Ready, steady… save!
You don’t need a chart to join in. Here are 2 ways to record your savings:
1. Cross it off
Pop a chart into your first post. Saved an amount? Cross it out! Read more »
£0.01 £0.02 £0.03
2. Write it down
Skip the chart and add updates to your first post. Read more »
“Another +£3 saved today. Go me!”
Use +£ before each new saving so it counts towards your total.
📨 Have you signed up to the Forum's new Email Digest yet? Get a selection of trending threads sent straight to your inbox daily, weekly or monthly!
Smart TRVs Query
Two questions, but linked.
1) we currently have 4 TRVs downstairs, all dumb. There are none upstairs. Two of the upstairs rooms are rarely used. Of the other two, one is our bedroom and the other is our son's nursery (he's 16 months old!). Overnight it can get chilly in his room so we would ideally like a Smart TRV, rather than leaving the heating high enough to tick over all night (and then our room is too warm!).
What's the best solution here? We could put smart TRVs everywhere just to keep that room warmer overnight, but that feels excessive (and expensive). Or maybe a handful of smart TRVs and the others dumb but then have the problem, presumably, that if the nursery is calling heat all the others will too unless I adjust them every night - which then is no different to the current limited-TRV world.
Thoughts welcomed...!
2) we have a Hive system. Which is unfortunate given the price of their TRVs (and other bits!). But as far as i understand those TRVs would work directly with the existing Hive hub (which currently only controls hot water and heating) without any faffing. Is anyone aware of a way to get other smart TRVs to control the (Hive) heating? I had thought that using Alexa to link things could work, but as far as I can tell from a brief search pretty much all the smart TRVs need a compatible hub (whether that's Hive, Tado, etc.).
Am I right that I could a cheaper smart setup, for example the TP Link system? That still requires a hub. But then I could presumably set a routine through Alexa where any of the TRVs calling heat would go via their own hub to Alexa which would then tell Hive to call heat? Cumbersome, but I think that would work? Or have I missed something...?
Thanks in advance
Steve
Comments
-
Stumbled across the Zigbee system. Reading through it would suggest that anything can connect to that. So to check, i think I could do something like;
- Pair Hive thermostat/heating controller with Zigbee via an app on my phone
- Install some other TRVs with a hub, then connect those to Zigbee to link everything together.
If this is right, i presume its simple enough to get a TRV in one room that needs heat to tell Hive to turn the heating on, etc.?
0 -
I think you'll always have the basic issue that, unless you fit Smart TRVs to all the working rads, or have all the non-Smart rads turned fully off, if one Smartie calls for heat, then all the non-Smart rads will also be heated.
Hive's Smart TRVs can be set to operate in two ways; the first is 'passive', so the program will make it open and close as room temp demand changes, but the boiler has to already be on. Or the other way - 'active', I guess? - is that if any Smart TRV calls for heat, it not only opens up, but also turns on the boiler.
We have one Smart Hive TRV fitted, and that's in our main bedroom. It is timed to give heat just before bedtime, and again just before wake-up. However, it's 'passive', so it rarely comes on in the eve, as the CH is usually off by then (log burner). But it always comes on in the morn, 'cos the CH is always on then too.
That's just to explain the system.
So, to heat your son's bedroom will also mean that any rad not shut off will also heat up. And that's obvs the issue you are aware of.
Short of fitting Smart TRVs to all the rads actually in use, and having the rarely-used rads manually shut off, there is no obvious solution I am aware of.
It's possible, tho', to divide the upstairs and down, by fitting motorised zone valves where the circuit splits. These could be operated by timers, so each will only be made available at set times. That means, say, the downstairs can be kept off all night, regardless of what the upstairs is doing.
Not sure that helps, as it's more intrusive to install = likely more costly.
I guess your best solution is to look for bargains on t'net for a full set of Smart TRVs, say Tado, and use AI to confirm it can be made to work alongside your Hive/boiler.
Can't remember what I paid for my Hive jobbie, but it was reasonable as a 'new-other' on eBay.
0 -
Thanks, this is broadly where i was thinking. I would be assuming they would be 'active' i.e. so triggering the low temp would then turn the valve on and tell the hub to turn the boiler on. The question is whether it needs to be only Hive TRVs that would turn the boiler on, or whether i can fudge that through a Zigbee and/or Alexa setup with some kind of IFTTT routine.
The couple of 'spare' bedrooms we tend to leave off most of the time, or with the non-TRV set low to get a smidge of heat in.
Im obviously aware black friday is rapidly approaching - presume that Hive TRVs might go on some form of sale then…
1 -
Most smart TRVs are passive, they are only opening or closing the valve on their radiator and if that does anything depends on if the boiler is on and the main thermostat set to above the temperature of where it is.
Some systems, like Hive can integrate with smart thermostat to actually turn the boiler on but for that to work seamlessly they all need to be the same system.The other option is to have something like Home Assistant running on a Raspberry Pi or Home Assistant Green which you can then programme to do what you want, so if the cheap zigbee TRV says its cold Home Assistant will tell the Thermostat to turn up the temperature.
These are an overhead to maintain plus there is no guarantee it will always work, it used to work well with Tado but they then restricted the volume of requests that can be done via the API to the extent that some say they only get an hour of control a day before their tokens are used up.
Never tried with Hive, in principle they are open to integrations, at the moment, but there are stories of it being unstable connections.
You could have non-smart TRVs in the rarely used rooms and just have them on frost protect all the time. All the others really need to be smart and Hive ideally for it to work seamlessly.
1 -
Would a (v) lowtech solution not just be an oil filled radiator with thermostat? I'm no Luddite and my poor analogue husband despairs of all the smart devices/linkage I've put in in the house (but likes coming down in the morning to a just boiled kettle!) but fitting smart TRVs and linking using any of the above methods is going to cost loads more than a decent small oil filled radiator. Plus kids rooms have to be kept between quite cool conditions anyway. If you didn't want to rely on only the radiator you could get a digital thermostat and link to a smart plug that would just turn on and off depending on the temps reached . .
I know it's not quite what you asked but unless you were going to do tons of work anyway on your heating system it will do what you need it to for now:eek::eek::eek: LBM 11/05/2010 - WE DID IT - DMP of £62000 paid off in 7 years:jDFD April20172 -
That is a very good point. By the time you've forked out £100's on Smart TRVs, that amount should pay for a few years of leccy for a winter-only oil-filled rad.
1 -
I also agree with @beckstar1975's lateral thinking.
An oil-filled radiator, perhaps with a basic timer plug, is a much more elegant solution than a complex process to fire up a gas boiler just to warm a lone radiator.
Also the surplus heat wasted when the boiler fires up and warms all the pipework then shuts down again probably costs more than the efficient energy used by the oil-filled radiator in the bedroom.
1 -
Funnily enough, the alternative option I had been considering, on the same lines, was to get an IR panel heater, something like this.
It was only on reading more about Zigbee/Home Assistant that I realised the need for a device to control it. Not scared of that, but probably makes the whole thing more complicated than its worth.
Re Alexa, the other stumbling block is that yes it is easy enough to turn up the thermostat to fire the boiler and turning it down again to turn it off, but then it loses the schedule mode. I think the easiest solution would be to start a boost for, say, 30 minutes (can already ask Alexa to do that), and then "stop boost" when the temperature is reached. At least that would keep Hive on its schedule.
But it still doesnt get away from the problem of only having a handful of TRVs.
So lets see what black friday deals appear…!
1 -
I think you may be doing the right thing - work out what you need for a complete remake of your existing system - number of Smart TRVs actually required, for example - and then explore costs for all the options. And the best deals.
Be ready to consider selling your Hive - there's a ready market for these - and going Tado or Wiser instead, if it's cheaper (or better). Tado is on its X range now, I believe - rechargeable TRVs etc.
So don't just look at Smart TRVs and how to use them alongside what you have - I fear you may regret that - but a complete change, even tho' it'll cost more.
Of course, also include the option simply buying Hive TRVs to use on your current system. Do your sums!
If you do go Smart TRV on the most commonly used rads, then you will undoubtedly save on energy costs, but it'll mainly just be sooo much simpler and nicer to use.
0 -
Funnily enough, the alternative option I had been considering, on the same lines, was to get an IR panel heater, something like this.
These look a bit neat neater than a free standing oil filled radiator, but the latter can be moved around the room which can be useful. They range from £30 to £100 and a few have wifi and can be controlled from your phone. Typically they are around 2KW maximum power, but just to keep the chill of a child's bedroom, I would have thought 1 KW or even less would be sufficient.
1
Confirm your email address to Create Threads and Reply
Categories
- All Categories
- 356K Banking & Borrowing
- 255K Reduce Debt & Boost Income
- 456.3K Spending & Discounts
- 248.5K Work, Benefits & Business
- 606.2K Mortgages, Homes & Bills
- 179.1K Life & Family
- 264K Travel & Transport
- 1.5M Hobbies & Leisure
- 16.2K Discuss & Feedback
- 37.7K Read-Only Boards