exceeding [F2£100] or more than [F3£30,000] [F4, or]"
I can't find that "single item" is defined anywhere in the Act.
There is some "myth busting" from FoS:Unfortunately, that does not cover the "single item" question particularly well - the nearest example is four tickets to a comedy show. That is not a good match for the OP's bedding.
It seems difficult to find definitive interpretations of what comprises a "set". I might suggest that, in the absence of a specific definition in the legislation, then a "lay-person" interpretation is appropriate. As would be understood by "the man on the Clapham Omnibus". If Parliament intended otherwise, then Parliament would have required to provide a definition in the legislation.
So, this would be a "set":However, if I purchase the following separates, it would not be a "set" even if I purchased one duvet cover plus one pair of pillowcases:
https://www.johnlewis.com/john-lewis-pure-cotton-percale-bedding/white/p6379896
(Please ignore the values of the above being below £100 - I am using the examples for what is / is not a set.)
1 -
Also, rather than being a member of what you dramatically call a "claque", I often disagree with what other contributors post.
An example here concerning sports direct - Sports Direct — MoneySavingExpert Forum And no, I don't work for them
If you want to look - I can't be bothered wasting my time any further - you'll find other posts by me questioning the generally held view on here that for any faults more than 6 months after purchase you need an independent report
Here's a good example from me about whether goods are of "satisfactory quailty" and wherter an independent report is required Beeping Smoke Alarm - less than 5 years old - said it lasts 10 - Page 2 — MoneySavingExpert Forum
You'll find others from me about "satisfactory quality" too.
I often disagree with other posters on here
they often disagree with me
But if you say you are aware of, or have personal knowledge of, court cases where the decision has gone against the commonly accepted view, don't keep it a secret, please let us know what they are to everybody's benefit.
Don't go "Well I know what they are but i'm not telling you"
0 -
You were the one person I was referring to as having considered the possibility that there may be this option - I saw no others.
0 -
Does that mean I'm not a member of the clique? 😉
But yes, I have agreed all along that the single item test can be satisfied by some collective entities, the issue being the lack of any visible authoritative definition, although there's plenty of anecdotal stuff on this site and elsewhere - trouble is, it's far from unanimous when it comes to detailed criteria such as itemised invoices, individual component prices, etc.
As ever, much of the issue relates to the Act being introduced over fifty years ago, when the regulated credit agreements were generally one-off arrangements for major purchases, so it wasn't anticipated back then that it would become applicable to credit cards used routinely for anything and everything!
Incidentally, the minimum item value has been increased from the original £30 in 1974 but has been £100 since 1984, so if it had continued to rise with inflation, it ought to be in £300-350 territory by now…
1
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 356K Banking & Borrowing
- 255K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 456.3K Spending & Discounts
- 248.5K Work, Benefits & Business
- 606.2K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 179.1K Life & Family
- 264K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards
